The post says you see no way he can be mafia basically? So you want to shoot town?
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Popcorn Mafia 4 - Cycle 5 Deadline August 27 at 10PM EDT
- Thread starter Aura Guardian
- Start date
The post says you see no way he can be mafia basically? So you want to shoot town?
Idk maybe I’m being overly harsh I think you’re viewing the game as like “clever is scumread we have to vote him”
If you’re unsure of celevers alignment, or you thinks he’s mafia sure but he’s one of your top townreads, you say there’s no way he can be mafia essentially
So you are openly claiming to be playing to mafias wincon, do I think it’s a slip? It feels too obvious, but that’s really not how town should be acting. If you truly believe with all your heart someone is town, you should never be shooting them, if you go after someone you think is certainly town, you are essentially playing to mafias wincon and are an extra team member for them
Now is celever the worst kill? No but I think he’s a bad one personally but this is outside the point, you should never be hunting down your top townreads just because someone else is telling you to do so, it’s mafias job to convince you to do that, as town, it’s your job to stop this happening
If you’re unsure of celevers alignment, or you thinks he’s mafia sure but he’s one of your top townreads, you say there’s no way he can be mafia essentially
So you are openly claiming to be playing to mafias wincon, do I think it’s a slip? It feels too obvious, but that’s really not how town should be acting. If you truly believe with all your heart someone is town, you should never be shooting them, if you go after someone you think is certainly town, you are essentially playing to mafias wincon and are an extra team member for them
Now is celever the worst kill? No but I think he’s a bad one personally but this is outside the point, you should never be hunting down your top townreads just because someone else is telling you to do so, it’s mafias job to convince you to do that, as town, it’s your job to stop this happening
Which opinion?
Right now I want to shoot skipper and Flanders and then shoot Joey and then maybe shoot celever and I'm not following the DBD scum reads because I liked the analysis of their "content blob" post but I don't feel strongly about them one way or the other, I generally agree with the idea that the Mafia is more among the inexperienced players, in particular I think I would have come under a lot more fire and disagreement if e.g. a Tommy led scum team was trying to coordinate
a fairy low key reading like a maf offended they're getting scum read for something they don't deserve to be scum read for
where you liked dbd’s wallpost d1 and thought it wasn’t just a content blob
In general my current zen on mafia is to trust my instincts on certain posts that catch my attention and ignore 90% of the thread as largely impossible for me to meaningfully derive distinct alignment indicative impressions so my reads based on that are pretty static and my reads based on vibes e.g. tommy (I think town) and celever (I probably shoot eventually but weight more likely to the town side) can shift
DBD in particular made one post I think is difficult to fake as scum and I've skimmed p much everything else they've posted
DBD in particular made one post I think is difficult to fake as scum and I've skimmed p much everything else they've posted
I’m really struggling on bluedoom because he has a lot of emotion which should be readable I’m pretty sure he’s exactly in
1) doomed mafia team
2) just genuinely tilted town
Because he’s like actually pissed, and tbf I was pissed the entire night phase too but I would say normally he’s a player who can bounce back
Either way I do genuinely think something in the game has him tilted lmao
1) doomed mafia team
2) just genuinely tilted town
Because he’s like actually pissed, and tbf I was pissed the entire night phase too but I would say normally he’s a player who can bounce back
Either way I do genuinely think something in the game has him tilted lmao
Went back and re-read this and it's much less in depth than I thought it was, I no longer think that post is difficult to fake.
Cont not blobs confirmed?
Content blobby yes. He had a couple of person grouping reads he listed that I think are interesting if he were to flip red
Gotta move you out of the towncore now, you have 0 reasoning on almost all these slots
Im asking you to live a little. I feel like none of the people I mentioned (you, airc, des, skipper) have given any unsafe opinions. Do you actually scum Celever?
Especially the other 3 though, Id like to see actually reasoned opinions or minimum containing conviction opinions.
Nah I think clever is town, even more now because after I started town reading him more he scumread me for horrible reasons which idt he does if he feels he can align with me
Evie how much mafia have you played out of curiosity?
these are all the games ive played ^