i mean like yeah but scum could have absolutely bussed hal even if it is a risky play, i dont think its worth completely clearing anyone who voted hal
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter HydrogenHydreigon
- Start date
yes. i think its reasonable for both scum to come up with and for town to be given , im not reading into his claim too much
ill have to relook at the wagonomics to see if ne/skip/hal is a viable scumteam but from interactions it seems likely
okay its perfectly reasonable for skip to either vote hal at the end of the day expecting him to not get voted out or bus him to gain towncred, or to not seem too closely paired with ne and hal. I dont think skip is the vote for now but worth considering for later days, especially if ne flips scum
that's hal see the undercase I understand why what I wrote is confusing though
okay, so that means you think skip bussed Hal or at least it's a possibility. let's look at that
the wagon was 4-2 neon when skip voted hal. do you think it's a good mafia strategy to vote your teammate and get closer to a tie vote when there's two minutes to deadline? what's the going to accomplish? okay maybe now skip looks better when town neon flips. but now you when the risk of Hal, who is probably one of the better players on the mafia team dying which then just happened.
it's an extremely risky vote. would you make the same play in that situation? I'm guessing you probably wouldn't. I personally would not. I might do it if neon was my teammate. but not with apricity/hal.
oh right that makes more sense
youre right, i probably wouldnt make that play. that doesnt mean skip isnt willing to though. it gives him an immense amount of towncred because bussing hal is such a dangerous play
in my one scumgame (which my iso is so cringe I wanna cry), I never voted for either of my partners once. Even when one of them was exposed to have fakeclaimed
even if skip had the guts to bus hal, i'm not sure if hal would allow that
Just saying ne did almost claim
Didn’t want to vote out Hal but was around at deadline and did nothing to stop that result. Interesting
You were so certain day 1 NE was town that you preferred to vote the claimed tracker and now you’ve backtracked on that. Hmm
Why do you think skip would make that play? If it’s such a strong play, why wouldn’t you make it?
Can you explain the pulsar read. I can’t remember any progression she’s had
mind still sleepy negl
like atp i see NE and hal voting together on cel day 1, NE and hal briefly voting together on AP as i noted in #1909 + voting together on neon day 2, and then i see the weird stance hal took on NE (see: #1341 in which he lists 4 reasons for a NE scumcase only to note that he tls NE solely because of AP scumming him + tone, and then in #1683 and #1711 his read on NE is more of a tr now)
though it's also that i want to prioritise resolving in evie and NE because both of them have partner equity with hal
i'd jump at the chance if we could chop both but atm i find myself leaning NE bc
1) evie is a claimed doc and i legitimately would crash out if the claim is legit and we misvote her
2) NE's disappearance rn alarms me bc it reminds me of the times i've seen scum dip from thread when there's high pressure on them so as to minimise spew
will admit point 2 is somewhat dubious because it could be due to oog circumstances but im still concerned regardless. idk i still want to hear from him that's why i've been masspinging him NightEmerald
yeah at the time i had him tentatively as a tl bc i did like some of the questions he posed, and i didn't rly want a repeat of the cel vote. however the neon counterwagon cropped up and prior to that i had neon down as towny, so i did not really want to vote him either. ultimately i wouldve made a decision much closer to dl but joey shifted plur to hal regardless
re: this i thought i had a decent enough meta read on NE but even post-cel vote i had been starting to re-evaluate it; hal flipping red definitely threw me for a loop and it caused me to expedite this
like atp i see NE and hal voting together on cel day 1, NE and hal briefly voting together on AP as i noted in #1909 + voting together on neon day 2, and then i see the weird stance hal took on NE (see: #1341 in which he lists 4 reasons for a NE scumcase only to note that he tls NE solely because of AP scumming him + tone, and then in #1683 and #1711 his read on NE is more of a tr now)
definitely a very low level read but she's been consistent with wanting NE out and in retrospect her posting has been pinging townie
though it's also that i want to prioritise resolving in evie and NE because both of them have partner equity with hal
i'd jump at the chance if we could chop both but atm i find myself leaning NE bc
1) evie is a claimed doc and i legitimately would crash out if the claim is legit and we misvote her
2) NE's disappearance rn alarms me bc it reminds me of the times i've seen scum dip from thread when there's high pressure on them so as to minimise spew
will admit point 2 is somewhat dubious because it could be due to oog circumstances but im still concerned regardless. idk i still want to hear from him that's why i've been masspinging him NightEmerald
there's a real chance i'm being too tunnel-visioned atm but i'm hitting walls