• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 1]

Status
Not open for further replies.
phoopes said:
##Vote: Unvote

##Vote: thechickening

I’m on my phone so idk if that’s the right format exactly but you get what I’m going for. My initial vote on Flanders was largely based off AFK status, since that’s not an issue anymore I’m flipping to chicken.

Still don’t like the “block genisu” nonsense (even if I don’t like genisu too for the opportunistic vote on me) but yeah
Click to expand...
why chicken over the other afks
 
pulsar512b said:
i really dont thijnk this is possible i think wiki articles suggests no multiples (as said earlier) but i also think like. i assume most of the roles arent just like 'tracker' like i suspect the roles on average have quite a lot of moving parts and as such theres way more design space
Click to expand...

Sure but I mean there can be multiple tracker variants etc I’m sure it’s not the exact same but just because a tracker exists doesn’t meant there not another etc
 
pulsar512b said:
i really dont thijnk this is possible i think wiki articles suggests no multiples (as said earlier) but i also think like. i assume most of the roles arent just like 'tracker' like i suspect the roles on average have quite a lot of moving parts and as such theres way more design space
Click to expand...
celever also says outright in the game design philosophy section of the op that not all roles are designed equally so my assumption is that some will have lots of parts and some will be rather straightforward
a fairy said:
chickening is better than three middling posts for sure, i like it more than the pulsar vote. hard for me to form reads on d1 but ive not read a wagon case that has motivated me yet so i def could see myself on chickening at eod
Click to expand...
has chickening made three posts? ive only seen one. also do they have scum/town games?
 
phoopes said:
##Vote: Unvote

##Vote: thechickening

I’m on my phone so idk if that’s the right format exactly but you get what I’m going for. My initial vote on Flanders was largely based off AFK status, since that’s not an issue anymore I’m flipping to chicken.

Still don’t like the “block genisu” nonsense (even if I don’t like genisu too for the opportunistic vote on me) but yeah
Click to expand...
what do you think about the flandrs entry though, beyond the fact that it happened?
 
Psypsypsypsypsythe said:
celever also says outright in the game design philosophy section of the op that not all roles are designed equally so my assumption is that some will have lots of parts and some will be rather straightforward

has chickening made three posts? ive only seen one. also do they have scum/town games?
Click to expand...
355 361 367

iirc the only scum chickening game i remember they got skill diff'd by realiti calling them by their discord name in game and getting reverse engineered into being maf buds but i could be misremembering
 
longpost coming, these are my reads for now, I also put how many posts have they made (in the time I searched for their posts)

Evie 1 Pages Pulsar 2 Pages A Fairy 2 Pages Tommy 5 pages StupidFlandrs48 1 Page ShyPebble 6 posts TheChickening 3 Posts DeadbyDaylight 3 Pages Airc 2 pages Peum 1 Page Des121 1 page (mostly filler tho) Phoopes 1 page in form of long posts Genisu 2 pages Liquidrelief 1 page Blizihguh 1 page (some long posts) Bluedoom 7 posts Psy 7 pages Saberslasher11 1 Page realiti 2 pages Hydrogenhydreigon 2 pages

Wanna be town leaders/most activity
Psy
Tommy

These two are the ones who have the mosts posts, both have trying to get reads on some players while not having anything directly scummy, I trust both of them for now since its not worth getting rid of the active players until there's strong evidence against them/ they will probably be targeted more for being the town leaders.

A lot of nothing burgers
AirC
A Fairy
Pulsar512b
Genisu

Their posts contain nothing that could progress the game forward and directly just say random things, A fairy is in this category because of them actively pushing the conversation on how Pulsar blocked GeniusU (which literally is not relevant and we cant get scumreads from this, please if you have any problems with pulsar just pm the host)

Generally AFK
Des121
Bluedoom
ShyPebble
Thechickening

I want to talk about them individually, Des121 has the mosts posts out of everyone here but a lot of the posts are literally one word or two, Bluedoom I have been reading their post history on another mafia games and he generally doesnt post a lot so im fine with them, ShyPebble has 6 posts, one of them being them accusing phoopes and then not saying anything else? Genuinely scummy. And the chickening, 3 posts. Really?


Im neutral about these players
Evie
Blizihguh
Saberslasher11
realiti

Players that have tried to make some reads and are defending/accusing people idk if they're scum but they seem fine for now

The "Im late" gang
Stupidflandrs48
Liquidrelief
Hydrogenhydreigon

Players that have come late so im going to talk about them individually, Stupidflandrs48 came late but made some reads so im not really suspecting him a lot, Liquidrelief didnt come late but has been playing like he has, They have been afk for most of the day and plays like des so generally sounds scummy, Hydrogenhydreigon came late but I think the same of them as stupidflandrs48, they have been making reads and reading the logs so I think they're fine for now

I genuinely dont know where to put them
Phoopes
Dead by Daylight

both of them would be in a section in between "Im neutral about these players" and "A lot of nothing burgers" Dead by Daylight has made few reads but they have been posting a lot of nothing burgers and Phoopes hasnt really said anything scummy but their posts are long enough and made some posts that dont sit right with me.

so from this I'll be changing my vote

##Vote: Unvote

##Vote: ShyPebble
 
realiti said:
why chicken over the other afks
Click to expand...
If I’m being 100% honest biggest part of it is self-preservation because I had most votes on me until recently, so anything to add to an AFK’s bandwagon

Psypsypsypsypsythe said:
what do you think about the flandrs entry though, beyond the fact that it happened?
Click to expand...
Don’t necessarily love how it happened/the resulting posts but at least it’s some content to go off of that we can look back to in future days
 
Tommy said:
Sure but I mean there can be multiple tracker variants etc I’m sure it’s not the exact same but just because a tracker exists doesn’t meant there not another etc
Click to expand...
i guess thats fair yeah there can be overlap or like i imagine theres some JOATs or JOATs with weird mechanics for when to shoot and they probably have overlap in the abilitiies they have
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top