• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Every game I’ve ever checked is balanced I’m the goat

Can’t even remember which setup you’re talking about though

Anyways said it a few times the game is less balanced because the third party, or feels so it’s not like the worst setup it’s just a werewolf extra night kill existing not on a set team completely swings for or against your team depending where it’s shooting

I think the game just feels infinitely worse for you as mafia because the double red check cop, and like look alignment cop is on record as one of my least favourite noc roles but it’s obviously one of the most popular in the wider mafia community

So idt the game is disapprove worthy just because an alignment cop exists, but the amount protectives is a lot but the werewolf is also giga strong role wise as a non towny entity
 
Tommy said:
Every game I’ve ever checked is balanced I’m the goat

Can’t even remember which setup you’re talking about though

Anyways said it a few times the game is less balanced because the third party, or feels so it’s not like the worst setup it’s just a werewolf extra night kill existing not on a set team completely swings for or against your team depending where it’s shooting

I think the game just feels infinitely worse for you as mafia because the double red check cop, and like look alignment cop is on record as one of my least favourite noc roles but it’s obviously one of the most popular in the wider mafia community

So idt the game is disapprove worthy just because an alignment cop exists, but the amount protectives is a lot but the werewolf is also giga strong role wise as a non towny entity
Click to expand...
I vaguely remember sending it to you like "sanity check this am I wrong for thinking it's not balanced" and you said something along the lines of "I'm drunk but p sure it's good I'll go stamp it" so maybe sober Tommy should check it again hahahaha :wo:
 
anyway I'm done doomering about the setup I approved myself I am mostly mad at myself but the responsible thing isn't to then flood the game with that self-annoyance

just hope Emerald turns hammer on lets have a lil speedrun

you should all be working out the werewolf is it's a free solve so yk
 
also Evie I'd actually prefer to get voted out I don't enjoy being in unwinnable positions

your logic is good I'm just not cringe enough to vote for myself and believe we've already lost so who has what role is irrelevant to me (I also frankly don't remember cos we sub actions as a team LOL!)
 
That’s defeats the point and fun if the setup to the point where it’s like why are you even doing this

Cop setups are something people enjoy it’s fine to have a cop even if it’s not your favourite

I’ve said already but having 3 people being balanced to share a wincon means the existing town and mafia have their win chance shrunk so if you want to immediately get a town vs mafia feel where it’s 50/50 or close you must remove the third party, if you’re unwilling to do that you just accept everyone’s chances are smaller to win
 
Honestly if your third manager came out as cop I might’ve believed the cc

The double red check on towny players was out playable imo, especially a fairy was so giga towny

Another town vote today could push you to mylo situations and phoopes was very cc-able I feel but shrug
 
Broke: The game is rigged in town’s favor
Woke: phoopes is just the GOAT
Bespoke:
1760617955459.jpeg
 
phoopes said:
but also in part because hal (I think it was hal) said he was playing a shitty game, and hal was actually one of my number one town reads so I trusted his vibes and it worked out.
Click to expand...
Hal only said that cos he was lashing out about him being wrong about Evie and me being right

Which TBC would have happened either way there was nothing too knowing going on wrt Evie she just didn’t do anything scummy LOL hal was just organically wrong

Optimal scum strat would’ve been to pile onto Evie but there was no justifiable reason to do that, I tried to come up with one

This hasn’t improved my health :psysad:
 
phoopes said:
Broke: The game is rigged in town’s favor
Woke: phoopes is just the GOAT
Bespoke:
View attachment 779783
Click to expand...
It’s really a postgame discussion but this is legit a bad setup I think, but I’m also trying to be careful not to discredit you you are the GOAT

Tommy’s right that trying to add a werewolf to classic when expanding player size is the fundamental mistake, but the execution is flawed beyond that lol

Again though Emerald didn’t make the setup, whoever on showdown did deserves the wrath
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top