Arcanine-Hisui has been quickbanned by a 5-1 vote of the 35 Pokes Tiering Council and re-rolled to Fezandipiti!!!
In a 5-1 vote, the natdex 35 tiering council, which is currently comprised of 3 new members compared to last month for reasons that will be explained forthwith in my next post, voted to
quickban Arcanine-Hisui
:arcanine-hisui:!! Harcanine very quickly arose as the top pokemon in the metagame once we began playing it, and people were identifying it as a problem pokemon before a single game was ever played. The combination of STAB Rock Head Head Smash and Flare Blitz is unresisted in the current metagame, with the best/only switchins being thick fat Miltank or occa berry Orthworm.
"Essentially, most teams will want harc, there is such a huge advantage to using the pokemon and I would bet is the #1 used mon by a fair margin. In large part because there are only 2 pokemon in the tier Orthoworm and Metagross I believe that can resist head smash. The move is so powerful and arcanine is already very very fast. Scarf Harc outspeeds most scarfers and imo is the best set but even regular boots or lo also really tear apart teams.
If this were the sole factor we could feasibly have a meta where everyone has to build around this very strong very oppressive mon, and we can argue about whether that is competitive or fair or balanced and whatnot.
However for me what I think takes away from the enjoyability of it, and makes it a bit less competitive is the combination of it being so oppressive while also requiring a lot more luck than the average pokemon.
If there are 3 head smashes in a game there is almost a 50% chance one will miss, if there are 4 it is more likely than not. In this specific metagame where Harc with head smash is so prevelent we are getting these 3-4+ head smash games consistently. With the metagame as it is, it is extremely likely somebody will be missing a head smash at some point, and there is no way to predict it.
If flare blitz were a better move, and believe me it is good, then there could be a stronger arguement to not click head smash so much. However in most scenarios head smash is just the better play, so long as it hits. This meta is filled with rock, fire, and water types meaning flare blitz is just not nearly as spammable as head smash. This specific meta is setup in such a way that luck will always have a larger impact.
This luck is much easier to handle early meta, so many people are trying different techs and strategies but by the time the tour comes around and the margins get thinner, those head smash misses are going to matter much. I also would not be surprised if Harc has like 80%+ usage but thats not the main reason I would want it banned
Anecdotal usage stats from Turtle12
Obviously these stats will be slightly skewed in my preference but that is crazy usage -- 93.75% across like 23 games.
Additionally, "Arcanine-Hisui is simply far too overcentralizing in the builder. Just about every viable team right now is forced to run mutliple defensive and offensive checks for Arcanine-Hisui, and even still the dog can force progress with Head Smash almost every time it comes in. Even dedicated checks like fast physdef Miltank aren't a surefire answer, with Life Orb Arcanine-Hisui rolling to KO with the combo of Close Combat + Extremespeed, and Choice Scarf Arcanine-Hisui 2HKOing with Head Smash and Close Combat. Since there are no
true defensive answers to Arcanine-Hisui, the meta is forced to go strictly towards Offense, with Balance being largely unviable, let alone slower team structures. Additionally, VoltTurn cores are extremely strong in this meta and it can be easy to strangle your opponent since they can never switch into any mon that risks dying to Arcanine, since letting you pivot into it and position it safely can be fatal. While I think Arcanine-Hisui is not
quite as dominant as many make it out to be, the pressure it exerts on the builder is completely preventing a diverse and healthy metagame from developing."
Unsurprisingly, I was once again in the minority on this quickban vote.
With 26 years' experience, I've grown accustomed to it I understood why most players felt that Harc was nigh on impossible to wall defensively long-term, but I wasn't quite convinced that that this resulted in an unhealthy metagame dynamic, that the pressure on the builder was really as great as it appeared, or that Harcanine was the root cause of the problem with the metagame. In the interest of time, I will expand on my thoughts more in a follow-up post where I will also provide an update on changes to the tiering council over the past 2 months!
Dhelmise akaa goat ping
tagging
dhelmise to please implement
banning Arcanine-Hisui and
replacing it with Fezandipiti both in the teambuilder and our spotlight ladder tysm goat
post co-written by myself,
Turtle12, and
fooflybag