Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

[apricity]

We can’t even annoy the werewolf, who we easily identified D1. Can’t kill or hook them, nor anything else.

This doesn’t read like someone who shot the werewolf

 

[Tommy]

Shoutout to phoopes and Evie btw they are newer players and last game were both mafia and played really well got to f5 and this game both playing enjoyable and strong games for town

Smogmaf future could be looking bright once we fix our activity issues

 

[Tommy]

I don’t even know what to do right now actually

Is hammer on?

It seems no but we should probably hopefully hammer if ne lets us

 

[Tommy]

is it BM if I confirm whether we shot the werewolf or not

No it’s a negotiation kingmaker game now it’s part of your wincon how you play around other alignments, they aren’t your teammate

 

[Tommy]

This doesn’t read like someone who shot the werewolf

They shoot werewolf so the kill fails, they can shoot the werewolf it just doesn’t do anything is how I’m reading it

Thus they shot werewolf and they lived?

 

[joey]

This doesn’t read like someone who shot the werewolf

The only advantage mafia has to figuring out who werewolf is on day 1 is that they know 2 extra players who aren't, I don't know what Celever was getting at but I find it hard to believe they would know with that level of confidence who the werewolf was

 

[apricity]

I don’t actually understand how the numbers work here

I guess we’re kind of hoping we flip mafia hook today right because then they’re stuck between hooking cop and RB?

 

[Tommy]

Or maybe they just role copped the werewolf true

 

[Tommy]

I don’t actually understand how the numbers work here

I guess we’re kind of hoping we flip mafia hook today right because then they’re stuck between hooking cop and RB?

If werewolf shoots town twice and mafia shoots down twice we go to 2-1-1

 

[joey]

Mafia has a role cop????

 

[apricity]

The only advantage mafia has to figuring out who werewolf is on day 1 is that they know 2 extra players who aren't, I don't know what Celever was getting at but I find it hard to believe they would know with that level of confidence who the werewolf was

To be fair sometimes celever just says things

Maybe he doesnt know

 

[joey]

a fairy is going to crucify me for this one I promise I did read the setup

 

[a fairy]

good morning

 

[Tommy]

Tomorrow if clever is alive then he is actually forced to push werewolf to have a chance at winning interestingly, so optimal maida play will involve trying to win town votes over while being open mafia


Rare scenario

 

[a fairy]

no i am past crucifying i have entered a state of nirvana and peace beyond anything. this game cannot affect me, it is a fiction of the mind.

 

[Celever]

No it’s a negotiation kingmaker game now it’s part of your wincon how you play around other alignments, they aren’t your teammate

ok well we didn't bc we're not dumb and we worked out who the werewolf is D1

we copped em N1 to confirm and were correct

I assume the werewolf shot hal

 

[Tommy]

Everyone thought I was the werewolf! So can’t be that obvious!

 

[Tommy]

ok well we didn't bc we're not dumb and we worked out who the werewolf is D1

we copped em N1 to confirm and were correct

I assume the werewolf shot hal

YOU shot chickening?

 

[Tommy]

Tbf idk why I’m believing what you say

 

[joey]

I don't think genisu would ever be wrong about something...

 

[Celever]

Everyone thought I was the werewolf! So can’t be that obvious!

we didn't think you were the werewolf!

didn't even come up in our discussions

I had it down to either the werewolf or DBD and a fairy tiebroke in favour of the werewolf bc we are GOAT solvers

 

[a fairy]

im so cool

 

[Tommy]

Like if I was werewolf here you actually probably do just shoot the surviving mafia player because it removes the chance of mafia opening your name publicly

 

[Celever]

YOU shot chickening?

yeah sorry fren

your mafia team is 2 mods we're not gonna kill a Tommy or hal to save afks are we

 

[a fairy]

right but with three mafia at least one of em makes it to tomorrow