Worldie said:Guys let's not pretend Focus Punch was ever a good move. It was ran cause the other fighting options were beyond abysmal.
When your best coverage option is 75 BP that practically does less damage than your stabs, you take the risk of doing nothing if the payout is oneshotting on a good prediction.
Nobody would have ever ran Focus Punch if there was even a slightest alternative.
I'm not sure what makes so many people draw the conclusion that "less option = better gameplay", you're not making any "interesting choice" when there's no alternatives to choose from in first place.
There's basically a few ways things can shake out:
No good options. This is where pre-CC Fighting sat, with people using Brick Break, trying to make Focus Punch or Dynamic Punch work, or praising Arceus that they get High Jump Kick or similar(which still wasn't great). There's a lot of thought that you use making a moveset with this as your STAB, but the end result isn't really worth it. Currently enjoyed by Flying, physical Electric, and similar types.
A very limited set of similar good options. Currently how most Special types work. You can choose between TBolt, Thunder, or Discharge depending on circumstances, but it's basically always Thunderbolt and the factors that go into that decision aren't exactly complex.
One strictly-better option. Current status with CC as the only move anyone cares about and needing a strong justification to use anything else.
What is actually interesting from a gameplay perspective is a situation where there's multiple potent moves, but each one has trade-offs, so you decide which to use on a moveset based on meta/which mon it is/etc. And Fighting honestly feels close to that except for CC existing. Which is just wasteful. Why do Superpower, HJK, Sacred Sword, Storm Throw, etc exist? Just click Close Combat lol.