I never did. Wis and ne are fine but I don't think Flanders/ap are
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter HydrogenHydreigon
- Start date
interesting, could you explain your opinions on these four?
Who do u want me to start with
SHOOT i forgot to mention him it seems. earlier i noted that a lot of hal's posting seemed to be discrediting AP (this is actually pretty consistent from what i read in his ISO), and as we were nearing deadline d2 it seemed like he was trying to possibly wrangle a vote on AP. my thought is that in a world with scum!AP/hal idt this level of distancing is necessary considering that post-celever vote these two would have considerable pull in the thread (and hence, would not need to publicly stoke conflict between each other like that?)
there is, of course, the possibility that yeah these two are paired after all but AP on his own seems fine off of what i see so far. there is a mild annoyance that he did not respond to some of my prods but i don't think that's necessarily scum-indicative lmao
i.e. today i probably don't vote there either
NE, then Flandrs, then AP, then wisteria
is this a new development? how come you feel this way after sticking to the evie vote at eod2?
It's not new I just felt like staying on her even because on d1 she didn't have enough information but after the claim she was ok.
Ne is town I believe because he did claim and have good reads. Flanders - he felt a little strange to me but then got better. Ap - his reads were fine to me. Wis is safe because of the way she/he is contributing
I'm being honest about it
okay im getting side tracked
i guess im just like lost on why stay on the doc claim if you think its okay
but you did say why so idk if i should be rehashing it
I meant like I just felt like staying on it I could have switched if I wanted to
will ask about this tho. earlier you mention flandrs and AP not being fine to you whereas you say this here, whats up with that?
Im in the office atm now so I cant post much but I just wanted to complain about this.
Our design team uses "KISS" as their motto but they say it stands for "Keep it simple yet impactful". Their butchering of this acronym make me irrationally angry.
im a bit underwhelmed by flandrs EoD2 because he defended the two people who voted with hal and i don't have a strong opinion on his posting, but im kinda interested in his sidequest and i think he will be easier to read as the game goes on
which notable people are you waiting to hear on?
Townpool
I like wis’s content and posting style. I feel like they’ve been very contributory to the flow of the game, if that makes sense. Not in a trying to dominate the thread, just trying to solve.
I felt like AP’s alignment is pretty much cleared with the Hal flip. Him p much lone voting the past days is fine ig. I think the tone in some of his post felt very frustrated town. I don’t think that his fight with Hal was staged imo. I’ve really only seen two s/s confrontations, and they’ve both been with realiti, and they’ve felt less aggressive than AP/hal. And I feel like AP was trying to solve d2.
As much as Joey’s scumread of me during d1 and d2 bothers me, I can’t deny that he wasn’t pushing it too too hard, which I respect. I think his subsequent posts have been productive as well.
Both CK’s and realiti’s posts have felt really productive. I’m really liking realiti’s entrance and feels very town!realiti (tho I have been wrong about this!)
I was obviously against the Neon wagon. I think he’s town tired from doing the sheet. And Hal trying to set up a wagon on Neon suggest to me that neon is town
They’re not gonna get nked so let’s hope their town
DBD
pulsar
des
POE
NE
evie
Ch3m
Oh that’s a shallow pool
Well NE and Evie are obviously part of this Hal voting block, and both have conveniently claimed town roles. I’m going to reiterate that I think Evie is more likely to be scum here. NE is a more complicated bc again the pings from my last game where he was scum are not pinging rn. He could be deep wolfing better here ig. Honestly, the pings from NE (the agenda fueled posting) were kinda fulfilled by Hal, so it wouldn’t be a big surprise if that’s the reason I’m not seeing scum!NE. Ch3m is the least clear one here where some of their posts give me question marks in my head , but I can’t decipher if it’s confused town or true scum.
Considering my scumpool is so small, here’s a ranking of my confidence in my town slots
Most confident
Neon
AP
Wis
joey
Realiti
Least Confident
I like wis’s content and posting style. I feel like they’ve been very contributory to the flow of the game, if that makes sense. Not in a trying to dominate the thread, just trying to solve.
I felt like AP’s alignment is pretty much cleared with the Hal flip. Him p much lone voting the past days is fine ig. I think the tone in some of his post felt very frustrated town. I don’t think that his fight with Hal was staged imo. I’ve really only seen two s/s confrontations, and they’ve both been with realiti, and they’ve felt less aggressive than AP/hal. And I feel like AP was trying to solve d2.
As much as Joey’s scumread of me during d1 and d2 bothers me, I can’t deny that he wasn’t pushing it too too hard, which I respect. I think his subsequent posts have been productive as well.
Both CK’s and realiti’s posts have felt really productive. I’m really liking realiti’s entrance and feels very town!realiti (tho I have been wrong about this!)
I was obviously against the Neon wagon. I think he’s town tired from doing the sheet. And Hal trying to set up a wagon on Neon suggest to me that neon is town
They’re not gonna get nked so let’s hope their town
DBD
pulsar
des
POE
NE
evie
Ch3m
Oh that’s a shallow pool
Well NE and Evie are obviously part of this Hal voting block, and both have conveniently claimed town roles. I’m going to reiterate that I think Evie is more likely to be scum here. NE is a more complicated bc again the pings from my last game where he was scum are not pinging rn. He could be deep wolfing better here ig. Honestly, the pings from NE (the agenda fueled posting) were kinda fulfilled by Hal, so it wouldn’t be a big surprise if that’s the reason I’m not seeing scum!NE. Ch3m is the least clear one here where some of their posts give me question marks in my head , but I can’t decipher if it’s confused town or true scum.
Considering my scumpool is so small, here’s a ranking of my confidence in my town slots
Most confident
Neon
AP
Wis
joey
Realiti
Least Confident
I just didn't like him and ap talking about me duh
Skipper u forget to put Flanders in the list.
I do think there is some loose connection between flavor and roles. Do you think the same based on the flipped roles so far?
Probably mafia roles correlate with their flavor as well so mafia can claim their role and have it make sense from a flavor PoV.
But I assume flavor would be difficult for mafia to just make up other roles altogether
What does poe mean?