NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

ne not having contributed so far today is slightly peculiar to me, i feel like he was active in previous days

Ch3mdah said:
"useful results" is a bit of an overstatement, but oh well
n1: evie (negative)
n2: NE (negative)
Click to expand...
unrelatedly this post is very interesting to me, i feel like a new player as scum doesnt make this play
 
NightEmerald said:
I think hal is the type of player that I’m electing to trust now because they’re pushing town in a good direction, part of it is the agreeing with me, and part of it is like the deeper meta read where the expected valie of keeping them around is far greater than the alternative
Click to expand...
i think this post seems like a scumbuddy trying to incept trust in hal
apricity said:
1. Then what is Wis in all of this?
2. NE "sticks out" too much for me to like him as scum. I feel like he hid a lot in his last game in discord. I don't see that here.
3. I don't agree that he wasn't engaging today I feel like he's been relatively flexible with everything

The rest some of which I agree with, there's some other stuff that I saw that you don't have in your list (his reaction to cel claiming tracker), but all in all I lean town here primarily off prose and tone. I don't understand what Wis' alignment is if NE is scum.

I don't think I can reasonably join this wagon today.
Click to expand...
and hal consistently defends them (i can find some other posts if you like), pushing me towards a ne/hal pairing



skippergamez said:
if I’m being perfectly honest I’ve only skimmed today. I will say the Apricity vote feels really reactionary and it’s not something I want to do today at least

I do think that wis is town

Someone (I think it was Joey) asked me about when I thought NE was towny. I feel like his interactions in the thread d1 came from a town POV. Which is just saying “he’s towny cause I feel like it” but idk that’s my perspective of him.
Click to expand...
There is also this post where skipper 1. defends hal 2. and townreads ne despite glaring holes in progression that he noted earlier
 
apricity said:
I can't get to where you're at on NE. Tonally he's too different from his last game in low power where I was scum with him.

Skip I'm still reading but I can't really get to him being scum based on low power either.
Click to expand...
this once again shows the trio of hal/ne/skip + “tonally” is a very fakeable reason to tr someone

apricity said:
I suppose I'll leave partial thoughts on NE and AP.

These thoughts won't result in a read but you'll get a sense of the things I'm seeing that I'm not loving. They're also not complete -- there's other stuff that I'm looking at which I don't want to share right now.

NE is an odd slot right now because you have:
-Hard defended by wist
-Hard defends wist
-main cw on day 1, and i guess the fairy kill, if you are reading into that
-in a weird spot threadwise where I really think a lot of people have been avoiding the slot entirely

1. The defense on wist feels know-y and pocket-y. This is like the biggest one for me. I get that he thinks he has a soulread on someone -- but in thread it just constantly feels like he's lovebombing wist into reciprocating and it just comes off so hard when it's not necessary at all. Nobody's running up wist outside of AP
2. He is actually like the weirdest slot in the game in terms of interactions. like it really feels like nobody is willing to come out and just talk about NE
3. I was actively rethinking Cel's alignment (obviously ultimately came to the wrong conclusion) after tracker claim + self vote. While I think NE just fucked off and found, like, literally one random turbo game between him and wist which he used as justification for having a soulread on wist? Which is unsatisfactory not only as a participant on the wagon but also is kind of a bad way to justify having a soulread on wist through, legitimately, one turbo game?

How many games have you played together? How many times have you been t/t, t/s, s/t, s/s? Do turbo games even count I don't really play them and I don't think so?
4. I find his ISO's completely ineffective. This ISO from skipper is actually very bad. Has anyone actually read it? And if the analysis is so bad here, why is there so much confidence in his wist vote?

All this being said, and the feeling that something could be here, I think this is completely outweighed by the fact that my last game with NE he was scum (albeit in exam season) and that looked completely different from what's here. While in exam season and scum he was checking on the thread when he had time, and not posting because he wanted to prep like large posts. And here even though he obviously has some personal problem with stardew valley or whatever the fuck, he's just constantly popping into thread yapping about random shit

Which feels tonally very different from his scumgame. But then I don't like the random shit he yaps about. So this is a rough slot for me to sort.

AP scumreading NE is like legitimately a top reason that I'm keeping NE in my townlists
Click to expand...
this is a very interesting post cause he expresses valid reasons to scumread ne but then once again trs him because his game looks different to hal’s previous scum game with him. Last line is also even more interesting after hal’s flip.
 
looking at the NE wall from hal and
apricity said:
2. He is actually like the weirdest slot in the game in terms of interactions. like it really feels like nobody is willing to come out and just talk about NE
Click to expand...
is this true i feel like people were discussing NE

hal made a similar claim about AP later on in the same wall
apricity said:
I think he's probably second to NE for having weird interactions with others because it feels like his reads are so disconnected from the rest of the thread but somehow nobody feels like they are pushing him on it? Outside of wist?
Click to expand...
so i guess i can draw parallels but at the same time it might be an effort to "shield" NE

idk maybe evie and NE are both town in which case im fucking washed (known fact)
 
HydrogenHydreigon said:
JALMONT will be subbing in for Dead by Daylight.

Due to the fact that this sub occurred relatively late in the cycle, I will be holding a vote on an extension.
React with Like for no extension.
React with Love for a 12 hour extension.
React with Haha for a 24 hour extension.
If extensions of another length are proposed and agreed upon they will also be considered.
Apologies for the inconvenience and thank you for your understanding
Click to expand...
Hello Jalmont I am drowning
 
wisteriapurple said:
so you can see the hal/evie and hal/NE voting blocks i mentioned in the other wall (highlighted them in purple anyway in this post)
in fact NE and hal voted together on AP briefly as well, until NE shifted away to evie before votecount 2.3 was posted
NE's vote
hal's vote
Click to expand...
Okay wait yeah those two are constantly following apricity on votes and shit.

it's like they're in some king of...
scumchat.

(This totally isn't just omgus trust me)
 
wisteriapurple said:
i also had a rolling VCA going on
#117 votecount 1.1
des121 (1): AngryPidgeon
a fairy (1): joey
AngryPidgeon (1): StupidFlandrs48
NightEmerald (1): wisteriapurple

#493 votecount 1.2
a fairy (2): joey, skippergamez
StupidFlandrs48 (2): wisteriapurple, realiti
des121 (2): AngryPidgeon, NightEmerald
AngryPidgeon (1): ImaginaryNeon
Celever (1): StupidFlandrs48
NightEmerald (1): pulsar512b

#603 votecount 1.3
NightEmerald (2): pulsar512b, ImaginaryNeon
a fairy (2): skippergamez, realiti
des121 (1): NightEmerald
Celever (1): StupidFlandrs48
wisteriapurple (1): AngryPidgeon
Evie (1): Celever

#821 votecount 1.4
Celever (6): StupidFlandrs48, apricity, NightEmerald, Evie, Celever, realiti
NightEmerald (2): pulsar512b, ImaginaryNeon
a fairy (1): skippergamez
wisteriapurple (1): AngryPidgeon
Evie (1): Dead By Daylight
skippergamez (1): joey

#838 votecount 1.5
Celever (5): apricity, NightEmerald, Evie, Celever, realiti
NightEmerald (2): pulsar512b, ImaginaryNeon
Evie (2): Dead By Daylight, skippergamez
wisteriapurple (1): AngryPidgeon
skippergamez (1): joey

#950 votecount 1.6 (final)
Celever (7): apricity, NightEmerald, Evie, Celever, realiti, wisteriapurple, M2H
NightEmerald (5): pulsar512b, ImaginaryNeon, joey, a fairy, StupidFlandrs48
Evie (2): Dead By Daylight, skippergamez
No Vote (1): Ch3mdah
Ch3mdah (1): AngryPidgeon
#1115 votecount 2.1
apricity (3): M2H, AngryPidgeon, ImaginaryNeon

#1352 votecount 2.2
apricity (3): M2H, AngryPidgeon, ImaginaryNeon
NightEmerald (1): joey

#1642 votecount 2.3
Evie (3): NightEmerald, des121, AngryPidgeon
apricity (2): ImaginaryNeon, M2H
AngryPidgeon (1): apricity
NightEmerald (1): joey

#1865 votecount 2.4 (final)
apricity (5): ImaginaryNeon, StupidFlandrs48, skippergamez, M2H, joey
ImaginaryNeon (3): apricity, Evie, NightEmerald
Evie (2): des121, AngryPidgeon
just changed all mentions of CK to realiti :blobthumbsup:
Click to expand...
Also I'm using the vc numbers from this to try and find those two's votes on me because vanity
 
DBD x random inmate yaoi
1001647819.jpg
 
Evie said:
yeah you're right this does feel super performative

##VOTE: Celever

I will not be around for deadline unfortunately so if you need anything from me speak now or hold your peace
Click to expand...
so you knew you weren't going to be on at deadline, saw someone claim tracker, and decided that was best place to leave your vote?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top