Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

[bluedoom]

Its weird because ya I feel like maf!realiti does w/e actions he did yesterday BUT I think maf!realiti usually makes status quo votes and doesn't do much to change the narrative and I don't feel like he's been doing that here.

 

[bluedoom]

I will say that you're crazy to think I'm mafia after I blindly voted joey when the mafia gameplan was supposedly to side with joey

 

[realiti]

I will say that you're crazy to think I'm mafia after I blindly voted joey when the mafia gameplan was supposedly to side with joey

I don't think that mafia picked a side because they could have framed you as WW, I think they were fine with the status quo as long as their 3rd member was not voted out

 

[realiti]

But yeah for me it's that + the genisu timeline that I find weird

-Vote Pulsar for more interaction
-Pulsar comes back, genisu leaves
-Genisu dies, try to vote me but doesn't actually for some reason
-Go and single out DBD despite not being that afk or having said anything that weird

ISO AirC and this is the ONLY read he has made the entire game

 

[realiti]

and genius was so obviously town from his first post, man cannot control his typing XD

 

[bluedoom]

I don't think that mafia picked a side because they could have framed you as WW, I think they were fine with the status quo as long as their 3rd member was not voted out

I guess that makes sense, I hadn't considered this.

 

[realiti]

Legit if I was scum why would I want to vote out Celever, it doesn't make sense, if we just random someone we have way greater odds of winning

AirC can you point out when you wanted to vote out celever this game

 

[realiti]

I think DBD vote is better no? Apart from being afk and not really saying anything Cary isn't that scummy right? Assuming they'll get subbed soon it doesn't matter if we vote them unless I missed something

See the thing with AirC is that he supposedly is following the game and forming opinions "Cary isn't that scummy" "DBD vote is better" but his ISO shows literally nothing, so I feel like he is just making things up as they go based on the status quo (nowhere in the thread has he mentioned either player before this)

 

[realiti]

Okay I don't want to metagame and shit but I see all this discussion about Cary and I can't not talk about the last game they played and their gameplay made 0 sense at all despite being town

Ok airc does mention scary at one point, but my point still stands

 

[realiti]

I will ask everybody for the 5th time to read AirC's ISO and tell me what they think because nobody has actually told me why he's towny, null is unfortunately not going to cut it when we are in MYLO

Evie apricity Tommy bluedoom

 

[bluedoom]

I will ask everybody for the 5th time to read AirC's ISO and tell me what they think because nobody has actually told me why he's towny, null is unfortunately not going to cut it when we are in MYLO

Evie apricity Tommy bluedoom

I think my reads(ignoring hal and Evie) are Tommy>you>airC, nothing about his ISO spells town to me.

Btw how many votes are on Celever? Was about to vote him.

 

[realiti]

I don't know why this post stuck with me 6 years later but y'all better take some time to get this vote right

NOC Post in thread '11p White Flag Thread'

Nov 26, 2019

i've had thought experiments like this before. and that's why i always argue with people like tommy, who think that if person A gets mislynched, it's their fault

no, it really isn't. that's such a mafiascum/451 way of thinking. because you're saying that a person got mislynched because they didn't follow the formula you (or site meta) prescribed for what town should do

which is fucking crazy! why on earth should you make judgments on a person's alignment based on how well they can play simon says? it's such an awful way of thinking

if person A gets mislynched by town 100% of the time...

• apricity

 

[realiti]

I think my reads(ignoring hal and Evie) are Tommy>you>airC, nothing about his ISO spells town to me.

Btw how many votes are on Celever? Was about to vote him.

I think there are 3 bolded votes on celever and 2 unbolded votes

 

[bluedoom]

I don't know why this post stuck with me 6 years later but y'all better take some time to get this vote right

NOC Post in thread '11p White Flag Thread'

Nov 26, 2019

i've had thought experiments like this before. and that's why i always argue with people like tommy, who think that if person A gets mislynched, it's their fault

no, it really isn't. that's such a mafiascum/451 way of thinking. because you're saying that a person got mislynched because they didn't follow the formula you (or site meta) prescribed for what town should do

which is fucking crazy! why on earth should you make judgments on a person's alignment based on how well they can play simon says? it's such an awful way of thinking

if person A gets mislynched by town 100% of the time...

• apricity

I mean I agree with hal's thoughts there but its so weird to quote this 6 years later.

 

[bluedoom]

I think there are 3 bolded votes on celever and 2 unbolded votes

oh so technically its hammer but we're still talking lol

 

[apricity]

Are we hammered

 

[realiti]

I mean I agree with hal's thoughts there but its so weird to quote this 6 years later.

TBF I thought this was more recent and I'm also shocked I remember this specific post but I just feel like the town PRs are hyperfixating on my joey read indicating me as scum due to "suboptimal gameplay" instead of actually trying to solve our slots

 

[apricity]

Just kidding that’s later tonight let’s gooooo formula one in Austin let’s get litttyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

 

[realiti]

IDK if votes count if they're unbolded

 

[NightEmerald]

IDK if votes count if they're unbolded

they count i must have miscounted mb

 

[apricity]

##vote celever

 

[realiti]

Tommy, Evie, AirC, me, Celever in that order I believe

 

[NightEmerald]

##vote: celever

this is hammer

Votes
Celever (5): Tommy, Evie, AirC, realiti, Celever

 

[apricity]

Sir my vote came later lmao

 

[NightEmerald]

I am on mobile rn you’re not getting fancy formatting,

Celever was voted and is the Mafia Rolecop.

If you lot lock in actions in 9 hours ill start the day early as well.