NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

NightEmerald said:
anyway

People that are 100% unquestionably town:
joey, flandrs, jalmont

AP>wis I want to be checked on the fact that compared to d1 and d2, d3 wis feels like theyve made significantly less progress

The blob of people that frankly give me next to nothing in terms of actual reads
skipper
neon
chem
evie
des
pulsar

I think they're scum:
realiti
Click to expand...
I switched off of NE because of this post, which at the time I absolutely could not see being from mafia

But seeing as it did work out wonderfully if he theoretically is mafia I don't really know

But it would've been an absolutely killer play
 
realiti said:
I guess Evie wasn't the worst vote but the rationale for switching off NE because his wagon was stagnant made no sense.
Click to expand...
Evie would have been a liability for mafia to leave alive. So frankly we should have just voted NE. Hindsight is 20/20. But Evie did feel like everyone's second favorite read so it sort of made sense how we got there.
 
joey said:
I switched off of NE because of this post, which at the time I absolutely could not see being from mafia

But seeing as it did work out wonderfully if he theoretically is mafia I don't really know

But it would've been an absolutely killer play
Click to expand...
i personally dont see how that post is indicative of alignment. flandrs moving off NE because he was "threadspewed" was just weird, as well as frankly everybody else on that wagon popping out of nowhere to vote evie
 
I know I said yesterday that Flandrs/NE/Chemdah was a meme team but I could actually see something like this. I think its weird that the Chemdah wagon never materialized as the CW. There has to be at minimum 1 mafia on the Evie wagon.
 
realiti said:
Not sure why you're basing your scumteam around a doctor claim, explain? And you think NE is town?
Click to expand...
Well now we know for certain that Evie protected M2H on N2. But mafia was apparently able to target M2H with another action to prevent the doctor. Unless its complete coincidence that mafia targeted M2H for a kill and happened to get lucky with Evie's protect.

I think you'll hate this but I feel like in a way we've gone all in on NE being town and if hes mafia then GG. I think he could be mafia. The EoD bit but without the self-vote is WIFOMy. His refusal to vote a CW is frankly suboptimal play regardless of alignment. I think NE makes sense as an Apricity partner and the pro-town vote would likely to have been to resolve his slot yesterday. Cause if he is town here he will be a distraction and he has enormous pairing information at associated with him at this point.
 
AngryPidgeon said:
Well now we know for certain that Evie protected M2H on N2. But mafia was apparently able to target M2H with another action to prevent the doctor. Unless its complete coincidence that mafia targeted M2H for a kill and happened to get lucky with Evie's protect.

I think you'll hate this but I feel like in a way we've gone all in on NE being town and if hes mafia then GG. I think he could be mafia. The EoD bit but without the self-vote is WIFOMy. His refusal to vote a CW is frankly suboptimal play regardless of alignment. I think NE makes sense as an Apricity partner and the pro-town vote would likely to have been to resolve his slot yesterday. Cause if he is town here he will be a distraction and he has enormous pairing information at associated with him at this point.
Click to expand...
my thoughts exactly i am a distraction to town and I shouldve died because d3 was mostly just spent on me and if d4 is the same we're basically lost
 
HydrogenHydreigon said:
Evie (6): StupidFlandrs48, wisteriapurple, joey, AngryPidgeon, pulsar512b, Ch3mdah
NightEmerald (5): realiti, Evie, skippergamez, ImaginaryNeon, des121
realiti (2): NightEmerald, JALMONT
Click to expand...
Im still inclined to think NE/flandrs is a bit on the nose but its possible flandrs as mafia led a CW onto town just to leave NE around for the next day. And if NE flips town, then Flandrs looks protown for leading a CW anyways. Im not sure if he actually expected the Evie wagon to go through.

Chemdah would make sense as an NE partner and tbh Joey does too. Im sure joey will say from his PoV I make sense as an NE partner. But if NE is mafia then I'd bet 2 on the Evie wagon.
 
realiti said:
as well as frankly everybody else on that wagon popping out of nowhere to vote evie
Click to expand...
Im pretty sure Des listed Evie as scum and I know Skipper scumread her too. Evie felt like mafia cause she failed to protect M2H on N2 and she was like everyone's 'maybe' pile which felt like she was being allowed to slide by. It was my read that she fit on a number of teams of people based on everyone scumreading her but votes never any vote materializing all day.
 
Helloooo

Unfortunate but I think this is still a net positive for town tbh, these flips are a lot of good info + Evie was gonna be dead + removing a sub from the PoE helps with game health. Leaning towards a skipper/NE or bluedoom/???(maybe joey or realiti) team in the remaining slots.
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
Helloooo

Unfortunate but I think this is still a net positive for town tbh, these flips are a lot of good info + Evie was gonna be dead + removing a sub from the PoE helps with game health. Leaning towards a skipper/NE or bluedoom/???(maybe joey or realiti) team in the remaining slots.
Click to expand...
Flanders I answered your previous question for me
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top