dk said:this tier is better with sleep gone but it still has glaring issues. twave is still nonsense. trying to build around clef + tspikes, cm clef + spikes, cm clef + twave mag, etc is nonsense. there are times when they just run the right utility clef (like protect) and the matchup gets x10 dumber. i wouldn't want the variance of spore loom back for anything, but clef is just a cancer on this tier for lack of a better way to phrase it, and looms nerf made that far more obvious. jirachi's been complained about to death, but at least it's a hyper efficient glue for the tier.
I know for the esteemed tour contingent (that run tiering)---whose distribution of community involvement is 99% discord chatting and 1% actually playing---this may not matter much, but it would be nice if what could be easily the best singles OU had more visible proactivity in its tiering process
as much as i enjoy discord chatting i also play this tier quite frequently.
clef is on the menu for pokemon to watch out for, but i disagree that it is as broken as you say, even with variance in the combinations listed above. the absence of loom + machamp does bode well for clef, but i think their impact on its viability is a bit exaggerated. without those two pokemon, other fighting types (luke, ape, yama) and cbtar have seen a resurgence, all of which handle clef well. support clef has remained at about the same threshold of viability, if not slightly lower, than it was pre-spl. cm clef has definitely improved from its lowpoint of the last couple years, but i hesitate to deem it broken. if anything, it is a response to the stagnation of defensive teams which relied too much on phasing / their own clef to beat special attackers. already, people have realized that they can alter the makeup of stall to handle cm clef beyond a cm war mirror (e.g. roar hippo, encore quag, encore knock clef, trick on stall, haze, jirachi, cbtar defense, sd emp, and others).
regardless, clef is an
excellent pokemon and i would like to see how it develops during dpp cup. if it becomes too oppressive, i am fine w/ a suspect test for it. right now i don't see any massive issues with it.
i am against banning jirachi. jirachi's flinch-hax is obnoxious but greatly exaggerated in the modern meta. jirachi is a fantastic glue pokemon, but the days of wishtect being able to 6-0 offense are long gone. the tier has adopted surprisingly well to jirachi's orthodox sets the past few years, and with loom gone i actually think jirachi has become a little bit worse. ground types are more freely able to pivot in jirachi without worrying about an incoming spore. mie can switch into jirachi and twave it without being worried about loom's constant presence. zapdos also doesn't need to pick and choose b/t countering physical jirachi and loom anymore. metagross, gliscor, hippo, slowtran, and rotom are just a few of the pokemon that handle jirachi better w/o spore.