• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Unpopular opinions

Karxrida said:
Hidden Power was probably removed to prevent Dynamax Max Moves bullshit. There might have also been issues with programming it idk.
Worldie said:
Pretty sure the consensus is that it was removed because it was one of the top 2 reasons for hacking pokemon, expecially legendaries. Lord forbid you needed a legendary with more than a viable single hidden power.
To iterate on this:

Other than the whole hacking issue, I don't think it had to do with power level per se.

Hidden power was in fact a very poorly balanced move, most of the time useless except for extremely specific cases (hitting a 4x weak target usually).
Even as coverage, we're talking of a 60 BP non stab move, rarely worth the slot expecially in VGC, and also restricted to special attackers. There was never a real concern about Hidden Power being OP and you didn't really hear people complain about "omg i got sniped by random hidden power X", since usually the moveslot cost of running a very specific hidden power over another move was so high that you could usually know which mons are likely to run it (generally due to either having literally 0 coverage options, or by virtue of one of their counters being suspiciously 4x weak to something).

Meanwhile, they were not afraid to introduce "hidden power but better" in gen 9 as we all know.

So no, I am quite sure it was never a balance concern. Though I can buy the whole "don't want to give everything Max Airstream", there's a possibility that was part of the reason, I am quite confident the main reason was that it was basically a massive incentive to hack pokemon if you wanted to save your sanity and time.
 
Hidden Power for the record still actually does exist technically, it's just exclusive to Unown in Legends: Arceus (and BDSP).

And in Arceus it functions in a rather unique way that loosely mirrors Arceus's ability to change types both for itself and its signature move Judgment, and especially mirrors Legend Plate Arceus.

It was always only learnable by Unown naturally but now it's basically been repurposed into "Unown's signature move".
 
ScraftyIsTheBest said:
Hidden Power for the record still actually does exist technically, it's just exclusive to Unown in Legends: Arceus (and BDSP).

And in Arceus it functions in a rather unique way that loosely mirrors Arceus's ability to change types both for itself and its signature move Judgment, and especially mirrors Legend Plate Arceus.

It was always only learnable by Unown naturally but now it's basically been repurposed into "Unown's signature move".
I think in regards to Toxic and Hidden Power specifically it's worth considering that their cullings were not solely for balance reasons. Like Worldie said there was never anyone complaining about Hidden Power being OP or random snipes in key tournaments, and if it were just to restrict the options for Dynamax they would've brought it back in SV. I think Game Freak just decided that, whatever reasons they might've had once for making these moves universal, they didn't agree with them anymore and wanted to dial it back for flavor reasons more in line with how movepools are designed in the modern day. I find Legends Arceus Hidden Power's status as a buffed Unown signature move with the nice visual storytelling bit of functioning the same as Legend Plate Judgement more interesting, but that's just me
 
Unless I'm forgetting something, in the actual games, isn't Hidden Power always a Normal type move that just deals a different type's damage, instead of actually being the type itself (ie: A Normal move that does Ice damage, not an Ice move to begin with)? Unless there's some von-fuckery I'm unaware of I don't see why the move wouldn't be something other than Max Strike when Dynamaxed.


Okay I was curious and checked to see if Nature Power would change types when Dynamaxed cuz it's the only other move I could think of that could deal a different type of damage and it seemed to stay as its intended move when in Dynamax, though maybe it being a status move originally has some sort of effect on this? I don't know, wondering if if HP got axed because of dynamax seems like pointless speculation for a move that didn't really need to be as distributed as it was to begin with.
 
Worldie said:
I'm honestly not even sure that's the case.

They were taken off because they had some dumb interactions with QR codes in gen 7, where the shared team would have their friendship set at the original value of the pokemon, so they would never be able to be used correctly, and that was an actual issue as for tournaments they would have players share a QR of the team and use it on staff consoles, to avoid any kind of tampering (teams had to actually be legal to be accepted as QR codes by the system, so no cheating to be had - emphasis on "legal" and not "legit").
Even though that was no longer the case in gen 9, they probably decided it was fine as is and they did not add them back.


Pretty sure the consensus is that it was removed because it was one of the top 2 reasons for hacking pokemon, expecially legendaries. Lord forbid you needed a legendary with more than a viable single hidden power.
Also, more directly, happiness and affection were glued together in Gen 8, so to get max power Return, you'd need to break the cap on Amie nonsense.

Did Normal get any compensation? lol no. But that's most likely why.
 
Volt-Ikazuchi said:
Did Normal get any compensation? lol no. But that's most likely why.

Didn,t need to, though. Most Normal Mons learn Body Slam (17 points weaker but 30% para chance) or Double Edge (18 points stronger but with recoil). The only Normal type I can think of that got really fucked is Stoutland, who for some reason gets neither. Even then, a timely switch-in into WoW or a Scald burn means 140 power Facade. That or 140 power Retaliate after a teammate falls.
 
Eeveeto said:
Didn,t need to, though. Most Normal Mons learn Body Slam (17 points weaker but 30% para chance) or Double Edge (18 points stronger but with recoil). The only Normal type I can think of that got really fucked is Stoutland, who for some reason gets neither. Even then, a timely switch-in into WoW or a Scald burn means 140 power Facade. That or 140 power Retaliate after a teammate falls.
I don't agree. Check how many Normal mons ran Return for STAB as a drawback-free option that's as strong as EQ.
 
Volt-Ikazuchi said:
I don't agree. Check how many Normal mons ran Return for STAB as a drawback-free option that's as strong as EQ.
Not so much in recent Gens, at least in the competitive scene. When Sand (and Hail) was permanent, sure, recoil-less move was better than Double Edge. Hazards control was worse too, so every chip mattered. Remove (or nerf) that and Double Edge becomes much more attractive. Body Slam too, on bulkier Mons is better for longer battles to cripple something.

In the end it doesn,t matter though. Normal Mons have gradually become worse after Gen 2, so no purely attacking moves even appear, at least in OU. The most relevant Normal Mons after gen 2 have been Chansey and Blissey, and they don,t use offensive Normal moves for obvious reasons.
In lower Tiers, with less Sand, things are mixed:
https://www.smogon.com/dex/sm/pokemon/ambipom/ < Life Orb guy obviously prefers Return over Double Edge.
https://www.smogon.com/dex/sm/pokemon/snorlax/ < Snorlax, depending on the set uses all 3 of the moves and sometimes even Facade instead.
And so on.

In-game Return is superior, but that mainly comes from the TM being overall very easy to get. Normal Mons would use any Normal STAB, even Strength, when Return is for some reason unavailable. In-game Normal types are great, in both Nuzlockes and regular runs. Thats as far as they can get, though.

So, I don,t think losing Return was a big nerf. The big nerf already happened in Gen 3, when types diversity got higher (more Steels and Ghosts, for example), resistances started to matter, EVs stopped being able to be maxed for all Stats and Normal type became one of the worst, unable to be saved even by the good movepool most Normal types usually get. They got a small buff when Steel stopped resisting Ghost, but it was not enough.
The only Mon that really has been nerfed is the one I already mentioned, Stoutland. This dog was relevant in Sand, I have used it in both ORAS and SM. But without Return, Body Slam and Double Edge, is almost useless now. Maybe Tera could have saved it, but it got Dexited from Paldea (probably because they wanted to promote all the Paldean dogs and Hisuian Arcanine too) after a very poor perfomance in SS https://www.smogon.com/dex/ss/pokemon/stoutland/ (pretty sure you can make a better set than that, but not much).
 
Eeveeto said:
So, I don,t think losing Return was a big nerf.
Losing Return greatly impacted Snorlax's usage in VGC (and Snorlax was a very relevant mon during SuMo) because it now fails to secure a bunch of OHKOs it would have gotten otherwise. And it can't really run Double-Edge because it was primarily known for a Belly Drum set. Additionally, physical Normals now have to compete with Ursaluna, who is optimized as hell to run Guts-boosted STAB Facade and none can really close the damage gap.

Mega Pinsir has also turned into a complete bum in both formats because it obviously doesn't have Return any more and lost Double-Edge for some reason in Champions. Bro has to use Body Slam and it sucks.
 
Karxrida said:
Losing Return greatly impacted Snorlax's usage in VGC (and Snorlax was a very relevant mon during SuMo) because it now fails to secure a bunch of OHKOs it would have gotten otherwise. And it can't really run Double-Edge because it was primarily known for a Belly Drum set. Additionally, physical Normals now have to compete with Ursaluna, who is optimized as hell to run Guts-boosted STAB Facade and none can really close the damage gap.

Mega Pinsir has also turned into a complete bum in both formats because it obviously doesn't have Return any more and lost Double-Edge for some reason in Champions. Bro has to use Body Slam and it sucks.
This I think is what needs to be emphasized: unlike Toxic, Return was completely culled despite the clear existence of Pokemon that, intentionally or not, depend heavily on the move as their primary option (several "ate" users on Physical sets and Snorlax/Stoutland obviously the ones discussed). Return being removed for the Friendship/Affection overlap is not outlandish, but it would have been nice foresight to give relevant alternatives to the major users, be it a new move or reworking an existing one like Chip Away, Cut, Mega Punch, Strength (especially with the latter already having its distribution shaved down by HM removal), etc. to a similar Ballpark of a general-use 90-100 BP Normal attack with no/minor secondary effects.

In a way, I consider it a microcosm of TPC's shortcoming with balancing: they will frequently see problems in balance and address the Mon/Move, but at least 1/3 of the time, they don't account for knock on effects (Be it something they SHOULD care about or primarily a concern in some of the fan circles), whether collateral from the nerfed element, or ripple effects of a major influence being uprooted and things it checked/affected/competed with moving into the vacuum.
 
Karxrida said:
Losing Return greatly impacted Snorlax's usage in VGC (and Snorlax was a very relevant mon during SuMo) because it now fails to secure a bunch of OHKOs it would have gotten otherwise. And it can't really run Double-Edge because it was primarily known for a Belly Drum set. Additionally, physical Normals now have to compete with Ursaluna, who is optimized as hell to run Guts-boosted STAB Facade and none can really close the damage gap.

Mega Pinsir has also turned into a complete bum in both formats because it obviously doesn't have Return any more and lost Double-Edge for some reason in Champions. Bro has to use Body Slam and it sucks.

To be fair, I recently started using Facade Pinsir in SM cause not getting statused with that Mon while boosting is kinda hard. But yeah, for Pinsir it's a big nerf.
Still, Normal types were not nerfed that hard with Return lose, because 90% of them were already very bad to begin with, and not all of the rest used Return either.
 
Eeveeto said:
To be fair, I recently started using Facade Pinsir in SM cause not getting statused with that Mon while boosting is kinda hard. But yeah, for Pinsir it's a big nerf.
Still, Normal types were not nerfed that hard with Return lose, because 90% of them were already very bad to begin with, and not all of the rest used Return either.
With how bad the Normal type is just losing one Pokemon's viability from it alone is a massive deal.
 
pika pal said:
In a way, I consider it a microcosm of TPC's shortcoming with balancing: they will frequently see problems in balance and address the Mon/Move, but at least 1/3 of the time, they don't account for knock on effects (Be it something they SHOULD care about or primarily a concern in some of the fan circles), whether collateral from the nerfed element, or ripple effects of a major influence being uprooted and things it checked/affected/competed with moving into the vacuum.
Tbh I don't think it's not so much that they don't account it, but rather they don't care.

Say, Pinsir losing Return and Double Edge. Pinsir was never a viable mega for VGC, it would never really use Return in its base form either (I mean, I gueeeess it could if it really wanted) and unlikely it'd ever be viable in Champions.
So to them there wasn't really much to address, a unviable pokemon stayed unviable without the move.

While they do their own balancing, I think they have long accepted that in this game with close to 1200 pokemon+forms, most of them will be awful in competitive and still "work just fine" in the games because the games are easy anyway. So the collaterals are rarely a issue.
 
I think what makes the loss of return worse is how Normal types were are already precariously close to falling out of use like in SV OU and even Champions, but having a strong 102 attack is just so great for sustainability.
Now there’s nothing there to fill in the gap, there’s basically Zero normal types in OU right now, and out of all of the Normal types in Champions only Mousehold and Girafarig uses Normal STAB regularly. And the former has an attack that can deal up to 200 damage, and the latter is a special attacker and doesn’t care for Returns loss

Edit: forgot about Mega Lopunny in Champions and to specify SV OU
 
Last edited:
Castersvarog said:
Now there’s nothing there to fill in the gap, there’s basically Zero normal types in OU right now, and out of all of the Normal types in Champions only Mousehold and Girafarig uses Normal STAB regularly. And the former has an attack that can deal up to 200 damage, and the latter is a special attacker and doesn’t care for Returns loss
Be honest with yourself, even if Lopunny still had access to Return, it still probably wouldn't use it cause CC + Ice Spinner already hits everything she needs to it, and that's the end of the Champions viable normal types that would use Return.

Kangaskhan already has Double Edge and really needs the added power with the Parental Bond nerf, Salamence mostly runs monospecial and would *still* run Double Edge on the mixed sets for the added damage anyway.

Let not us pretend that the removal of Return had anything to do with normal types viability. It doesn't. Normal just doesn't cut it anymore as an offensive type unless it's backed by some very dumb gimmick (like Ursaluna's Facade+Guts shenenigans), because in 2026 not being able to hit anything supereffectively just doesn't cut it anymore.
 
Worldie said:
Be honest with yourself, even if Lopunny still had access to Return, it still probably wouldn't use it cause CC + Ice Spinner already hits everything she needs to it, and that's the end of the Champions viable normal types that would use Return.
Ice Spinner is 80 BP and also does not give MLopunny perfect coverage. 102 BP STAB is a notable step up from that, which is why MLop used to run exclusively STAB moves and support before Return was removed and it suddenly needed coverage options.
 
Hugin said:
Ice Spinner is 80 BP and also does not give MLopunny perfect coverage. 102 BP STAB is a notable step up from that, which is why MLop used to run exclusively STAB moves and support before Return was removed and it suddenly needed coverage options.
My point is that anything she doesn't want to hit with Close Combat currently is either weak or 4x weak to ice. So realistically you'd probably run Triple Axel regardless. And Triple Axel is actually 120 (assuming accuracy doesn't mess with you).

(idk why i said Ice Spinner, sorry i'm stupid)

I honestly don't think M-Lop would run Return in VGC even if it had it. In singles probably would, but we know they don't really care about these + I don't think M-Lop is that good in BSS anyway.
 
I am pretty grateful that Return was removed from Mega Salamence at least. While its double edge packs a punch, it still has a big drawback with the recoil which can add up with chip from other sources like Helmet or Rocks. This at least makes it easier to chip down into KO range where some priority begins to start threatening it. It winds up feeling more like a juiced up Charizard X as a result when running DD - to me anyways. You can run Facade as well which is cool to mimic those refresh sets back in Gen 6.

General solution for fixing weaker normal offense is giving all the normal types a wider array of Normal moves + buffing them appropriately. Moves like Mega Kick, Mega Punch could probably have their BP / accuracy increased respectively + given to more normal types. Moves like Facade are still amazing, and other moves like Retaliate probably could just be increased in BP in general just to give more scenarios where we click that move. I do actually like that Mega Lopunny is forced to use a normal move with consequences now as opposed to Return - given how much of a terror it would be with SD sets otherwise - but I do think Mega Kick should being something like 120 BP / 80 Acc or 120 / 85 Acc to match Power Whip or Gunk Shot. Rock Climb is cool but it could probably use a better BP / accuracy distrubution so that only tauros doesn't run it. Give mons like Unfezaunt & Stoutland Double Edge, Ambipom Tail Slap (IDK why they removed it in the first place), increase Hyper Drill distribution, etc. Most of those would go a much longer way I think in helping these normal types.

I don't really like how some of the new OP normal moves they made in gen 9 are like Blood Moon and Population Bomb. They did make good normal types in gen 9, but giving them OP tools like Ursaluna's crazy trading ability (with a truly obscene stat spread), bloodmoon having an unresisted STAB combo with its ability + Ground STAB & a broken move, or Maushold's 300 BP move that just farms any team w/o helmet wasn't the way.
 
ScraftyIsTheBest said:
It was always only learnable by Unown naturally but now it's basically been repurposed into "Unown's signature move".
Actually no, Slowking could learn it via Move Relearner from Gen 4 until it stopped existing in Gen 8, and the Meditite, Burmy, Shellos, Solosis, and Elgyem lines could have always been able to get it via level as well.

Gen 2 is the only generation prior to Gen 8 where only Unown got it via level.
Worldie said:
Salamence mostly runs monospecial and would *still* run Double Edge on the mixed sets for the added damage anyway.
Salamence mostly runs mono-special in Champions *because* it no longer gets Return and Double-Edge deals too much self-chip to be viable as a primary STAB.
 
Sqookblooks said:
My unpopular opinion is that Charizard is actually a really cool mon and has a very good design, and the fandom hatred for it has gotten extremely bland and super performative. Not every random Glup Shitto mon is going to see the light of day. Some mons are naturally going to be media darlings while others not so much.
In all fairness, Charizard is indeed a cool mon and a good design for resembling a dragon but not in an on-the-nose way. It was already popular back in RBY for those reasons.

Being media darlings is not bad by itself, but it can get to the point where one get so much new stuff at the expense of a Glup Shitto that could benefit a litle push, or worse, their own fellow Kanto starters in the case of Gen 8. That generation can be considered at being a media darling in the worst way possible, since overexposure can get people sick of it due to how artificial some of the new stuffs come across.

If they haven’t went overboard with Charizard back in Gen 6 + 7, Leon having Charizard as his ace wouldn’t be so controversial by adding overexposure on top of already blatant overexposure.
 
AztecCroc said:
Salamence mostly runs mono-special in Champions *because* it no longer gets Return and Double-Edge deals too much self-chip to be viable as a primary STAB.
People still use Double-Edge sometimes, especially since mixed sets can steal KOs and Coaching is a thing. Pure Special is largely due to a combination of Intimidate being super common in VGC and the set's ability to run better coverage.
 
AztecCroc said:
Salamence mostly runs mono-special in Champions *because* it no longer gets Return and Double-Edge deals too much self-chip to be viable as a primary STAB.
No, that is incorrect. It runs mono-special because Draco Meteor and Flamethrower are both valuable coverage moves and Hyper Voice lacks power after the nerfs. Running mono-physical makes you super vulnerable to the intimidate spam, and if you run mixed then you are kinda stuck in only running double flying stab with no coverage so you want the extra damage from Double Edge for the KOs (that return will not be picking up uninvested).
 
Back
Top