NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

Ch3mdah said:
there's a chance that evie and NE are both town, but to me that seems extremely unlikely, chances are one, if not both of them are scum. the fact that NE and evie both voted with hal is an indicator that they're both scum, but if i had to choose one i'd rather go for NE of the two from the risk involved with voting a doc claim, but evie could be lying about that, not to mention how a non killing scum role completely counters evie, and that scum targeted m2h instead of the doc claim n2. on the other hand, NE claims that his role gains 0.5 votes if he guesses the number of failed actions during the night? Me personally, looking at my own role that seems off to me. and about my results, it's sorta NAI since I could get negative or positive from both town and scum, it's kinda like the investigator from ToS1, except it separates roles into two groups instead of 11.
Click to expand...
If you're gonna give this much in terms of hints about your role then you might as well just formally claim at this point. Does your role, in your opinion, feel incompatible with town!NE's claim or not? Also, at this current moment, do you or do you not believe Evie's claim?
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
If you're gonna give this much in terms of hints about your role then you might as well just formally claim at this point. Does your role, in your opinion, feel incompatible with town!NE's claim or not? Also, at this current moment, do you or do you not believe Evie's claim?
Click to expand...
i feel like just from flips if nothing else ne's claim feels. odd?
 
like surely you would not put it in the same game as a tracker right. i guess maybe im wrong and insane or something? like i feel like if you have someone like this and a tracker in the same game the conditional half mayor should be pissed asf at getting a dogshit role right
 
pulsar512b said:
like surely you would not put it in the same game as a tracker right. i guess maybe im wrong and insane or something? like i feel like if you have someone like this and a tracker in the same game the conditional half mayor should be pissed asf at getting a dogshit role right
Click to expand...
vote now on your phones is conditional half mayor or 4 shot commuter better
 
pulsar512b said:
like surely you would not put it in the same game as a tracker right. i guess maybe im wrong and insane or something? like i feel like if you have someone like this and a tracker in the same game the conditional half mayor should be pissed asf at getting a dogshit role right
Click to expand...
In fairness it's a 17p role madness game, some roles are gonna be dogshit. Just take it from me, the designer of our last closed setup role madness!

Speaking of which, Hydro was one of the key p[ayers in Lumiose so I really wouldn't put it past him to get cheeky with weird inclusions like that after being exposed to it in another game.
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
If you're gonna give this much in terms of hints about your role then you might as well just formally claim at this point. Does your role, in your opinion, feel incompatible with town!NE's claim or not? Also, at this current moment, do you or do you not believe Evie's claim?
Click to expand...
imo, my role's more compatible with town!NE, yet again, the support this gives to NE is flimsy, if you REALLY want me to formally claim I can do that. onto believing evie's claim, I do believe it, then again I could easily see evie being scum for the reasons in my last post
 
Well on second thought maybe they're both true but one of them is a scum role

It just would not make sense to have town roles that have essentially the same function but at different power levels
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
What do you think could be the other half of that? If you're gonna tinfoil ya might as well fully commit to the bit :mad:
Click to expand...
maybe if he gets another thing right ("x-shots used"? "number of people targeting the most popular person"? "number of people targeting you"? "number of roles used"?) he gets an NK? and so far hes just done a bad job guessing.
 
Votecount 3.3
NightEmerald (4): realiti, Evie, skippergamez, ImaginaryNeon
skippergamez (2): StupidFlandrs48, des121
realiti (1): NightEmerald
des121 (1): AngryPidgeon

As a remind deadline has been extented 24 hours!
Ping me for mistakes
 
Ch3mdah said:
onto believing evie's claim, I do believe it, then again I could easily see evie being scum for the reasons in my last post
Click to expand...
Flandrs is saying that chemdah is being ambivalent about his Evie read.
Chemdah believes Evie is mafia but he also apparently believe the Doctor claim is real.
So Chemdah believes that Evie is a mafia doctor?
I mean its not the most outlandish thought.
When I design setups I like to do things like give Mafia Cops and Town Rolecops just to subvert expectations. This is a role madness game and a doctor may be a somewhat useful scum role because it looks town to some investigative roles, and there _could_ be a SK or Vig in the game.
 
Ch3mdah said:
there's a chance that evie and NE are both town, but to me that seems extremely unlikely, chances are one, if not both of them are scum.
Click to expand...
This could be seen as hedgy too. It feels weird because Chemdah starts by saying they Evie/NE might be town, but odds are both are scum, which is a pretty hard read and hes suggesting its based on his role results, although tbh that part is unclear. I agree with Flandrs you may as well claim now. Because what I understand from your post is that you have role related reasons for believing Des and NE arent town.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top