Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

[Tommy]

listen i put out a comment about the structure and you gave your thoughts i think actually im off the hook here

You’re off the hook here’s your posted pass

 

[a fairy]

wearing it like a badge proudly. ive scribbled on it "contributed to a d1"

 

[Tommy]

this could be a tommy posts an anti mafia post then says mafia would never post that

Yeah but I’m gonna get scumread no matter what I do so there’s no gain to me posting an anti mafia post I might as well mafia side publicly at that point!

 

[genisu]

Yeah but I’m gonna get scumread no matter what I do so there’s no gain to me posting an anti mafia post I might as well mafia side publicly at that point!

why would you get scumread no matter what

 

[Tommy]

why would you get scumread no matter what

I am scumread every game on the premise that I’m the GOAT

 

[joey]

wdyt abt the tommy posts

Generally positive. It's true that it would be a bit silly to post that as mafia. But Tommy also just likes to discuss mafia philosophy in general and it's not like saying that automatically does any real harm to mafia. Werewolf on the mind could easily be a Werewolf post as well but it's no more wolfy than it is towny.

 

[joey]

To give a read I'd say 20% chance Tommy is mafia, 6.7% chance Tommy is 3p and 73.3% chance Tommy is town

 

[a fairy]

can you show your work

 

[joey]

can you show your work

vibes

 

[a fairy]

half credit

 

[thechickening]

the numbers make me giggle. anyways, i will be alive closer to 7 pm eastern when i get off work but i am not afk i promise WLDHSJDS

 

[ItsScaryCary]

To give a read I'd say 20% chance Tommy is mafia, 6.7% chance Tommy is 3p and 73.3% chance Tommy is town

everyone is mafia unless they say otherwise

 

[phoopes]

if people actually afk I will tilt off the planet given ne already gave a chance with the rerand btw

For what it’s worth despite the tag I didn’t get a notification so that could be happening with some other folks too

But I’m here now!

 

[genisu]

phoopes ItsScaryCary id like to know if u 2 have any thoughts on the setup

 

[genisu]

i forgot smogon policy on using outside stuff to try to spew, may i take an attempt?

 

[a fairy]

Celever or joey can correct me but i dont think there's anything explicitly prohibiting it but like, i dunno, making decisions based on information you have from a private discord where you see someone chatty but they arent active in thread, or based on someone tweeting "sick!! cant even look at a screen" without it being common thread knowledge feels a bit unenjoyable to me. ik i avoid that stuff personally

 

[genisu]

hmm ill keep this knowledge to myself for now

 

[Tommy]

For what it’s worth despite the tag I didn’t get a notification so that could be happening with some other folks too

But I’m here now!

It’s because non badged members can only tag 10 max per post

 

[a fairy]

ill get that fixed for future games i think

 

[a fairy]

i got that fixed for future games everyone thank (but do not ping) kalalokki

 

[Ehmcee]

So like how much of this course is participation marks

 

[Tommy]

genisu if something is borderline it’s best to either stay on the side of caution or to ask the host imo

The answer is some things are fine and some aren’t like if you see someone viewing on old mafia thread then that’s fine if you see someone posting in discord then probably not

 

[Tommy]

Unless it’s in a mafia server you share in which case please go ahead!!

 

[Tommy]

vote pulsar

Will park here till we get satisfying game talk

 

[genisu]

Unless it’s in a mafia server you share in which case please go ahead!!

i think its not a great way to play this game, ill save it for when town needs it(dont need to put a target on someones back either)