• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
realiti said:
bluedoom can u read d1 and d2 and give your reads before reading d3
Click to expand...
ngl I hate that you made me read 50 pages (D2 is the worst):

Tommy is straight up town, he doesn't seem to be playing any differently from the previous game, feel like the defeatism shown early in the game thinking it would end up as another town loss due to inactivity checks out with how he usually feels as town.

I think genisu is to- oh he died.

I keep reading through most of pages 30-40 and see discussion between Tommy and Hal which makes me wonder who tf had thread presence.

I want to say that the DbD wagon looking at page 50 looks bad; I'd think that at least one of phoopes/airC is mafia here.

There is the wagon on my slot but Idk what to make of it because I would totally believe cary getting wagoned for trolling the game, he did it in our last oc too. I kinda feel like its scummy on principle though because my slot would've been an easy misvote.
 
Tommy said:
Yeah I understand but curious WHY you think or if there’s any consideration, I’d you’re just confident it’s absolutely those 2 as final two then chill but confirming since I had doubts about bluedoom personally
Click to expand...
AirC I'm most confident on because the post where they were like "I will shoot confirmed town" is TOO evil/no way that was coached or whatever, so I ultimately think it's frustrated/inexperienced town. As for the others...

As for the others, I essentially agree with hal's analysis in 1983.
apricity said:
This one drives me crazy. Realiti really pushing for it to not be joey genuinely makes me think it's joey ww/realiti scum because for WHATEVER REASON mafia don't want to go into 3-1MYLO so the 3rd scum is probably trying to make that happen
Click to expand...
This makes the most sense to me too.

Since I'm confident on AirC being town, and am most convinced on joey WW and realiti third maf, that leaves Tommy and bluedoom as town. I'm more confident on bluedoom though as they said they'd post when they're back from work and now it's been over 12 hours. I don't like metagaming that much but I feel like if they were maf there'd be a coached post by now. This leaves town or WW for bluedoom and I agree with hal that joey has been more actively exhibiting the behavior of a WW (not that bluedoom has had much chance but we work with what we have).

So here's essentially where I am.

Confirmed town:
Me
hal
Evie

Town to maf confidence levels (most likely town being at top):
AirC (99% sure town)
Tommy (pretty confident town)
bluedoom (biggest unknown but I lean town)
joey (lean wolf)
realiti (lean maf)

Confirmed mafia:
fairy
Celever

Our best chance to hit werewolf is joey. Based off hal's post (1949) that I agree with wholeheartedly, it's best to hit wolf. Thus...

##Vote: joey
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top