• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Rejected Impact of Tera Blast ban in OU on lower tiers

Status
Not open for further replies.

Django

is a Tournament Directoris a Member of Senior Staffis a Community Contributoris a Metagame Resource Contributoris a Tiering Contributoris a Dedicated Tournament Hostis a Contributor Alumnusis a Smogon Media Contributor Alumnus
NU Leader
I'm making this thread on the assumption that Tera Blast gets banned - if not all of this is moot and we can ignore it.

We recently froze rises as we are reaching the end of the generation. Usually this would coincide with a period of stability and tiering action slowing down relatively speaking. However at the moment we have a potentially huge suspect in Tera Blast which could have long reaching ripple effects throughout lower tiers. We can already see potential arguments for multiple unbans in OU, UU, and RU - all of which will have further impacts on usage and Pokemon changing tiers.

While Gen10 is not expected until late 2027 (so ~5-6 drops?), there is still a potentially long reaching impact here. We've seen ladder decline month on month as interest in SV wanes, and I don't think anyone expects that to meaningfully pick up. Assuming Tera Blast is banned, we're also going to see more suspect tests on the back of it, which will result in spikes in ladder activity with teams optimised for suspect runs, not regular ladder play. We're also going to see peaks and troughs as new mons move around tiers and interest shifts - all of this is to say a Tera Blast ban would be very destabilising to lower tiers and spikes in ladder activity might have outsized impact during a period of lower activity generally.

What I would like to avoid is a situation where we spend another year or two dealing with multiple big shifts and moving slowly to address issues. As Gen10 creeps closer and closer these issues will get worse, and you can very easily imagine a scenario where the tiers we end up locked with at the end of SV are neither stable nor representative of the metagames longer term. Even the most recent shift has seen big changes to PU - the effects of something changing in OU can take almost a year to reach there.

So a few suggestions on how to deal with this:
1. Tier leaders and councils of lower tiers commit to being as active as possible and dealing with tiering issues as soon as they come up. This sounds easy but we've seen it not quite be the case across the generation. Time is of the essence and waiting weeks-months to deal with something will have bigger impacts the higher up it starts
2. Do we consider unfreezing rises? I know this sounds strange, but entering a period where lots of changes are going to happen on the back of a Tera Blast ban with rises also frozen feels very strange to me. Situations almost certainly will arise where a niche mon (maybe something like a Gastrodon?) will have OU usage but remain in a lower tier. That seems very anti usage based tiering in general.
3. Do we move to 1 month shifts? Similar to early DLC cycles, this could help us move things through tiers faster and avoid it taking years for changes to be stabalised
4. Do we look at the rise and drop %'s again? There's been a few discussions on this and I think it's worth exploring whether these could help mitigate the effect of a late generation change like this.

Overall I want to discuss how we can best handle the (potential) upcoming instability and make sure we don't lose more time by discussing this only after it has happened. It feels prudent to talk about it now pending the result of the suspect.

Note: I don't want to discuss the Tera Blast suspect itself. That's an OU decision and not something for here.
 
I think a lot of this depends on what OU does really - but in theory you would unfreeze rises but keep 3 month shifts, and then freeze rises again at the very end like last gen. But I wouldn’t do it for next shift - there’s too much stuff going to be happening to make it accurate - keep the next shift as drops only and then at the subsequent shift allow rises again. That will probably get people mad but like if we are potentially unbanning some things and changing the tier fairly significantly then it’s the only way to remain accurate
 
I feel like the prospect of unfreezing rises completely misses the point of why they were frozen in the first place. Ladders have had increasingly lowered interest with the gen being years old at this point and all unfreezing them does is reintroduce the lower tiers eating each other alive. Functionally I struggle to see what the benefit of unfreezing the rises is because the idea that something "should" rise to a tier but cant due to freezes is just a consequence of needing to patch an already broken system. You can call it "anti-usage" but again, we really can't let tiers tear each other apart if we want these metagames to have any longevity, and no matter how late into the gen rise freezing happens, something gets left behind when in theory it "should" rise. Primary example I can think of is Diggesrby in SS UU, but last gen probably had a bunch more.

TLDR: Do not unfreeze rises, not only is there no way a TB ban causes enough of a shift to make it worth and even if it somehow did, we're far better off having some misplaced mons than to have LTs get ripped apart further.
 
ThatOneApple said:
I feel like the prospect of unfreezing rises completely misses the point of why they were frozen in the first place. Ladders have had increasingly lowered interest with the gen being years old at this point and all unfreezing them does is reintroduce the lower tiers eating each other alive. Functionally I struggle to see what the benefit of unfreezing the rises is because the idea that something "should" rise to a tier but cant due to freezes is just a consequence of needing to patch an already broken system. You can call it "anti-usage" but again, we really can't let tiers tear each other apart if we want these metagames to have any longevity, and no matter how late into the gen rise freezing happens, something gets left behind when in theory it "should" rise. Primary example I can think of is Diggesrby in SS UU, but last gen probably had a bunch more.

TLDR: Do not unfreeze rises, not only is there no way a TB ban causes enough of a shift to make it worth and even if it somehow did, we're far better off having some misplaced mons than to have LTs get ripped apart further.
Rises aren't all bad. We recently saw a suspected mon rise from NU to RU (Toxtricity). While it didn't get enough votes to be banned, it certainly was controversial and it leaving the tier opens up the builder a little bit. There's shifts like this which perhaps go unnoticed but are an important part of usage based tiering. It makes little sense to me to continue down the the usage based tiering path while also freezing rises for ~18 months during one of the potentially biggest upheavals in the whole gen. Without rises it's not really usage based, and if we're that unhappy with it we should do something else.

I do concede that rises have more risk of removing a core part of a tier (obviously). I think if we were to unfreeze rises we should do it alongside either shorter shift windows or changing thresholds to reduce some of that risk. But taking it off the table entirely feels premature
 
Django said:
Rises aren't all bad. We recently saw a suspected mon rise from NU to RU (Toxtricity). While it didn't get enough votes to be banned, it certainly was controversial and it leaving the tier opens up the builder a little bit. There's shifts like this which perhaps go unnoticed but are an important part of usage based tiering. It makes little sense to me to continue down the the usage based tiering path while also freezing rises for ~18 months during one of the potentially biggest upheavals in the whole gen. Without rises it's not really usage based, and if we're that unhappy with it we should do something else.

I do concede that rises have more risk of removing a core part of a tier (obviously). I think if we were to unfreeze rises we should do it alongside either shorter shift windows or changing thresholds to reduce some of that risk. But taking it off the table entirely feels premature
I struggle to see many players wanting this, one case of the builder being opened up after a rise doesnt really match the loads of cases of LTs having severe builder issues from core pieces being removed (Also, if Tox was just a builder constraint, who the hell voted dnb?). Additionally, as I said in the initial thread, it not being truly usage based isnt a bad thing either, because as we've seen the system we used is flawed to hell and back. As such, I believe the discussion should be how we can alter the system as a whole rather than ripping off the band-aid we put on it and watching tiers cannibalize each other.
 
Django said:
But taking it off the table entirely feels premature

Generally agree with this. There is no reason to take anything off the table, but also I think there isn’t much at all that should be done at the moment. We should definitely not rise anything on the next shift, mostly because we already said we weren’t but also because it’s wildly unpredictable what it would look like.

The best assessment would be to wait and see if Tera Blast is even banned in the first place, not speculate whatsoever on what effects that would have for now, and just see what “could have rose” when shifts happen. If the meta looks incredibly inaccurate, I.e. multiple mons OU by usage that are still UU, then yes we should absolutely unfreeze rises to have accurate tiers. But it’s a bit silly to even argue the point atm because it’s very possible nothing significant will change in rises anyways. We really just don’t know
 
A Tera Blast ban would be a major shake-up across all lower tiers, changing viability of several Pokémon and providing the opportunity for multiple resuspects. Keeping rises frozen in this environment would be absolutely pointless, if they were frozen for "stability" - all that would do is artificially keep tiers at higher power levels and enable Pokémon to be highly viable (and with high usage) in more tiers.

Rises are an important part of the system, and both drops and rises can have positive and negative effects on metagames. Rises make it possible for Pokémon at the bottom of the system to have a metagame where they can be viable. They can remove unhealthy, pressuring, or just simply annoying elements, the kinds that don't ever justify a ban. They lower power levels, allowing previously too weak, niche options to become vital defensive, support pieces and glues, or allowing healthier offensive threats to shine. If there isn't a reason to remove them - as there would no longer be after a Tera Blast ban - we should keep them.
 
On the assumption that Tera blast does get banned, I was actually gonna make a thread discussing the unfreezing of rises to begin with. Speaking as an RU council member and as an active player there, Tera blast banned would shake a lot of things up. Torterra and Entei will take a colossal hit and both of them have become staples of archetypes, Porygon-Z would go from suspect candidate to fraud in 1 hour, and others like Magnezone and Gastrodon would see their viability fluctuate. This would also enable quite a few Pokemon to be unbanned. Comfey and Yanmega are practically 100% to drop without question, while considerations for Volcanion, Gyarados, and potentially others are expected.

To be clear, let's just go on an assumption that Volcanion + Yanmega/Comfey, this would impact Suicune tremendously as well. The snowball effect would be strong, and its not unreasonably to expect a large swath of drops but.. rises wouldn't be happening. Mew for instance rose to UU and I've been smiling a lot more recently for that reason I hated that guy lmao. I'm sure a lot of tiers have had guys taken that arguably shouldn't have cough cough hippowdon, but they've definitely also had guys taken that they didn't care much for as well. Toxtricity and Mew, for instance. Same with Revavroom. The sentiment that rises are all bad is strictly nonsense, and I do think tiers would be best off when they are more close to what's actually viable within them. If this ban does go through, please re-instate rises until the beginning of 2027.

This is a complete side tangent, but I really hope we could just allow BL Pokemon to rise with impunity. 98% of the time these Pokemon are not genuine resuspect candidates for the tier below and it was really silly being an SS RU player seeing both Bewear and Pangoro sitting in NUBL despite both of them being A ranks caliber Pokemon for example. It's not allowed for what is simply speaking a fringe case scenario and frankly having viable mons be represented as "X tier by usage" is more beneficial to me than that.
 
Unfreezing rises should be avoided. Having rises frozen gives lower tiers the privilege of greater stability in the event of a Tera Blast ban causing upheaval. Even without a Tera Blast ban, it's clear that most lower tiers are in more unstable states - UU, RU, NU, and ZU are all holding suspect tests, and PU unbanned Heracross on top of taking controversial drops like Scrafty and Slowbro-G. Rises being frozen gives these tiers more breathing room to have gaps of development in between suspects.

Ladder declines as the generation goes on, and lower ladder activity means that there's more skew in usage stats. As mentioned above, ladders with suspect tests ongoing are already going to be less representative of the typical ladder metagame because players are trying to get suspect reqs with teams designed to do so efficiently. This is even more reason to stop rises. We might see ladder activity get a nice spike for April thanks to the suspect tests, but activity will decline and become less representative of competitive play the longer Champions is out and the more SV drags on.

Django said:
Do we consider unfreezing rises? I know this sounds strange, but entering a period where lots of changes are going to happen on the back of a Tera Blast ban with rises also frozen feels very strange to me. Situations almost certainly will arise where a niche mon (maybe something like a Gastrodon?) will have OU usage but remain in a lower tier. That seems very anti usage based tiering in general.
Keeping rises frozen promotes stability during a potential period of instability, which would work to the advantage of tiering. Councils get to keep track of fewer moving targets between tier shifts, tournament players could more deeply develop their metagames without the pressure of rises upending teams/structures/trends, and ladder usage would serve as a more accurate snapshot of metagame trends instead of reactions to staples rising and chains of suspect tests.

Pokemon having usage in a higher tier and remaining in a lower tier is baked into the usage-based tiering system. It can't really be anti-usage when it's part of the way it works. Clefable can't move from UU to OU in DPP despite its position as one of the best Pokemon in both tiers, and these two tiers are the ur-examples of usage-based tiering. Even when we try really hard in the present to make sure that the snapshots of our tiers are as accurate to the metagames as possible, they end up becoming inaccurate through age and development, and that's totally fine! If we're going to make choices about how our present decisions impact tiering long-term, I'd rather have it so that the focus is on wrapping up tiering for the generation neatly instead of dogmatically trying to preserve rises because they're the status quo. We can't really see what's going to be good in the future, but we can tier things as they are now to ensure that the playerbase isn't left with a rotten hand at the worst possible time in a generation.

sugar ovens said:
All [freezing rises] would do is artificially keep tiers at higher power levels and enable Pokémon to be highly viable (and with high usage) in more tiers.
Putting aside that the whole tiering system is artificial, the situation of Pokemon from lower tiers being viable in higher tiers isn't new (DPP Clefable), and it's not bad either. Blissey having niches in UU and OU doesn't have to take away from its role in RU, and Pokemon like it that can healthily exist in multiple tiers. These Pokemon are frequently inoffensive defensive Pokemon like Blissey, Gastrodon, and Quagsire that serve as glue or help to rein in more offensive threats that would verge on banworthy without them.

Plenty of players specifically enjoy being able to viably use lower tier Pokemon in higher tiers, so any argument of tiering identity/distinctiveness being critical wouldn't hold here either.

sugar ovens said:
[Rises] can remove unhealthy, pressuring, or just simply annoying elements, the kinds that don't ever justify a ban.
LBN said:
I'm sure a lot of tiers have had guys taken that arguably shouldn't have cough cough hippowdon, but they've definitely also had guys taken that they didn't care much for as well. Toxtricity and Mew, for instance. Same with Revavroom. The sentiment that rises are all bad is strictly nonsense
If there are identifiably unhealthy elements in a tier, it's the responsibility of the leadership of that tier to take action, not tier shifts. Rises might be neutral in the types of Pokemon they remove by taking Pokemon that are healthy and unhealthy, but the consequences of rises that remove healthy, staple Pokemon are going to be negative if the goal is to promote stability / manage instability to wrap the gen up. Rises being frozen doesn't take away the ability (or responsibility) of tiering leadership to act on things that are unhealthy.

LBN said:
This is a complete side tangent, but I really hope we could just allow BL Pokemon to rise with impunity. 98% of the time these Pokemon are not genuine resuspect candidates for the tier below and it was really silly being an SS RU player seeing both Bewear and Pangoro sitting in NUBL despite both of them being A ranks caliber Pokemon for example. It's not allowed for what is simply speaking a fringe case scenario and frankly having viable mons be represented as "X tier by usage" is more beneficial to me than that.
Not only would this violate tiering policy by arbitrarily exempting Pokemon just because they're not usable in a separate tier, but it would also actually remove the flexibility of lower tier councils to adjust to new tiering developments (cough cough, potential Tera Blast ban, cough cough) and changes in playerbase opinions by resuspecting elements of their banlist. Banned Pokemon aren't meaningfully distinct from the other Pokemon in pick up in usage in a higher tier, and they should be tiered the same way, even if the tag of UUBL doesn't capture Volcarona's viability in ORAS OU.
 
missangelic said:
Putting aside that the whole tiering system is artificial, the situation of Pokemon from lower tiers being viable in higher tiers isn't new (DPP Clefable), and it's not bad either. Blissey having niches in UU and OU doesn't have to take away from its role in RU, and Pokemon like it that can healthily exist in multiple tiers. These Pokemon are frequently inoffensive defensive Pokemon like Blissey, Gastrodon, and Quagsire that serve as glue or help to rein in more offensive threats that would verge on banworthy without them.

The distinctive features of lower tiers are diferent Pokémon pools and tier shifts. The reason why a casual ladder player tries out a lower tier over the far less dead OU ladder is to be able to play with wacky unmons, or to participate in Smogon's quite cool and interesting way of "ranking" the mons, not because a friend invites them to play for them in PUCL. This is something that only lower tiers offer, and the reason why we should try having the metagames as distinct as possible over having them blur together, with a massive pool of hopelessly unviable Pokémon unranked below the system. It's not just inherently good, it's key to future activity, and preservation of lower tiers. And yes, the tiers that need active ladders to survive should cater to the ladder player.

The viability development after the gen ends is completely irrelevant, the playerbases are different, ways people discover them are somewhat different, and the activity in them is not as important.

missangelic said:
If there are identifiably unhealthy elements in a tier, it's the responsibility of the leadership of that tier to take action, not tier shifts. Rises might be neutral in the types of Pokemon they remove by taking Pokemon that are healthy and unhealthy, but the consequences of rises that remove healthy, staple Pokemon are going to be negative if the goal is to promote stability / manage instability to wrap the gen up. Rises being frozen doesn't take away the ability (or responsibility) of tiering leadership to act on things that are unhealthy.

Well, no. Not only it is not the responsibility of the leadership of the tier to take action in these circumstances, but in fact doing so would directly violate the tiering policy. "Unhealthy" elements are the most vague and controversial thing to take tiering action against, and said tiering action is explicitly only meant to be taken in drastic circumstances. And even if someone actually decided to suspect test something like PU Bellibolt (a generally annoying defensive piece often fishing for Static procs, but not "uncompetitive" enough), the suspect would not result in a ban. They would get laughed at.

It also goes both ways, if there's a broken element that popped up as a result of a rise, the leadership should deal with it with tiering action - just in this case it's *actually* their responsibility to do so.


Really though, the whole framing of "promoting stability" in this whole rise business is just dishonest. There's no major practical difference between the instability caused by drops and rises (i can somewhat accept the argument that the development cause by rises can be a bit slower to bloom, but that's a matter of freezing rises for one shift, not one-and-a-half-year). You're just as guaranteed that your teams become unusable what a major element drops as when a major element rises, you are just as capable to take tiering action againsts broken elements that drop (besides the occasional quickban-worthy super-broken threat) as against broken elements that pop up after rises. New options can drop into the pond directly, or you can take them from the bottom after rises make space for them to be viable. And from a content creation perspective it's just flat out easier to take care of rises. The difference is in perception, drops are more fun and exciting, and the view of rises has grown toxic, the banter of "NU always stealing shit from us!" and annoyance of the higher tier dangling with the new toys at just enough usage became people unironically arguing that we should stop tiers "cannibalizing each other" as soon as possible, rises are seen as a pure negative now, even if the reality has always been that shifts are a neutral force, that can have positive and negative effect.

If stability was the priority, we would have a framework of preparing for the end of the gen - or be working on it. What's keeping us from a four- or six- month shifts period to accomodate for lower ladder activity, to have a larger sample size? How about a transition phase with separate cutoffs that not just stave off rises while not really doing anything to keep tiers stable, but that actually do keep the status quo outside of extreme cases - think quickshift cutoffs, passing a very low cutoff to drop, or a very high cutoff to rise in tier shifts. Or just freeze the tiers completely - that would be something applicable for this situation too, just keeping Tera Blast in lower tiers, nothing changes. Now, I personally don't want any of these solutions - just thinking of what a hypothetical person who would truly care to keep lower tiers stable and give council time to wrap up before the end of the generation (i don't remember seeing anyone like that between the recent policy threads, but, hypothetically) would argue for.

In the end, a Tera Blast ban would be a major jolt of activity - and instability - that would eradicate any last semblance of legitimacy behind the rise freeze, and tiers should be allowed to freely develop after the fact, at least for a period of time. Lower tiers just won't be stable after the fact for a while, unless some other solution is implemented to slow the changes. I don't see a reason to flip-flop between rises and no rises either just because something was previously decided - it's just extraordinary circumstances, things has changed now, happens. Skipping the tier shift completely is something that could be considered, but there will be a lot of time between the result of the suspect and the shift, so- not that needed i think.
 
Last edited:
sugar ovens said:
The distinctive features of lower tiers are diferent Pokémon pools and tier shifts. The reason why a casual ladder player tries out a lower tier over the far less dead OU ladder is to be able to play with wacky unmons, or to participate in Smogon's quite cool and interesting way of "ranking" the mons, not because a friend invites them to play for them in PUCL. This is something that only lower tiers offer, and the reason why we should try having the metagames as distinct as possible over having them blur together, with a massive pool of hopelessly unviable Pokémon unranked below the system. It's not just inherently good, it's key to future activity, and preservation of lower tiers. And yes, the tiers that need active ladders to survive should cater to the ladder player.

The viability development after the gen ends is completely irrelevant, the playerbases are different, ways people discover them are somewhat different, and the activity in them is not as important.
This isn't true, with usage-based old gens like DPP OU and DPP UU being examples of situations where an overlap in relevant Pokemon didn't kill future competitive activity or ruin the distinctiveness of each tier despite being played for years. Ladder players and casuals seeing that they can succeed with more diverse picks outside of the tier is also actually appealing and stimulates activity and interest, and preserving a higher diversity of options helps that too. If the goal was actually to make tiers as distinct as possible, the usage stat threshold wouldn't have been raised between Gens 7 and 8.

And that's with DPP UU and OU Clefable being the most standout example of tiers having a Pokemon that's actually entrenched at top level in both of them in an old gen for years. Saying tiers would lose their identities in just a year if we don't observe rises is so overblown. The threshold for rising is having a coinflip of a chance to see a Pokemon once in a string of 15 games. There's a good chance to go 20 games without seeing Gastrodon in UU, so it's not going to kill RU if they also like using the slug in 2026 and 2027.

I do think there's room to adjust this system of frozen rises so that we can observe when lower tier Pokemon genuinely do reach staple-levels in higher tiers. One of my suggestions in the previous thread on the pattern of rises was to decouple the threshold for rises and drops, and the OP here mentions revisiting the threshold too. I think this type of change would be a good potential compromise to observe Pokemon legitimately becoming staples in higher tiers without causing the same levels of upheaval as we have with shifts now.

sugar ovens said:
Really though, the whole framing of "promoting stability" in this whole rise business is just dishonest. There's no major practical difference between the instability caused by drops and rises (i can somewhat accept the argument that the development cause by rises can be a bit slower to bloom, but that's a matter of freezing rises for one shift, not one-and-a-half-year).
This just isn't true evidentially if you compare to SS and its period of freezing rises.
Post-Freeze SS Tier Shifts
July 2022 shifts
Gastrodon moved from RU to NU

Araquanid moved from NU to PU
Doublade moved from NU to PU
Guzzlord moved from NU to PU
Inteleon moved from NU to PU

Ninjask moved from PU to ZU
Palossand moved from PU to ZU

August 2022 Shifts
No quick drops

September 2022 Shifts
No quick drops

October 2022 Shifts
Zapdos-Galar moved from OU to UUBL
Regieleki moved from OU to UU
Tentacruel moved from UU to RU
Silvally-Steel moved from NU to PU
Zoroark moved from NU to PU
Cofagrigus moved from PU to ZU
Glastrier moved from PU to ZU
Perrserker moved from PU to ZU

November 2022 Shifts
No quick drops
Across all the frozen rise shifts in SS, the only drop UU got from OU was Regieleki and the only drop RU got was the middling Tentacruel. It should be obvious that this pattern would have extended to tiers below RU if there had been more than two tier shifts (OU-UU-RU) with frozen rises. When rises are frozen and ladder activity declines, it counterintuitively ends up with the situation where higher tiers finally cough up unviable Pokemon into tiers they were using, and said Pokemon aren't even showing that they're shaking up the tier below.

It's dishonest to pretend like the effects (really the lack of effects) of these Pokemon would have been on the same level as the canceled rises that would have taken place in the same period: Rotom-Wash, Excadrill, and Slowking were all top tier Pokemon that would have risen from UU to OU in just the July 2022 tier shifts.

Stability is explicitly mentioned as a priority in both the Tiering for Generation 8 thread and the end-of-gen policy update thread, which functionally are part of the tiering policy framework for how lower tiers are run. People don't even talk about how stats aren't even weighted by month anymore in the pursuit of stability, so the the opposition to reforms just comes off as reactionary against discussion of any attempt to reform the tiering system.

There still hasn't been an outline from leadership on what it takes to formalize this or further develop it, but it's not like planning tiering for lower tiers in Gen 9 was made easy by the way Game Freak has released updates and information (or more accurately, did not release updates and information) in both Gen 8 and Gen 9. I'm in agreement though that there should be some addendum to our current policy though, along with a much more open and forthright amount of communication from tiering leadership when before this comes up as an issue again for Gen 10.

Also, IF Tera Blast IS banned, then freezing rises isn't going to effect the pretty obvious cross-tier outcome where Pokemon that were banned because of Tera Blast will either stay in their home tier after being unbanned or decline further into even lower tiers. Be honest: Regieleki getting freed from Ubers and flopping out of OU would have no relationship to rises, just like in SS. Yanmega being more manageable in RU without Tera Blast would not make Talonflame's rise somehow a justifiable good for the tier. The direct ripple effects of a Tera Blast ban would not delegitimize freezing rises.
 
Ngl the more I read the "unfreeze rises" argument the more I think about how UU almost lost drill, and the clusterfuck that that would lead to on on the UU ladder. Ignoring the potential TB ban for a second, the entire purpose of freezing rises was resulting from the declining quality of ladder games that was only going to get worse as the next year went on, especially in LTs. Just looking at UU for a second, all we've done is steal meta staples that provided some stability when they arent even that good. Meanwhile, an actually good mon in UU, Gardevoir, remains in RU without ever getting super close to rising. So like... even the argument that rises allow mons to reach tiers they "belong" in doesnt make sense considering it doesnt seem to happen this late in the gen to begin with.

sugar ovens said:
If stability was the priority, we would have a framework of preparing for the end of the gen - or be working on it
sugar ovens said:
In the end, a Tera Blast ban would be a major jolt of activity - and instability - that would eradicate any last semblance of legitimacy behind the rise freeze, and tiers should be allowed to freely develop after the fact, at least for a period of time.
We had a whole discussion thread about this that lead to the freezing of rises. As misangelic said, Tera Blast being banned has like zero impact on the points made, and unfreezing them will just lead to the issues stated in that thread becoming worse and worse.

LBN said:
On the assumption that Tera blast does get banned, I was actually gonna make a thread discussing the unfreezing of rises to begin with. Speaking as an RU council member and as an active player there, Tera blast banned would shake a lot of things up.
An RU player cannot be sayin this yall are losing Slowbro if we unfreeze rises (/hj... well more like quarter joking because UU ladder is a bit weird at times)
 
I really do not see the point for a lot of the suggested proposals, as I feel like they either further increase the negative impacts from the shakeups tiers would have or are simply unable to happen.

The second option is honestly the single worst thing to do and I’m kinda shocked at how supported it is. There are two primary issues with implementing rises:
  • The decrease in ladder activity due to Champions dropping
  • The fact ladder stats do not accurately represent tiers
The first point is the primary one but lets go over it. While lower tier activity might not be so harshly affected by Champions, OU ladder activity most definitely will, with it allowing for usage stats to be much more manipulable by certain ladder players spamming teams. This is something that had its own thread with bots contaminating usage which luckily was resolved but if a popular RMT or sample is spammed a lot, then that can also force Pokemon to rise, see Talonflame rising to UU or Toxtricity rising to RU while being B- on the VR’s for the tiers they rose to. And reminder, this was before Champions dropped, including that it further increases the issue. Say for example, Excadrill rises to OU from UU, Excadrill is a staple piece of UU and is sure to have massive ramifications for the tier. As such, UU might look to some mons in RU, potentially something like Cyclizar may be used to try and deal with the hazard control issue they may have (could be another ground or a defogger but for the sake of this arguement lets say its cyclizar). Cyclizar rising to UU would heavily affect RU, which then might use Pokemon such as Tsareena as a spinner option to compensate, which then NU might try out some PU removal that could help with their removal being stolen. That sort of thing will basically massively affect tiers and further cannibalize them basically rendering the point of the proposal mute. It would not help stabilise tiers, but destabilise them further. Just because all rises are not horrible does not mean we should implement them this late into the gen where ladder activity is at its lowest, the potential for massive destabilizing shifts are big and would lead to tiers being in a very undesirable shape by the end of the gen, leading to less people desiring to play these tiers post gen.

The second point adds onto the first point, sometimes ladders just yoink things from lower tiers that do not ultimately deserve to be in said higher tiers. Both Talon and Hippo are great examples of this (B- in UU) while Mesprit and Toucannon were both projected to rise to NU at some point (both completely unviable in NU). Don't even get me started on how Braviary is still NU btw, thats a whole thing. With decreased activity, there is a higher chance for this to happen. Maybe Mandibuzz or something rises to OU, or Chesnaught rises to UU etc. These can occur as we have seen and serve to further destablise tiers. Missangelic has basically nailed the point, they further destabilise tiers and do not acheive the intended outcome.


1 month shifts (which I’m assuming would be just drops) is a bit more interesting but I think ultimately would not work as intended. It would still put a lot of pressure on councils to quickly fix metas, though ofc it would also make things easier to stabilise ig? Idk, I need to think further on this part before commenting further.

Changing the threshold for rises/drops is one that I ultimately would be in support of, but as Marty stated here it is apparently a non starter. Perhaps you could try to get that changed for Gen 10 but thats outside the scope of this thread so yeah. Good solution unfortunately it is unviable.

Ultimately, I do think the best solution is to just let councils work out the shifts by being as active as possible. Implementing rises this late just fucks up tiers even further.
 
Heatranator said:
I really do not see the point for a lot of the suggested proposals, as I feel like they either further increase the negative impacts from the shakeups tiers would have or are simply unable to happen.

The second option is honestly the single worst thing to do and I’m kinda shocked at how supported it is. There are two primary issues with implementing rises:
  • The decrease in ladder activity due to Champions dropping
  • The fact ladder stats do not accurately represent tiers
The first point is the primary one but lets go over it. While lower tier activity might not be so harshly affected by Champions, OU ladder activity most definitely will, with it allowing for usage stats to be much more manipulable by certain ladder players spamming teams. This is something that had its own thread with bots contaminating usage which luckily was resolved but if a popular RMT or sample is spammed a lot, then that can also force Pokemon to rise, see Talonflame rising to UU or Toxtricity rising to RU while being B- on the VR’s for the tiers they rose to. And reminder, this was before Champions dropped, including that it further increases the issue. Say for example, Excadrill rises to OU from UU, Excadrill is a staple piece of UU and is sure to have massive ramifications for the tier. As such, UU might look to some mons in RU, potentially something like Cyclizar may be used to try and deal with the hazard control issue they may have (could be another ground or a defogger but for the sake of this arguement lets say its cyclizar). Cyclizar rising to UU would heavily affect RU, which then might use Pokemon such as Tsareena as a spinner option to compensate, which then NU might try out some PU removal that could help with their removal being stolen. That sort of thing will basically massively affect tiers and further cannibalize them basically rendering the point of the proposal mute. It would not help stabilise tiers, but destabilise them further. Just because all rises are not horrible does not mean we should implement them this late into the gen where ladder activity is at its lowest, the potential for massive destabilizing shifts are big and would lead to tiers being in a very undesirable shape by the end of the gen, leading to less people desiring to play these tiers post gen.

The second point adds onto the first point, sometimes ladders just yoink things from lower tiers that do not ultimately deserve to be in said higher tiers. Both Talon and Hippo are great examples of this (B- in UU) while Mesprit and Toucannon were both projected to rise to NU at some point (both completely unviable in NU). Don't even get me started on how Braviary is still NU btw, thats a whole thing. With decreased activity, there is a higher chance for this to happen. Maybe Mandibuzz or something rises to OU, or Chesnaught rises to UU etc. These can occur as we have seen and serve to further destablise tiers. Missangelic has basically nailed the point, they further destabilise tiers and do not acheive the intended outcome.


1 month shifts (which I’m assuming would be just drops) is a bit more interesting but I think ultimately would not work as intended. It would still put a lot of pressure on councils to quickly fix metas, though ofc it would also make things easier to stabilise ig? Idk, I need to think further on this part before commenting further.

Changing the threshold for rises/drops is one that I ultimately would be in support of, but as Marty stated here it is apparently a non starter. Perhaps you could try to get that changed for Gen 10 but thats outside the scope of this thread so yeah. Good solution unfortunately it is unviable.

Ultimately, I do think the best solution is to just let councils work out the shifts by being as active as possible. Implementing rises this late just fucks up tiers even further.

Just a quick question after reading all of this. Based on what you said, then wouldn’t you say unfreezing rises would be warranted if:

A) ladder activity increases following a Tera blast ban to the point accurate representations aof the meta are played and develops on the ladder, and

B) certain mons do in fact show higher usage in a tier above it by more than a marginal amount, in addition to being generally thought quite good in that tier

not saying this is happening, but I think saying it definitely won’t happen is very dismissive in the same regard that saying it will definitely happen is quite a guess. We should take a wait and see approach but trying to theory our way into this argument is not going to get very far until we see how in fact things do change and we should absolutely not rule anything in out to address it.
 
With the tera blast suspect ending pretty soon I figured I should air my thoughts out. I think unfreezing rises is counterintuitive to the development of current low tiers and a tera blast ban has little to no impact on current metagames. Looking at popular potential tera blast users by BL tier there are (note I have mainly been involved with ru/pu this gen so if I have a few unfitting mons in these lists then I apologize in advance):
UUBL
:moltres-galar:
:polteageist:
RUBL
:comfey:
:gyarados:
:yanmega:
:serperior:
:blastoise:
:volcanion:
NUBL
:cloyster:
PUBL
:frosmoth:
While these are not all exactly similar or even banned just due to the move tera blast it is likely a lot of low tiers will revisit BL lists in order to gauge potential unbans/suspects. Almost all of these users are offensive or "cheese" style pokemon usually slotting into teams like HO in order to set up then win with coverage gained by tera blast. I did not include all users of the move normally in the tier since 1. that's too much for me to care to track rn, and 2. ultimately beyond BL pokemon it does not broadly change the metagame. Tera Blast is not inherently making different pokemon viable, it mainly adds to those with offensive sets that appreciate the coverage. This move does not change anything beyond that, and I think the impact it has on lower tiers is very overblown in the OP. I do not really see what the gain is in unfreezing rises when if any of these pokemon were to rise to begin with, they would have naturally (while having a stronger moveset). Doing this because of potential increase in ladder activity sounds fine on paper but in actuality it's going to affect lower tiers with less ladder activity. I think creating stability for the last year of SV transitioning into an oldgen should be a priority rather than caring about what listed tier a pokemon is. Lower tier pokemon are often used upwards, but just because they get that usage from someone does it necessarily mean they should rise? A lot of people disliked Uberfiend rising braviary outside of PU multiple times despite it being ranked poorly in NU (literally in a Do Not Use tier), or the RMT stall that peaked UU that made talonflame rise from RU (which is ranked B- currently but still was barely used before the stall saw use).

The decision to freeze rises also was not influenced at all by tera blast's suspecting or potential ban, so I'm unsure how unfreezing rises is related or warranted. If anything rises should definitely not be freed if we're aiming for stability, due to the highly likely suspect periods if the ban ends up happening. Not all activity is indicative of an accurate metagame depiction, and most suspects do lead people to piloting team styles like HO that are easy to pick up and easy to play a lot of games quickly. I think rises being unfrozen is setting back the outcome people wanted to see for low tier stability for a reason that ultimately does not change metagames besides unbans. I think low tiers do have an identity in shifts, but the tiers themselves should be able to also have an identity, without ending the generation with pokemon that did not accurately represent it throughout. I do not believe any other action needs to be taken during the rest of SV, aside from councils being active (which should be a responsibility of the position regardless). If there are previous or current instances of council people not being active or slowing down the tiering process they should just not be a member, it is an optional position that should be given to people willing to contribute and be present.
 
Last edited:
So, I want to revisit this thread now we have much more context on a) Tera Blast ban actually happening b) more data from 3 months of tier shifts c) more information on timing of the generation.

To start, we should remember the context of rises being frozen being when we were very unsure on what Pokemon Champions would actually be, and whether it would signal the end of Gen 9. We've seen now that Gen 10 is probably not coming until September 2027 at the earliest, so we are looking at another 4 tier shifts (at least). When we froze shifts in Gen 8, it was with 2 shifts left. Now we are looking at 5+ shifts with rises frozen, so it's worth analysing the impact of this and if this is indeed the impact we want.

I'd also like to try and steer the discussion in a slightly different discussion since last time I think there was too much focus on unfreezing rises alone, rather than the broader topic.

To start then, I'd like to attempt to frame what we are optimising for between now and the end of the generation. To me, there are two goals:
  1. Tiers which are stable and do not require much (ideally 0) tiering action post generation
  2. Tiers which accurately reflect the state of the metagame
I think both of these are important. Goal 1 ensures tiers are balanced and can continue to be played in tournaments and ladders post generation by those who already enjoy them. Goal 2 I think leans more towards new players but is also important for everyone e.g. when building the tier you can look at the tierlist and see what threats exist and what is viable. Situations where a top tier mon in UU is listed under RU or PU are confusing and inaccurate.

The two goals are also tricky to balance. Optimising for one too much leads to the other being neglected. Right now I think we are optimising too much for option 1, at the expense of option 2. I'll use the latest tier shift data to illustrate this.

So, looking at the rises which have been blocked in the most recent 3 months of usage:
Rises
Garchomp would have moved from UUBL to OU

Serperior would have moved from RUBL to UU
Thundurus would have moved from RUBL To UU
Gardevoir would have moved from RU to UU
Ninetales-Alola would have moved from PU to UU

Cresselia would have moved from NUBL to RU

Drednaw would have moved from PUBL to NU
Scrafty would have moved from PUBL to NU
Ambipom would have moved from PU to NU
Grimmsnarl would have moved from PU to NU
Wo-Chien would have moved from PU to NU
Brute Bonnet would have moved from ZU to NU (and had enough usage to move to PU too!)

Mesprit would have moved from ZU to PU
Venusaur would have moved from ZU to PU
Whimsicott would have moved from ZU to PU

Primeape would have moved from SUBL to ZU
Cryogonal would have moved from SU to ZU
Dusknoir would have moved from SU to ZU
Eelektross would have moved from SU to ZU
Rotom would have moved from SU to ZU
Samurott would have moved from SU to ZU
Toedscruel would have moved from SU to ZU
Naclstack would have moved from NFE to ZU

First thing to point out, the BL -> tier above rises are immaterial to tiering stability, and only serve to make the teambuilding and tier learning experience worse. We should allow those rises to go through regardless of anything else imo.

I'll talk about a few particular examples:

Gardevoir would have moved from RU to UU (6.520% in UU, 11.419% in RU), A- on UU VR
Ninetales-Alola would have moved from PU to UU (5.726% in UU, 6.794% in PU) B- on UU VR

These are both legitimately UU Pokemon. Gardevoir has been talked about as one of the best Scarf mons in the tier, and is a great check to Latios. Ninetales-Alola meanwhile is a key enabler for Veil offense, leading to multiple discussions about potentially banning Light Clay.

Ambipom would have moved from PU to NU (6.260% in NU, 11.985% in PU) B on NU VR
Grimmsnarl would have moved from PU to NU (5.357% in NU, 5.913% in PU) B- on NU VR
Wo-Chien would have moved from PU to NU (4.714% in NU, 8.914% in PU) A- on VR
Brute Bonnet would have moved from ZU to NU (4.877% in NU, 4.823% in PU) B+ on VR

Ambipom is a very legitimate NU Pokemon. It's been discussed as being underrated on the VR, and continues to gain popularity as an anti HO tool which also abuses Spikes very well. Grimmsnarl similarly serves a role of being both good against HO, and also being able to tech for fat matchups with SubBU sets. Wo-Chien and Brute Bonnet probably cannibalise each others usage a bit, but they both add crucial type resistances in NU but end up on different styles of team (Balance vs Offense).

Mesprit would have moved from ZU to PU (6.095% in PU) B on PU VR
Venusaur would have moved from ZU to PU (5.942% in PU) A- on PU VR
Whimsicott would have moved from ZU to PU (4.619% in PU) C+ on PU VR

The usage here is partly driven by the rise of Sun as a top tier playstyle in PU. They also have niches outside of Sun, checking top tier threats such as Pawmot.

I won't comment too much on SU -> ZU rises other than pointing out that these mons are again very legit in ZU.

So, looking at the above, we see a large number of mons which are ranking highly on the tiers they should be rising to VRs, as well as getting usage way above the 4.52% cutoff. Some of course are much closer to the cutoff, but there is a real variety here. I also think it's worth pointing out that these types of rises are not metagame defining in the way previous rises were (e.g. Talonflame and Hippowdown rising from RU to UU). What we're seeing here is mons shifting with metagames as we get closer to tiers which are more stable. The tops of the tiers are staying relatively the same, and middling usage mons are shifting around as niches are discovered and solidified.

Overall, it doesn't feel to me like the blanket freezing of rises is having the desired effect. We are artificially stabilising, at the cost of accuracy and consistency.

So to open the discussion on this, I want to ask a few questions:
  1. Do the results we see above make sense to you? Should we be blocking these rises?
  2. Are we optimising for the right metric at the right point in the generation e.g. stability over all else with 4+ tier shifts left
  3. If the answer to either of the above is "no" - what is the solution?
  4. If the answer to 1 or 2 is "yes" - why? Do we need to change anything outside of the tiering system to handle the change in accuracy and consistency?
 
Django said:
So, I want to revisit this thread now we have much more context on a) Tera Blast ban actually happening b) more data from 3 months of tier shifts c) more information on timing of the generation.

To start, we should remember the context of rises being frozen being when we were very unsure on what Pokemon Champions would actually be, and whether it would signal the end of Gen 9. We've seen now that Gen 10 is probably not coming until September 2027 at the earliest, so we are looking at another 4 tier shifts (at least). When we froze shifts in Gen 8, it was with 2 shifts left. Now we are looking at 5+ shifts with rises frozen, so it's worth analysing the impact of this and if this is indeed the impact we want.

I'd also like to try and steer the discussion in a slightly different discussion since last time I think there was too much focus on unfreezing rises alone, rather than the broader topic.

To start then, I'd like to attempt to frame what we are optimising for between now and the end of the generation. To me, there are two goals:
  1. Tiers which are stable and do not require much (ideally 0) tiering action post generation
  2. Tiers which accurately reflect the state of the metagame
I think both of these are important. Goal 1 ensures tiers are balanced and can continue to be played in tournaments and ladders post generation by those who already enjoy them. Goal 2 I think leans more towards new players but is also important for everyone e.g. when building the tier you can look at the tierlist and see what threats exist and what is viable. Situations where a top tier mon in UU is listed under RU or PU are confusing and inaccurate.

The two goals are also tricky to balance. Optimising for one too much leads to the other being neglected. Right now I think we are optimising too much for option 1, at the expense of option 2. I'll use the latest tier shift data to illustrate this.

So, looking at the rises which have been blocked in the most recent 3 months of usage:
Rises
Garchomp would have moved from UUBL to OU

Serperior would have moved from RUBL to UU
Thundurus would have moved from RUBL To UU
Gardevoir would have moved from RU to UU
Ninetales-Alola would have moved from PU to UU

Cresselia would have moved from NUBL to RU

Drednaw would have moved from PUBL to NU
Scrafty would have moved from PUBL to NU
Ambipom would have moved from PU to NU
Grimmsnarl would have moved from PU to NU
Wo-Chien would have moved from PU to NU
Brute Bonnet would have moved from ZU to NU (and had enough usage to move to PU too!)

Mesprit would have moved from ZU to PU
Venusaur would have moved from ZU to PU
Whimsicott would have moved from ZU to PU

Primeape would have moved from SUBL to ZU
Cryogonal would have moved from SU to ZU
Dusknoir would have moved from SU to ZU
Eelektross would have moved from SU to ZU
Rotom would have moved from SU to ZU
Samurott would have moved from SU to ZU
Toedscruel would have moved from SU to ZU
Naclstack would have moved from NFE to ZU

First thing to point out, the BL -> tier above rises are immaterial to tiering stability, and only serve to make the teambuilding and tier learning experience worse. We should allow those rises to go through regardless of anything else imo.

I'll talk about a few particular examples:

Gardevoir would have moved from RU to UU (6.520% in UU, 11.419% in RU), A- on UU VR
Ninetales-Alola would have moved from PU to UU (5.726% in UU, 6.794% in PU) B- on UU VR

These are both legitimately UU Pokemon. Gardevoir has been talked about as one of the best Scarf mons in the tier, and is a great check to Latios. Ninetales-Alola meanwhile is a key enabler for Veil offense, leading to multiple discussions about potentially banning Light Clay.

Ambipom would have moved from PU to NU (6.260% in NU, 11.985% in PU) B on NU VR
Grimmsnarl would have moved from PU to NU (5.357% in NU, 5.913% in PU) B- on NU VR
Wo-Chien would have moved from PU to NU (4.714% in NU, 8.914% in PU) A- on VR
Brute Bonnet would have moved from ZU to NU (4.877% in NU, 4.823% in PU) B+ on VR

Ambipom is a very legitimate NU Pokemon. It's been discussed as being underrated on the VR, and continues to gain popularity as an anti HO tool which also abuses Spikes very well. Grimmsnarl similarly serves a role of being both good against HO, and also being able to tech for fat matchups with SubBU sets. Wo-Chien and Brute Bonnet probably cannibalise each others usage a bit, but they both add crucial type resistances in NU but end up on different styles of team (Balance vs Offense).

Mesprit would have moved from ZU to PU (6.095% in PU) B on PU VR
Venusaur would have moved from ZU to PU (5.942% in PU) A- on PU VR
Whimsicott would have moved from ZU to PU (4.619% in PU) C+ on PU VR

The usage here is partly driven by the rise of Sun as a top tier playstyle in PU. They also have niches outside of Sun, checking top tier threats such as Pawmot.

I won't comment too much on SU -> ZU rises other than pointing out that these mons are again very legit in ZU.

So, looking at the above, we see a large number of mons which are ranking highly on the tiers they should be rising to VRs, as well as getting usage way above the 4.52% cutoff. Some of course are much closer to the cutoff, but there is a real variety here. I also think it's worth pointing out that these types of rises are not metagame defining in the way previous rises were (e.g. Talonflame and Hippowdown rising from RU to UU). What we're seeing here is mons shifting with metagames as we get closer to tiers which are more stable. The tops of the tiers are staying relatively the same, and middling usage mons are shifting around as niches are discovered and solidified.

Overall, it doesn't feel to me like the blanket freezing of rises is having the desired effect. We are artificially stabilising, at the cost of accuracy and consistency.

So to open the discussion on this, I want to ask a few questions:
  1. Do the results we see above make sense to you? Should we be blocking these rises?
  2. Are we optimising for the right metric at the right point in the generation e.g. stability over all else with 4+ tier shifts left
  3. If the answer to either of the above is "no" - what is the solution?
  4. If the answer to 1 or 2 is "yes" - why? Do we need to change anything outside of the tiering system to handle the change in accuracy and consistency?
Very much agree with this post, but more importantly want to emphasize the fact that freezing rises from xxBL to the above tier makes no sense if the goal was stability. It has no positive impact and reduces the accuracy of what the tier is supposed to be via usage. And, since the reasoning and goal of the freeze was already stated as stability, this should be immediately looked at and allowed to go through. Freezing BLs is immaterial to stability and play, but it is very material to identity and accuracy of said tiers via usage.

As for the other rises, I agree we should allow them but honestly it’s mons so we can really just do what people want to generally do, I don’t think it requires a super significant philosophical push one way or the other. Just do what the people want to do, generally, unless it’s unclear then some big heads should look into it more.
 
hi, here's my washed ass opinion on this situation

while i still believe that freezing was the net positive solution (minus the bl rises; those should prolly be unfrozen), this is an issue that seems kinda hard to solve with our current tiering system. the timing of the tera blast suspect and ban did not help either; i expressed my support in the original thread believing that ou wasn't gonna touch tera blast (as part of their hands-off approach on tera as a mechanic). ultimately while i do believe that usage-based tiering should be changed, it's likely to be an arduous process that me and my dusty brain doesn't have a solution to.
in the meantime, i think making the teambuilder sort by usage rather than alphabetically by default is a decent compromise. right now, it helps new players see what lower-tier mons have found viability in their tier of choice, while in future generations it'll help dissuade players from chronic noob traps like forretress and azelf. it's not a flawless solution (especially if some jackass decides to pull another "ambipom to the top" stunt), but it's at least something.
 
The freeze is definitely protective of stability and consistency at this point in time. The purpose of a system is what it does, and the previous system we were using was not able to fulfill the stated goal of having more drops than rises for lower tiers. Now, after this band-aid fix, this system is just beginning to do its stated purpose. I think the best avenue from here is to explore reforming the usage-based tiering system for Generation 10 so there doesn’t have to be this type of sudden flip toward the end of a Generation. Regardless, I’d like to highlight where and how freezing rises benefits lower tiers.

:uxie::mesprit:
For example, if rises still been in effect, ZU would have lost 3 of its top Pokemon. One of those losses, Mesprit, would have risen because of the vacuum left behind by Uxie moving from PU to NU in the prior tier shifts. The freeze stops this chain of the tiering vacuum sucking up staple Pokemon that stabilize the tier.

Even more examples
:passimian::primeape:
In April 2026, Passimian moved from ZU to PU while Primeape would move from ZU to SU. Three months later, Passimian has dropped back to ZU just as Primeape would have seen enough usage to climb back to ZU. It’s hard not to see this as an obvious example of where freezing even just three months earlier would have actually made for a more accurate reflection of ZU and a more consistent experience with the tier.

:rotom-mow::rotom:
Another ZU/SU example, sorry official tier players, but the lower stability of the ZU and PU ladders is a product of the system to this point and is really efficient for illustrating my points about it. Rotom-Mow, even though it would have dropped to SU by falling out of ZU by usage in April, actually moved to PU by usage. I do think Rotom’s rise is also related to ZU losing Passimian as a Scarfer, but that just hammers my point home here that choosing not to freeze continues this destabilizing trend of needing to constantly fill the void with new Pokemon cannibalized from lower tiers.

:wo-chien: | :heatran::weavile::tinkaton::scizor:
July 2026: Wo-Chien would have moved from PU to NU
April 2026: Wo-Chien moved from NU to PU
October 2025: Wo-Chien moved from PU to NU
Live waffler reaction. I’ll get into this point a bit more later, but I think the freeze on rises helps with preventing situations like Wo-Chien’s where it jumps between tiers that it’s completely fine in. There’s examples of these Pokemon across tiers too: UU just got Heatran back, but it’s also seen this behavior from Weavile, Tinkaton, and Scizor.

:ambipom::ninetales-alola:
These two are nice because they provide two very different examples of averted rises that still portray the benefits of freezing. Ambipom is a popular and stabilizing force in PU at the moment, but it seeing modest interest in NU as cheesier playstyles take stage doesn’t have to mean that PU needs to give up this tool. PU gets to keep a very popular pivot, NU still has access to it as a solid tool, and both tiers are better off for this.
On the flipside, Ninetales-Alola is a somewhat different Pokemon between in PU and UU between the teams it features on and the sets it runs. If one Pokemon behaves like two different Pokemon between tiers, I think that’s a case for the freeze, not against it. Pokemon being successful in different tiers for different reasons is a cool feature of the system in my opinion rather than a negative bug. I think this rubs people the wrong way sometimes when it comes to usage, but some Pokemon are sometimes just better in higher tiers because the tiers are environments, not linear points of a decreasing power scale. I think if we can handle and understand DPP Clefable ruling OU and UU, there can be tolerance for when this happens on a much smaller scale in lower tiers with less relevant Pokemon.

Another point: the averted rises this cycle did not see high levels of usage.
Of the averted rises, none of them broke 6.7% on average across three months, which would effectively represent an average of “usage and a half” for one month. If we were seeing multiple Pokemon breach something like 9.04% or even 13.56% usage (like Rhydon did in 2024 PU) then I think there would be grounds for a reevaluation, but there’s not an overwhelming amount of Pokemon seeing even solid usage in higher tiers. As Django mentioned, most of these Pokemon are more modest in usage or roles or viability in the higher tiers, not reaching staple-levels, and tend to be reacting to specific trends that may receive tiering action more than crystallizing into part of the tier.

BLs should not be tiered separately from the policy on freezing rises. Moving them up would make tiering incoherent by treating them differently because of the actions of a lower tier. More importantly, rising BLs rules out retesting them later on if they seem to no longer be banworthy. Tiers with and without frozen rises have tested Pokemon back in even after the Generation has ended. Also, as more Pokemon trickle back down, it’s not unlikely that some banned Pokemon might become easier to handle, especially ones that had Tera Blast as part of the reason why they were banned. The beneficial part of the freeze is that it gives councils and playerbases of the present and future more options to work with for making playing the tiers themselves enjoyable, and we don’t need to revert that because it’s Garchomp’s turn now that Tyranitar got off the carousel that waffles between OU and UUBL/UU.

The other problem is that ladder activity hit a generational low this last month (below 770k games in OU, when no other month has gone below 930k, the previous lowest). As ladders become less active, usage stats will start to skew even more, which makes those destabilizing rises even more likely to occur. We are still not seeing an end to the (now-averted) rises outnumbering drops, and those Pokemon that do break the threshold are only going to be less accurate representations of trends as the Generation winds down.

I think it’s very difficult to accurately assess whether or not the freeze is doing its intended purpose when this is the first set of shifts it’s implemented - I think comparing to SS would help paint a bigger picture of what’s going to happen to SV, and I believe that we’ll better understand the implications of freezing long-term once we see the actualized effects of it, which I would like to analyze but it’s very late and I’ve nearly run out of battery typing on this.
 
Last edited:
missangelic said:
The freeze is definitely protective of stability and consistency at this point in time. The purpose of a system is what it does, and the previous system we were using was not able to fulfill the stated goal of having more drops than rises for lower tiers. Now, after this band-aid fix, this system is just beginning to do its stated purpose.
I don't think it's been stated anywhere as an explicit goal for the tiering system to provide more drops than rises? The goal of the usage based tiering system has been to provide tiers which accurately reflect usage - very little else. We've become frustrated with that and attempted to adjust it, but the system as a whole isn't designed explicitly to produce more drops than rises.

I won't comment on the specific points about benefits for lower tiers because yes, the benefits to stability are clear. However, it strikes me that most arguments in this section are really just arguments against rises full stop, rather than rises specifically at this point in the generation. The phenomenons described here are persistent throughout the entire lifecycle of the tier, and not anything new. We've dealt with them for generations. I'm not particularly interested in debating whether or not rises are good or bad for lower tier stability because of course the answer is they are bad. What I am interested in looking into is whether freezing those rises right now in the generation is the right choice when trying to find the balance between stability, accuracy, and consistency.

One question I find interesting when thinking about this: if we 100% knew the timeline for Gen9 ending at the start of Gen9, would we have chosen now to freeze rises? Why or why not?

missangelic said:
BLs should not be tiered separately from the policy on freezing rises. Moving them up would make tiering incoherent by treating them differently because of the actions of a lower tier. More importantly, rising BLs rules out retesting them later on if they seem to no longer be banworthy. Tiers with and without frozen rises have tested Pokemon back in even after the Generation has ended. Also, as more Pokemon trickle back down, it’s not unlikely that some banned Pokemon might become easier to handle, especially ones that had Tera Blast as part of the reason why they were banned. The beneficial part of the freeze is that it gives councils and playerbases of the present and future more options to work with for making playing the tiers themselves enjoyable, and we don’t need to revert that because it’s Garchomp’s turn now that Tyranitar got off the carousel that waffles between OU and UUBL/UU.
I think a situation where a mon is RU by usage but able to be retested back to NU post generation is extremely incoherent from the perspective of adherence to usage based tiering. Allowing these edge cases under the guise of "gives councils and playerbases of the present and future more options to work with for making playing the tiers themselves enjoyable" is a departure into a lite version of VR based tiering, which I don't think is the intended outcome of the decision to freeze rises.

missangelic said:
The other problem is that ladder activity hit a generational low this last month (below 770k games in OU, when no other month has gone below 930k, the previous lowest). As ladders become less active, usage stats will start to skew even more, which makes those destabilizing rises even more likely to occur. We are still not seeing an end to the (now-averted) rises outnumbering drops, and those Pokemon that do break the threshold are only going to be less accurate representations of trends as the Generation winds down.
I agree fewer ladder games is a problem. It's a somewhat arbitrary metric though and we've never had a minimum amount of ladder games to decide whether usage based tiering is good enough, so I think trying to apply that now as a decision point is a little flimsy. The generation is also not winding down as it will be in the final 3 months - there are still two full SCL tournaments to take place in Gen9.

missangelic said:
I think it’s very difficult to accurately assess whether or not the freeze is doing its intended purpose when this is the first set of shifts it’s implemented - I think comparing to SS would help paint a bigger picture of what’s going to happen to SV, and I believe that we’ll better understand the implications of freezing long-term once we see the actualized effects of it, which I would like to analyze but it’s very late and I’ve nearly run out of battery typing on this.
The problem with waiting to see the full effects is we will never be able to undo the results. If there are multiple pokemon we decide "should" rise at the end of the generation based on usage, the argument will always be that we shouldn't do it because it creates too much instability while Gen10 rolls in. We need to make sensible decisions now otherwise we will just have to deal with the outcomes both good and bad.

Side note:
I find a lot of the debate on this topic tends to regress into essentially do you believe in usage based tiering vs do you believe in VR based tiering. It seems to me that at this point in the generation a certain number of people (impossible to know if it's a majority or a minority) have become frustrated with usage based and leaned more into VR based, perhaps driven by more frequent VR based tiers existing across the site. The application of the frozen rises across 4+ tiering shifts is both unprecedented and also essentially a large VR based experiment, as we've made the decision that every mon is appropriately tiered in SV and should never be in a higher tier. Given this, I'd suggest that if we are happy with that choice, we should also move to allow councils to force drop Pokemon that don't meet VR standards. There are numerous examples of this across SV and I don't think it's insane to suggest force drops, if we are happy with frozen rises. I find this comparison useful when thinking about the results / intentions behind what we are attempting to do
 
Django said:
I don't think it's been stated anywhere as an explicit goal for the tiering system to provide more drops than rises?
From "Tiering for Generation 8":
Hogg said:
So what does it mean to increase the tiering threshold? Well, the end result will be smaller tiers overall, where rises are less frequent but drops are more common.
The aim of the policy was an outcome, that outcome wasn't reached, and the current one is aiming to correct that.

Django said:
I think a situation where a mon is RU by usage but able to be retested back to NU post generation is extremely incoherent from the perspective of adherence to usage based tiering. Allowing these edge cases under the guise of "gives councils and playerbases of the present and future more options to work with for making playing the tiers themselves enjoyable" is a departure into a lite version of VR based tiering, which I don't think is the intended outcome of the decision to freeze rises.
As you outline, definitionally, that Pokemon would not be RU by usage but an NUBL Pokemon with decent usage on the RU ladder. That's because the definition of what is RU by usage would be "Pokemon that saw 4.52% on the RU ladder before rises were frozen".
Choosing to give lower tiers the power to ban something and therefore make it part of a tier above that it's reached a threshold in, something it would gain exception for as a BL, is definitionally a system that has lower tier council/playerbase veto votes, which has been rejected for tiering whenever it's been brought up. I get not being a fan of freezing, but I don't agree with likening it to "VR-based tiering" to disparage it when it's clearly and entirely a usage-based system.

Part of why I'm calling for people to bring forward comparisons to SS tiering is because I want people to:
1. See the effects of a freeze at the point SS had and whether or not they feel that served to improve the system at the end of the Generation and following its end - would people want do undo, redo, or adjust the freeze that Generation oversaw?
2. Develop a better understanding of what is coming down the pipeline for the rest of the Generation - was the tier shift was got just now similar or different than what we could expect, and what can we expect for the next one?
3. Create projections of what is going to happen when the comparative models can't be used - we'll be freezing for more shifts than in SS, so what should we expect when we reach that point?
 
missangelic said:
. That's because the definition of what is RU by usage would be "Pokemon that saw 4.52% on the RU ladder before rises were frozen".
just want to quickly point out that this is not actually correct. Freezing rises does in fact cause inaccurate representation of tiers, because a Pokemon that say above a 4.52% usage in RU for example is not actually RU by usage. Freezing rises does not change that, it’s just a compromise to favor stability in exchange for lower accuracy. Accepting this means accepting that some tiers are not going to be accurate representations of what usage stats say they are. Which is fine if that’s what people want, but trying to change what the definition of usage is with some of these arguments is a bit silly. If people want to freeze rises and keep them that way for now then ok, but let’s not get it twisted on why the decision was made and what usage based tiering is supposed to be reflect. It was made simply for stability purposes, not with any intent to change the definition of usage based tiering. The future of usage based tiering and what to do with it is its own separate topic, but not relevant to the discussion for this specific situation. The real question is whether or not the freeze decision was a bit premature given the time between that decision and when Gen 10 is released, as well as what happened with the Tera Blast ban.
 
missangelic said:
As you outline, definitionally, that Pokemon would not be RU by usage but an NUBL Pokemon with decent usage on the RU ladder. That's because the definition of what is RU by usage would be "Pokemon that saw 4.52% on the RU ladder before rises were frozen".
RU by usage is literally > 4.52%, there's no other definition to it.

missangelic said:
Choosing to give lower tiers the power to ban something and therefore make it part of a tier above that it's reached a threshold in, something it would gain exception for as a BL, is definitionally a system that has lower tier council/playerbase veto votes, which has been rejected for tiering whenever it's been brought up.
I've read this a few times and I don't understand it - where is the veto vote here? If we're talking about the situation where an NU mon which is RU by usage is voted to NUBL, and therefore bumped up to RU...fine? That is more accurate and has 0 impact on stability. On the other hand leaving a situation on the table where an RU by usage mon (currently with 0 guardrails - this could be 50% used in RU) is possible to be unbanned into NU is incoherent. That loophole should be removed.

missangelic said:
I get not being a fan of freezing, but I don't agree with likening it to "VR-based tiering" to disparage it when it's clearly and entirely a usage-based system.
It is not an entirely usage-based system - we've stopped using one half of usage based tiering. Pretending this is still entirely usage-based and hasn't had some level of subjective human choice (VR based) is silly. The intent here is not to disparge, but to be clear about the result of our decision so we can also look at whether it actually makes sense or not.

missangelic said:
Part of why I'm calling for people to bring forward comparisons to SS tiering is because I want people to:
1. See the effects of a freeze at the point SS had and whether or not they feel that served to improve the system at the end of the Generation and following its end - would people want do undo, redo, or adjust the freeze that Generation oversaw?
2. Develop a better understanding of what is coming down the pipeline for the rest of the Generation - was the tier shift was got just now similar or different than what we could expect, and what can we expect for the next one?
3. Create projections of what is going to happen when the comparative models can't be used - we'll be freezing for more shifts than in SS, so what should we expect when we reach that point?
It's extremely hard to answer these questions because we're in uncharted territory. I have no opinion on whether or not it was a good or a bad change as I wasn't involved at that point and so not qualified to comment. As for what's coming, the Tera blast ban makes it very difficult to say other than "more change than we would typically expect at this stage in the generation". Because of that, the only projection that really makes sense is that there will be more inaccuracy produced for the longer the tiers are frozen. I think it's important to either avoid that inaccuracy or deal with it after it arises. (hence the question in my original post reviving this topic: Do we need to change anything outside of the tiering system to handle the change in accuracy and consistency?)
 
Django said:
RU by usage is literally > 4.52%, there's no other definition to it.
This is not true. Just as an example, Entei was NUBL at the end of SS even though it saw greater than 4.52% usage in RU, and that’s because the definition of RU at the end of the Generation was as I described: Pokemon that saw 4.52% usage or greater prior to the freeze on rises. You’re free to not like that that’s the case, but it’s the objective definition for what the tiers were and continue to be.

This doesn’t stop being usage-based tiering just because rises are gone. It still depends on usage, and there’s no a subjective element where a tiering council or community picks and chooses what is or isn’t in the tier above them. If your issue is that the system itself is being decided upon by humans, then I have bad news, as usage-based tiering is already relying on non-objective, arbitrary metrics decided by people, such as whether or not 3.41% or 4.52% should be used as the cutoff, stats being weighted or unweighted by ELO or month, and the amount of time that cycles of shifts last for.
 
Django said:
Do the results we see above make sense to you? Should we be blocking these rises?
These results were completely expected, linking my post from a few months ago as evidence. I still hold the same position as back then, blocking rises was a mistake and the SV lower tiers placements are going to be representative of neither viability nor usage, which doesn't make much sense for our system.

Django said:
Are we optimising for the right metric at the right point in the generation e.g. stability over all else with 4+ tier shifts left
While last gen, the decision to freeze tiers was taken to avoid having to tier SS during SV. The current decision is to avoid having to tier SV during SV; this is the sign higher-ups have given up on tiering actively SV. Lower tier communities shouldn't be rotting, while waiting for WW release.

Django said:
If the answer to either of the above is "no" - what is the solution?
The previous thread already pointed fingers at many tier leaders not doing a sufficient job, or even being inactive. Many communities have checked out on the generation and are just waiting on SV to end, so things can change. Inactive council and tier leaders are what we should tackle right now, instead of comforting the false narrative that it is too late in the generation to have actual tiering. Even though many people won't like my solution, it is pretty simple; take your responsabilities and step up or resign; I've resigned myself earlier this year because I couldn't handle it anymore. Communities need active councils and leaders that take talk about the tier in community spaces (forums, rooms, discord) and actively play; those standards have been more or less outlined in a previous thread, but it had no actual impact on how lower tiers are managed.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top