Wanted to post some thoughts after playing wcop quals + main event. Will share some teams I built and general meta thoughts.
vs mintwinter (qualifiers)
:lokix: - :magnezone: - :latios: - :excadrill: - :gardevoir: - :toxapex:
My first thoughts looking at most scouts and the tier in general was a) Lokix is broken and b) with the right set Magnezone can trap all the Steels. Lokix main checks being Skarm and Tink makes U-Turn Kix + Zone very obvious, and the rest of the team kinda builds itself. Latios can do the pivot trap thing as well, while Excadrill and Gardevoir love Steels being gone and give you all of Rocks / Removal / Speed Control. Toxapex glues a lot of holes since you cheat a lot with this structure. Often you need to just commit to winning first once the Steel is gone. I think this type of structure should get used a lot more, it's hard to stop unless you lean hard on Enamorus.
vs franco
:cresselia: - :suicune: - :sandy-shocks: - :tinkaton: - :lokix: - :conkeldurr:
I was 99% sure stall was coming, so sacrificed a lot of mus to target this one specifically. SubCM Suicune + Lunar Dance Cress should have beaten most stall variants, in tests it can break through even Leftovers Blissey as well. Sadly here I missed T-Wave vs Cyclizar which meant I couldn't keep hazards up, and couldn't beat Haze Pex. I should have committed to the Tera Normal Conk + Lunar wincon, but overthought opposing Teras too much. Still, fun game to try and build for.
vs meru
:mew: - :bisharp: - :manaphy: - :ninetales-alola: - :zapdos-galar: - :thundurus-therian:
This was made targeting a BO / Balance MU with stuff like Slowking, we didn't expect Sun or cheese in this MU (even though it is in the scout). Decent sets like the Mew one didn't get to do anything here which was a bit sad, and I obviously got lucky later on with the flinch, but T1 and T2 could have changed the game completely and came down to a speed tie. Bit of a silly game really, cheese vs cheese isn't much fun
vs spell
:lokix: - :manaphy: - :thundurus: - :latios: - :grimmsnarl: - :excadrill:
At this point I had entirely given up building anything non cheese. It felt impossible to attempt to cover all of the possible extreme matchups in Stall / Sun / Veil / Screens / HO, so I just decided to bring another Screens team which would have a better matchup into offense. Going Grimm > Tales and Rain Dance Manaphy makes the Sun mu extremely playable, while Fimp Lokix helps get out of holes and means you can trade more while screens are up. This had a lot of options to win during the actual game and I was really happy with how the MU landed. The third SD didn't really matter either way with Manaphy + Lokix, and some combination of Thundurus + Latios was going to end that game.
Looking at my teams throughout the tournament, I realised after my loss to etern that building anything balanced wasn't really worthwhile. By the last week I had given up entirely. Covering every matchup is just impossible and makes the overall meta incredibly fishy. It seems really clear to me that Screens / Sun / Lokix are all too much for the tier. Right now these cheese HOs can just be customised to beat w/e matchup you think is coming, without really sacrificing anything. Trying to beat these with balance while also ensuring you can effectively break stall is a real losing battle, there's just not enough room on the team.
I might have missed a lot of discussion on Discord, but it really surprises me there isn't more tiering action being taken at the moment. I'd love to see Heat Rock + Manaphy banned (Manaphy being by far the best Screens abuser), then taking a look at both Light Clay and Lokix.
With those changes I think there would be healthy space for balance in the tier, which would be really fun as UU is one of the few tiers with actual viable defensive pieces and viable removal. Unfortunately the variety in HO options is just too much to let Skarm / Bliss / Pex actually do anything.