i presume this is over the fakeclaim accusations, i do honestly think that's the case
-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 3]
- Thread starter Celever
- Start date
- Status
do i care?
I don't find liquid particularly scummy, but I'm fine with voting them for now to pressure them. DBD is kinda in the same boat as Pulsar for me but to less severity. Woud vote them but would rather vote Pulsar. Des claim is kinda a ... moment and I still don't know why des claimed cop, but pretty scummy.
also would vote Des unless we get more details about the cop role. But idk if that would change much.
why is the des cop claim scummy
claiming it without giving any results, nor the type of cop is just giving maf a sign to shoot them anyways, while holding back info for town. Also it's really easy to claim rolecop if u just watchout for tracks and watches or just say it on who you targetted. But not claiming the type of cop also allows for flexibility on what you claim later. It just feels like a move to try to not get lynched by town cuz why would town vote a cop.
so you're saying we shouldn't suspect it all, and just believe it? It would be a different case if there was any actually other info apart from Des claimed cop.
guys theres no way scum is fine with saber making these posts right
Yep, there's no reason to suspect it for now. Someone having a role claimed is 60% more information about them than 70% of the players still alive, so unless its lategame where everyone will need to get their claims or we decide that we absolutely need those results, there's no reason to vote or suspect Des for now. Moreso when your reasoning for suspect is "He sounds scummy" or "That's a mafia claim." Having their role now will make it easier for us anyways when it comes to lategame if they're indeed mafia.
Btw talking about roles that have appeared, Shypebble said that there's a role that can attach people's lives, considering how that could work, if that person is town (Which I think so considering that Pebble was attached to Des and Pulsar and he didnt die last night), couldnt it theorically attach a sus person to Tommy so we can vote him out? As tommy said that voting him out has some benefits for town? This is assuming that the role has no charges or smth like that.
Idk how would we communicate this, maybe tommy can ask for them to be linked to someone and we lynch him the next day.
Even if you suspect they're scum, voting them out rn would be goofy when there are many other people who look at least as scummy who haven't claimed cop
I would only be willing to vote Des if they don't at the bare minimum give us a reason why they aren't giving more info.
I don't think we should vote Des out for what they've claimed, especially since there are better options rn.
"I would vote des but I wouldnt vote des"
I will read and consider whatever Saber posts but for now I'm going to
##Vote: Saberslasher11
Setting aside the blatant contradiction, I think "I would only vote des out if she continues to do what she is clearly going to do" is the kind of reasoning you come up with when you're scum and want to justify voting for someone who you know is going to be obstinate.
At the start of the day I was giving saber a lot of credit because I didn't think scum would just let the only two D2 wagons be scum. But I think given the way that played out, and the list of people I scum read, it's entirely possible. Like, do we think bd, saber, and liquid were going to execute a well organized astroturf wagon? If scum includes dbd, liquid, and saber, is it possible that dbd was just freaking out trying to save his team from throwing by inactivity and then saber walked in and made it worse? Maybe the scum is just really disorganized this game.
Hard for me to imagine what kind of defense from Saber would change my mind at this point tbh. Maybe someone else will slip before EOD. I will try my best to be on tomorrow before the deadline but no promises.
##Vote: Saberslasher11
Setting aside the blatant contradiction, I think "I would only vote des out if she continues to do what she is clearly going to do" is the kind of reasoning you come up with when you're scum and want to justify voting for someone who you know is going to be obstinate.
At the start of the day I was giving saber a lot of credit because I didn't think scum would just let the only two D2 wagons be scum. But I think given the way that played out, and the list of people I scum read, it's entirely possible. Like, do we think bd, saber, and liquid were going to execute a well organized astroturf wagon? If scum includes dbd, liquid, and saber, is it possible that dbd was just freaking out trying to save his team from throwing by inactivity and then saber walked in and made it worse? Maybe the scum is just really disorganized this game.
Hard for me to imagine what kind of defense from Saber would change my mind at this point tbh. Maybe someone else will slip before EOD. I will try my best to be on tomorrow before the deadline but no promises.
This is actually what I was thinking earlier but I decided to not post it, I am giving DBD the benefit of the doubt overall. Saber sounds very scummy but I dont think mafia would throw themselves that hard against fire if Saber was mafia. Still, very scummy posts
- Status