-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter HydrogenHydreigon
- Start date
I kinda of thought he was scummy like ik my reads were wrong but like I'm trying my best here. It's just the way Hal didn't post reads at first makes it odd
I just wanted to stay on that wagon since I felt like it
Sure
I'm gonna go to sleep and post results when I wake up if enough people give me the green light on this, gn
Respectfully this post is nothing lol, "since I felt like it" is not a reason
Probably a good thing to do now that you've expressed that you have useful results, but I don't know if you would've been on the radar for a nightkill before that
Yea but I just felt like it
can you elaborate more about this in general
Which part
what exactly strikes odd here? what do you expect to have happened?
"It reminds me of the first mafia game I played where I was the only 1 left" do you think you can give us a breakdown of what happened in this game beyond you being the last one left?
I mean m2h with that discussion but whoever was on that wagon was um a Lil weird. Like the first time mafia voted everyone else and it was a 1v1
Read hal's ISO & EoD2.
Neon is almost certainly town IMO, hal's CW seems like a genuine self-pres attempt and I don't see why he'd pick a partner over a townie. From past experience hal is pretty interactive with his team (pinging them, asking them to post & vote). Doubt he'll throw Neon under the bus for no reason especially when Neon is seemingly AFK.
Unless skipper drastically leveled up in the past six months I'm just going to assume he's town here. 4 quick votes on Neon and he votes hal, it's either a bizarre bussing gambit as mafia or he is town. I still only have a two year old game as my scum!skipper reference but he's typing like every town game he's played.
Joey is probably town off his vote but there was ton of traction for hal near EoD, so it's possible that scum made a last minute decision to bus for cred...I think his vote has less town cred than skipper but don't think there's reason to be paranoid of him right now.
Dunno how much I can read into Flandrs' vote, he and hal were lightly sussing each other throughout the day so he doesn't have the luxury to be flexible with his vote & support hal on a Neon CW. Haven't really looked too deep into this slot yet.
Leaning AP town, doubt his argument with hal was staged. Looking at the timestamps and how random it was, just seems like two big egos fighting against each other instead of an actual distancing attempt as partners. Like his posting too, doesn't feel like he's trying to force misvotes or pushing agendas.
wisteria is firing posts left and right, I have no meta reference for them but I instinctually lean them town over scum, will have to read more in depth later. Apparently there's some deep connection with them and NE that I have not read into yet.
hal's stance on NE is super weird, he & NE both deepwolfed the last game they played together and it almost feels like hal is fixated on distancing by referencing that game (#1711, #1683, #1341, #1031 is not about NE but about that game, etc)...he doesn't really make a firm read on NE either but defends him against pressure near EoD.
Personally think NE & Evie's claims are whatever, both claimed under pressure & the roles are hard to prove (aka potential fakeclaims). Seeing as hal was in self-pres mode, I kinda think KISS (keep it simple stupid) is the best option here and we just vote one of these two...I doubt hal told his entire team to leave him out to dry.
Neon is almost certainly town IMO, hal's CW seems like a genuine self-pres attempt and I don't see why he'd pick a partner over a townie. From past experience hal is pretty interactive with his team (pinging them, asking them to post & vote). Doubt he'll throw Neon under the bus for no reason especially when Neon is seemingly AFK.
Unless skipper drastically leveled up in the past six months I'm just going to assume he's town here. 4 quick votes on Neon and he votes hal, it's either a bizarre bussing gambit as mafia or he is town. I still only have a two year old game as my scum!skipper reference but he's typing like every town game he's played.
Joey is probably town off his vote but there was ton of traction for hal near EoD, so it's possible that scum made a last minute decision to bus for cred...I think his vote has less town cred than skipper but don't think there's reason to be paranoid of him right now.
Dunno how much I can read into Flandrs' vote, he and hal were lightly sussing each other throughout the day so he doesn't have the luxury to be flexible with his vote & support hal on a Neon CW. Haven't really looked too deep into this slot yet.
Leaning AP town, doubt his argument with hal was staged. Looking at the timestamps and how random it was, just seems like two big egos fighting against each other instead of an actual distancing attempt as partners. Like his posting too, doesn't feel like he's trying to force misvotes or pushing agendas.
wisteria is firing posts left and right, I have no meta reference for them but I instinctually lean them town over scum, will have to read more in depth later. Apparently there's some deep connection with them and NE that I have not read into yet.
hal's stance on NE is super weird, he & NE both deepwolfed the last game they played together and it almost feels like hal is fixated on distancing by referencing that game (#1711, #1683, #1341, #1031 is not about NE but about that game, etc)...he doesn't really make a firm read on NE either but defends him against pressure near EoD.
Personally think NE & Evie's claims are whatever, both claimed under pressure & the roles are hard to prove (aka potential fakeclaims). Seeing as hal was in self-pres mode, I kinda think KISS (keep it simple stupid) is the best option here and we just vote one of these two...I doubt hal told his entire team to leave him out to dry.
oh hold up did you mean "went after M2H" as in pushing him because i totally though you meant him getting nightkilled :skull:
umm it's late so that might be screwing with my reading comprehension rn but what exactly does "that wagon" refer to
and actually dym posting a link to the game you're referring to i'll read through it in the morning perhaps
the "deep connection" was that we're usually able to soulread each other quickly but atp i'm highly doubting my initial tr on him lmfao rip
Sure when I have a chance
wisteria you seem like you're up to date with everything, where's your head at right now?
After reading page 68-page 74 (EoD2), which people look good to you and which don't? There was a lot of vote movement that led to mafia being voted off so that's where I'm looking at for initial reads
Also, have you rolled mafia in a game recently?
so the following post basically summarises my thoughts for today
will note that i had a tr on your slot (CK) during day 1 but i intend to re-evaluate it to cover my bases
yeah that's where i'm at too. do you have a read on AP?