• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

(Little) Things that annoy you in Pokémon

I'd love for them to remove CC/Knock off from every fighting type so you guys can instead go complaining about fighting types should get more common coverage and base power moves :)

I stg, half of the time people complain that "rock doesn't have a accurate phys move, fighting and flying lacks a good special move, etc.." and the other half of the time it's "why is this stab attack so commonly distributed i wish it was rarer and pokemon had to deal with worse options".
 
Worldie said:
I'd love for them to remove CC/Knock off from every fighting type so you guys can instead go complaining about fighting types should get more common coverage and base power moves :)

I stg, half of the time people complain that "rock doesn't have a accurate phys move, fighting and flying lacks a good special move, etc.." and the other half of the time it's "why is this stab attack so commonly distributed i wish it was rarer and pokemon had to deal with worse options".
Then Knock Off shouldn’t be 65 BP on top of a power boost if the foe hold an item since the sixth Generation in the first place. Close Combat wouldn’t be so lambasted if it weren’t decided to be widely distributed over Superpower or High Jump Kick at the 8th Generation onward.

The problem is that these two moves are too good at their job (item removal + damage bonus if successful on that, relatively low-risk move for faster Pokémon, respectively) to be widely distributed like that, and that was the case for Scald and Toxic, too. Toxic made sense back then in RBY as Koga’s “secret ninja technique” but doesn’t age so well with some newer Pokémon having stronger defensive stats and type.

You don’t have to oppose one side or worse, oppose both, about move rebalancing or redistribution. Because these two sides have a point given that Pokémon is unbalanced as-is even with the fundamentals (monster-collecting turn-based RPG) in mind.
 
Last edited:
On the fighting move discussion, and ignoring signature/limited moves:

The Special types(except Grass) have a base-90, 100% accuracy Special move with near-universal availability for a broadly-distributed STAB. Their physical options are generally lower BP or else 120 BP with a major drawback. The Physical types roughly 50% of the time get the 90 BP no-drawback Special move, but also usually get a 120 BP Physical option with a drawback(recoil damage, low accuracy, etc). The weird thing is that Close Combat's drawback is so minor compared to the alternatives. No one complains about Brave Bird or Stone Edge being broadly distributed, after all.

And I'd be fine with them making that sort of thing an unofficial rule. There's an interesting dynamic you could push in the P/S split to encourage mons using that side of their STABs, while also pushing a dynamic of physical mons in general being powerful but riskier. The problem is they don't have a baseline for the drawbacks and haven't applied it evenly across types. Water gets Waterfall and Flip Turn, while Electric relies on Wild Charge. Fighting gets Close Combat and Focus Blast, Rock gets Stone Edge and Power Gem. There's no system, no logic you can rely on for what mons will have for their bread-and-butter moveset.
 
Hugin said:
On the fighting move discussion, and ignoring signature/limited moves:

The Special types(except Grass) have a base-90, 100% accuracy Special move with near-universal availability for a broadly-distributed STAB. Their physical options are generally lower BP or else 120 BP with a major drawback. The Physical types roughly 50% of the time get the 90 BP no-drawback Special move, but also usually get a 120 BP Physical option with a drawback(recoil damage, low accuracy, etc). The weird thing is that Close Combat's drawback is so minor compared to the alternatives. No one complains about Brave Bird or Stone Edge being broadly distributed, after all.

And I'd be fine with them making that sort of thing an unofficial rule. There's an interesting dynamic you could push in the P/S split to encourage mons using that side of their STABs, while also pushing a dynamic of physical mons in general being powerful but riskier. The problem is they don't have a baseline for the drawbacks and haven't applied it evenly across types. Water gets Waterfall and Flip Turn, while Electric relies on Wild Charge. Fighting gets Close Combat and Focus Blast, Rock gets Stone Edge and Power Gem. There's no system, no logic you can rely on for what mons will have for their bread-and-butter moveset.
One thing I wanna add to the CC vs Stone edge or Brave bird thing is that there is more powerful Fighting type attacks that were good but ultimately completely overshadowed by Close Combat.
High Jump Kick, Axe Kick, Super Power, Focus Punch, Dynamic Punch, Cross Chop, Hammer Arm, Jump Kick. There are so many 100+ BP attacks that Fighting type has, I’m pretty sure it’s the most out of all types.
But absolutely none of them are used because CCs defense drops are so much simpler to work around vs Recoil or an Attack/speed drop. Combined with everyone and their mother getting the attack and it becomes incredibly homogenous and rather dull
 
Last edited:
Hugin said:
On the fighting move discussion, and ignoring signature/limited moves:

The Special types(except Grass) have a base-90, 100% accuracy Special move with near-universal availability for a broadly-distributed STAB. Their physical options are generally lower BP or else 120 BP with a major drawback. The Physical types roughly 50% of the time get the 90 BP no-drawback Special move, but also usually get a 120 BP Physical option with a drawback(recoil damage, low accuracy, etc). The weird thing is that Close Combat's drawback is so minor compared to the alternatives. No one complains about Brave Bird or Stone Edge being broadly distributed, after all.

And I'd be fine with them making that sort of thing an unofficial rule. There's an interesting dynamic you could push in the P/S split to encourage mons using that side of their STABs, while also pushing a dynamic of physical mons in general being powerful but riskier. The problem is they don't have a baseline for the drawbacks and haven't applied it evenly across types. Water gets Waterfall and Flip Turn, while Electric relies on Wild Charge. Fighting gets Close Combat and Focus Blast, Rock gets Stone Edge and Power Gem. There's no system, no logic you can rely on for what mons will have for their bread-and-butter moveset.
Flavor is the name of the game in Pokémon, especially back in the first four generations, even at the expense of effectiveness. But it does help that Physical mons already feel more powerful but riskier due to the moves you mentioned (for the most part) as well as various deterrents such as Burn, Intimidate, and contact-punishing ones like Spiky Shield (move), Rough Skin + Iron Barbs (Abilities), Rocky Helmet (held item) and Static (Ability).

This lack of system does make it age poorly, not helping is the amount of overlaps we get overtime within a single type (hyper offense Electric, bulky pure Fighting, slow and defensive Rock or Ice with no Recovery, etc.) meaning the less need for “better” widely distributed moves of one type.
 
AztecCroc said:
Focus Punch was never good, it was only ever a gimmick with Substitute or After You.
It was never good as a STAB move but it's had value throughout the years as a way to catch Blissey/potentially other Fighting-weak pokes on switch in.

It's way more interesting than Close Combat, regardless. A perfect sort of TM move: easy to apply for flavor, with possible but not overbearing strategic use.
 
Guys let's not pretend Focus Punch was ever a good move. It was ran cause the other fighting options were beyond abysmal.
When your best coverage option is 75 BP that practically does less damage than your stabs, you take the risk of doing nothing if the payout is oneshotting on a good prediction.

Nobody would have ever ran Focus Punch if there was even a slightest alternative.

I'm not sure what makes so many people draw the conclusion that "less option = better gameplay", you're not making any "interesting choice" when there's no alternatives to choose from in first place.
 
Worldie said:
Guys let's not pretend Focus Punch was ever a good move. It was ran cause the other fighting options were beyond abysmal.
When your best coverage option is 75 BP that practically does less damage than your stabs, you take the risk of doing nothing if the payout is oneshotting on a good prediction.

Nobody would have ever ran Focus Punch if there was even a slightest alternative.

I'm not sure what makes so many people draw the conclusion that "less option = better gameplay", you're not making any "interesting choice" when there's no alternatives to choose from in first place.
There's basically a few ways things can shake out:
No good options. This is where pre-CC Fighting sat, with people using Brick Break, trying to make Focus Punch or Dynamic Punch work, or praising Arceus that they get High Jump Kick or similar(which still wasn't great). There's a lot of thought that you use making a moveset with this as your STAB, but the end result isn't really worth it. Currently enjoyed by Flying, physical Electric, and similar types.
A very limited set of similar good options. Currently how most Special types work. You can choose between TBolt, Thunder, or Discharge depending on circumstances, but it's basically always Thunderbolt and the factors that go into that decision aren't exactly complex.
One strictly-better option. Current status with CC as the only move anyone cares about and needing a strong justification to use anything else.

What is actually interesting from a gameplay perspective is a situation where there's multiple potent moves, but each one has trade-offs, so you decide which to use on a moveset based on meta/which mon it is/etc. And Fighting honestly feels close to that except for CC existing. Which is just wasteful. Why do Superpower, HJK, Sacred Sword, Storm Throw, etc exist? Just click Close Combat lol.
 
Hugin said:
There's basically a few ways things can shake out:
No good options. This is where pre-CC Fighting sat, with people using Brick Break, trying to make Focus Punch or Dynamic Punch work, or praising Arceus that they get High Jump Kick or similar(which still wasn't great). There's a lot of thought that you use making a moveset with this as your STAB, but the end result isn't really worth it. Currently enjoyed by Flying, physical Electric, and similar types.
A very limited set of similar good options. Currently how most Special types work. You can choose between TBolt, Thunder, or Discharge depending on circumstances, but it's basically always Thunderbolt and the factors that go into that decision aren't exactly complex.
One strictly-better option. Current status with CC as the only move anyone cares about and needing a strong justification to use anything else.

What is actually interesting from a gameplay perspective is a situation where there's multiple potent moves, but each one has trade-offs, so you decide which to use on a moveset based on meta/which mon it is/etc. And Fighting honestly feels close to that except for CC existing. Which is just wasteful. Why do Superpower, HJK, Sacred Sword, Storm Throw, etc exist? Just click Close Combat lol.
Sacred Sword is actually not a great example here, Gallade and the Musketeers are the only Fighting types to get both and non-Fighting types just expands to Zacian and Aegislash. And non-Mega Gallade actually does prefer Sacred Sword thanks to it being Sharpness boosted.

Storm Throw is similarly nonsensical to include here, even with it's guaranteed crit, it's barely stronger than Brick Break and pre-ZA was only learned by Throh, Pinsir, and Pangoro.

A lot of the Pokemon that previously only got High Jump Kick rather than Close Combat getting it in Gen 8 was probably both a preemptive overcorrection to GMax Orbeetle suddenly making Gravity a lot more accessible and just turning off the entire Jump Kick family and to the removal of regular Jump Kick and Karate Chop and Rolling Kick and Sky Uppercut and Wake Up Slap and Power-Up Punch suddenly leaving massive chunks of most of the more gracile Fighting types completely stabless for most of their learnsets and needing to be replaced with substitutes and then Gen 9 doubled down with additional cuts. Fighting was second only to Bug in how many of its moves were removed by Dexit.
 
AztecCroc said:
Sacred Sword is actually not a great example here, Gallade and the Musketeers are the only Fighting types to get both and non-Fighting types just expands to Zacian and Aegislash. And non-Mega Gallade actually does prefer Sacred Sword thanks to it being Sharpness boosted.

Storm Throw is similarly nonsensical to include here, even with it's guaranteed crit, it's barely stronger than Brick Break and pre-ZA was only learned by Throh, Pinsir, and Pangoro.

A lot of the Pokemon that previously only got High Jump Kick rather than Close Combat getting it in Gen 8 was probably both a preemptive overcorrection to GMax Orbeetle suddenly making Gravity a lot more accessible and just turning off the entire Jump Kick family and to the removal of regular Jump Kick and Karate Chop and Rolling Kick and Sky Uppercut and Wake Up Slap and Power-Up Punch suddenly leaving massive chunks of most of the more gracile Fighting types completely stabless for most of their learnsets and needing to be replaced with substitutes and then Gen 9 doubled down with additional cuts. Fighting was second only to Bug in how many of its moves were removed by Dexit.
Maybe this is just my over-familiarity with mons that have Flash Cannon, Iron Head, or Shadow Ball as their main STAB, but I have a hard time considering Brick Break or by comparison Storm Throw as unsalvageably weak. I do also think non-Sharpness Sacred Sword is worth noting since it has the potential to make those few mons more unique but isn't doing so because Close Combat is preferred. Aegislash especially is a mon I really don't like running CC: its entire gimmick is that it can pivot back to having its full defenses available after attacking.
 

I genuinely despise power creep as the main incentive to get new expansions in TCG formats. Or in general.

Mega Sharpedo was released just last month and is already filling job applications at McDonald's because Piplup is just a low-risk alternative but with worse stats.

Fuecoco has almost the same offensive presence as Buzzwole but with a lot less setup.

Mewtwo is hitting 140 for 3 like Mega Lucario with much better support, and hitting as two types, which has pretty much no downside in Pocket since there aren't resistances. It's crazy.
 
The beginning of this post reminded me that esoteric evolution methods are cute... the first time. Subsequent interactions with said methods can instantly become a major nuisance if you want to have multiples of Pokémon that require them.

Gholdengo immediately comes to mind (why do you have to collect 1000 coins each time), but it's also a huge annoyance if you want something like Kingambit or Palafin.

Additionally, I will include Trade Evos as part of this. It has been surprisingly hard for me to get ahold of friends to do them even with online trading because adults have jobs and lives and might reside in different time zones. This one is extra annoying to me since GF has shown they're willing to bend the rules of Trade Evos when convenient for them.
 
Last edited:
A few pet peeves about VGC:

-Why is it every time a spread move with a miss chance misses, the Pokémon that it misses is almost always the one I need to be hit the most?

-Why do people, despite being in a position that they will certainly without a doubt lose with no margin of error, still choose to click protect? Why? Like ATP you're just timer stalling and being a jerk.

-I hate Encore Whims so much dawg... Especially the mirror matches since I don't run Max Speed Whims.

-Ultra Ball Tier in Champions in general. I don't like it. I could get so close to Master Ball, then just have a losing streak screw it all over.
 
Protect and Detect in general are bad design TBH. I think protection moves should exist, but they should all have a whole category of moves that go around them. King's Shield and clones that protect against damaging moves, but not status moves, and inflict a problem if the attacker uses a contact move, are far better than a flat "you can do nothing to me" move. Not that those are great either, the problems are generally extremely punishing and lean towards making physical attackers worse, but there's something interesting there that doesn't exist with Protect/Detect.

And I'm not saying protection moves are too common. But the widely-distributed ones should be limited and able to be planned around, not just "wait 1 turn where nothing happens".
 
Hugin said:
Protect and Detect in general are bad design TBH. I think protection moves should exist, but they should all have a whole category of moves that go around them. King's Shield and clones that protect against damaging moves, but not status moves, and inflict a problem if the attacker uses a contact move, are far better than a flat "you can do nothing to me" move. Not that those are great either, the problems are generally extremely punishing and lean towards making physical attackers worse, but there's something interesting there that doesn't exist with Protect/Detect.

And I'm not saying protection moves are too common. But the widely-distributed ones should be limited and able to be planned around, not just "wait 1 turn where nothing happens".
You are able to plan around them, though. By reading the Protect and not attacking them this turn, either double-targeting their ally in doubles or setting up some kind of effect for free.
 
Also doubles would be practically unplayable without Protect, as Urshifu clearly shown last generation.

Now, we could easily delete the fact you have a chance to win the match if you click Protect twice in a row and just make it fail... That, that I'd be ok with. Game's already got enough RNG as is.
 
Worldie said:
Also doubles would be practically unplayable without Protect, as Urshifu clearly shown last generation.

Not true, Watershifu succeeded (on top of being a legendary with good STAB combo and coverage) specifically because everyone relied on Protect to stop powerful moves. If no one had Protect, Watershifu would be worse, though the meta would definetely become much more offensive (which in Doubles case is actually something I would like).

I like Protect and similar moves existing, but would like Protect not being an universal move. Universal moves, if powerful, make good Pokemon even better. Encore for example was a very cool move in the past when very few Mons learned it, but now that many good Mons learn it, why would people use Ludicolo when Iron Valiant or Ogerpon learn it too? Protect is the extreme offender of that, a lower distribution would be good in my opinion. It should still be more common than Spiky Shield, Baneful Bunker or Burning Bulwark, but not every single Mon should be learning it. The worse the Mon in Stats and typing, the better good moves it should have and viceversa.
 
Eeveeto said:
Not true, Watershifu succeeded (on top of being a legendary with good STAB combo and coverage) specifically because everyone relied on Protect to stop powerful moves. If no one had Protect, Watershifu would be worse, though the meta would definetely become much more offensive (which in Doubles case is actually something I would like).
People also universally hated Urshifu. Its ability got severely nerfed in Champions for a reason.
 
Recovery moves getting their PP almost universally cut to 5 in SV (not Wish, but it doesn't work immediately) but not Protect (when Detect has been at 5 since Gen 2, for some reason) was a questionable decision.

I'm undecided if Wish should also have its PP cut to 5. It would be more consistent, and as most users of it are quite bulky anyway, it would likely be better for balance.
 
What is the purpose of Take Down in the context of Gen 1's game design.

It is barely stronger than Body Slam with two downsides (recoil and imperfect accuracy). While I understand that some moves are intentionally designed to be weaker than others for the purposes of game progression, this doesn't really work for Take Down. The Body Slam TM is available before you can buy the Take Down TM in Celadon, and every Pokémon that learns Take Down naturally bar Growlithe does so in the 40s or higher. By the time those mons can learn the move, the HM for Strength will have become available as an easy access alternative with no downsides outside of being unable to be overwritten, but it's Gen 1 and the Pokémon movepools are weird so who cares.

The only upside I can think of for Take Down is the option for its TM to be infinitely purchased since it's in the Department Store. But again, Strength exists, and Normal isn't so in demand as coverage that you need to slap it on every party member anyway.

Later games would rectify the issues with Take Down by making it a fairly early level-up move for a lot of things like the Lilipup line in Gen 5, giving it an actual place in the progression system. But in the context of Gen 1 it makes no sense.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top