So, these kinds of posts are probably my least favorite to make here on Smogon for a couple of reasons, but I’ll bite the bullet. I should make it clear that my perspective likely isn’t unique among those who have already chimed in with their opinions previously — I haven’t read everything here thoroughly, but I skimmed over the thread enough to have a general idea of what’s going on — but ADV lower tiers are very near and dear to me, so I thought it wise to try and help make these tournaments the best I think they can be. Because apparently these sorts of things are about which crowd has the most amount of people being the most vocal about what they think, I guess.
Incidentally, I’ve played lower tiers in this year’s ADVPL, both editions of ADVLTL, and came up just short of ADV Slam playoffs last year, so I do have a vested interest and qualified stance on these matters, at least in my opinion. If you’re around in the ADV RU server, you may have seen me make a lot of these points there, and the only difference is that they’ll be a bit more coherent in this post.
the slam
Alright, I’ll start with what is probably the least contentious of my takes. I don’t want people to disregard this post too soon, after all. As with quite a few others, I don’t like the proposed format for ADV Slam. The idea is evidently that the tournament becomes more approachable for both the playerbase and hosts with the new format, but I think that logic is fundamentally flawed.
Regarding approachability for the players, I actually think the opposite effect would take form. Someone who is only interested in UU, for example, doesn’t want to play Ubers or NU or any other tier just so they can play one game of UU in their ADV Slam set. While I think the idea of being a [TIER] main isn’t as logically sound as being a [GENERATION] main, a ton of people on the site make that choice, and many of those people are at least mildly interested in ADV such that they participate in ADV slam just for their one tier (this, of course, is not specific to any one generation’s Slam tournament).
The natural increase in variance born of removing cups is also worth noting. I think double elimination is great, I think BO5 is great, I don’t think that necessarily makes for a great replacement here. If you lose in a cup for getting particularly unlucky, you have the other four (or, in ADV’s case, six) cups to salvage your points with. With one double elimination tournament, you only get to lose once while keeping any chance at a decent performance. Sure, BO5 formats can reduce the impact of RNG on a given set, but all else equal, nothing is stopping someone from critting you in game 5 in a BO5 just as often as they can crit you in game 3 of a BO3.
We can also examine the validity of the number of tournaments taking place with the current ADV Slam format. From a hosting point of view, I do understand the workload that seven cups demand; I don’t have a ton of experience hosting, but the few times I have helped with hosting a tournament, I learned just how exhausting that can be in some cases. However, the ADV community is large enough that, as an outsider looking in, I think you could certainly get enough people who are motivated enough to let ADV Slam, as it currently exists, run smoothly again this year and for many to come. (hell, I’d even volunteer to help out there if absolutely necessary; I care far too much about these lower tiers to let this tour die off on the insane off-chance that hosting is somehow the limiting factor)
I have heard points about players not wanting to enter seven tournaments just so they have the best odds at qualifying for playoffs, which is probably the fairest criticism yet. Beyond the exhaustion of playing in that many tours concurrently, it’s also obviously a sizable time commitment. Personally, I never found that to be a problem despite being occupied full time and having a life outside of Smogon, but this counterargument to the current Slam format could lead to a serious case for cutting down the total number of cups.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m glad ZU and LC have a spot where they’re both represented like this, even if I’m not terribly invested in either tier. I think it’s interesting that ADV is the only generation whose slam includes both ZU and LC (with some generations featuring neither), but as far as I’m aware, they are some of the less popular tiers among ADV players. If you were to make any changes to the ADV Slam format, I think downsizing in this way is the only one I’d be on board with. If you want even more of a case for that downsizing, it would make the current BO5 format of Slam playoffs easier to prep for since you know which tiers are viable for being played, even if the set does go to game 5.
Also, 5k reaction score as a prize doesn’t even come close to making up for how bastardized I think the proposed Slam format is. Maybe I’m the odd one out here, but I’ve never locked in for a tournament just because it has a reaction score prize. Let’s also not forget that this was all announced a week and a half before the scheduled start date of ADV Slam, with (to my knowledge) no notice ahead of time regarding the potential direction of the tournament. That somehow just adds to the reaction score prize feeling like jingling keys in front of ADV lower tier players’ faces, if that makes sense.
the premier
I originally planned to talk about my thoughts on ADVPL last because I probably have the hottest takes regarding it, but my stance on ADVLTL kinda requires me to set things up with ADVPL. Because we are on the internet, and more importantly we are on Smogon, I’m going to add the disclaimer that I, DONBONEJONES, AM NOT, NOR DO I ENDORSE TIERBASHING. ALL SMOGON FORMATS ARE EQUALLY VALID AND I DO NOT CARE WHICH ONES PEOPLE CHOOSE TO PLAY. THIS IS EXCLUSIVELY A CRITICISM OF THE PROPOPSED TOURNAMENT FORMATS FOR THE FOLLOWING YEAR(S). Alright, time to get some (more) people mad.
Let’s talk about why specifically most of the tiers got pruned from ADVPL. The OP states that this is due to most of them not being considered official by the end of ADV as a current generation, leaving only Ubers, OU, UU, and NU. I obviously wasn’t around on Smogon when ADV ceased being current, so I welcome anyone who was to correct me on this, but I’m pretty sure NU wasn’t even considered official at that point in time. Ok, sure, people may have played it as an ADV tier long before any of the other lower tiers came about, but I don’t see any logical reason to exclude other tiers at that point.
This makes the post almost seem like it’s contradicting itself, stating that “Ubers UU and NU were chosen for their historical inclusion in ADVPL, to avoid arbitrary decision making on tier inclusion”. If we want to discuss what is or isn’t arbitrary, we can call into question the idea of having tiers labeled as official (that’s right, we’re getting philosophical). If you want to look at this matter with any sense of objectivity, you should question what actually makes a tier official, because if it had anything to do with the pokemon that make up those tiers or the power levels, then RU would be official (or even UUBL by that logic, but I at least understand the thought process behind why that one isn’t official).
Also, I might be reading too much into things here, but the OP literally puts “official” in quotation marks under the ADVPL and ADVLTL section. It’s like these people know that a tier being “official” doesn’t practically mean anything. Strange
If you go by when exactly those tiers came into existence, then Ubers/OU/UU/NU definitely predate the other tiers, but NU and PU have been featured in teamtours for similar amounts of time anyway. After a bit of research, it seems ADV NU was first featured in a teamtour in NUPL 2016, whereas ADV PU’s first team tour was PUPL… 2017… that whole historical inclusion thing is holding up a bit less to me at this point.
The counterargument you’re likely thinking of at this point is that the actual historical inclusion nonsense is about the first two editions of ADVPL featuring only those tiers, then like… yeah? That is certainly true, but as more tiers got introduced into ADVPL over time (DOU in 2022, PU and LC in 2023-2026, and RU in 2024-2026), most players seemed to be fine with these changes. Scanning through ADVPL Format Discussion threads of years past, we see many cases of people saying the format was totally fine and didn’t need to be changed, or that only very minor changes were ideal to them. Of the limited amount of people I actually talk with on Smogon, none of those who have a vested interest in lower tiers and participated in ADVPL in any capacity said much, if anything, about needing to change the format.
I can’t fully speak to the managerial side of things, but it didn’t seem like there was an inherent struggle to field and prep a good lower tier lineup, especially from the perspective of my team (Degenerate Delibirds). It’s entirely possible that I’m advertising my lack of knowledge regarding how specifically the ADV playerbase felt about this year’s ADVPL, but given all of this context, I see no logical reason to change a format that most people were totally on board with.
Okay, sure, you wanted to cut down the number of OU slots in favor of increasing the average quality of OU games in the tour. I can’t speak to how much having five total OU slots affected that, but I at least understand where that sentiment comes from. What doesn’t make sense to me beyond arbitrary principle is the requirement of 50% of ADVPL’s slots being dedicated to OU. I see absolutely no reason that this specific metric is the case aside from sounding nice. To be clear, I have no problem with having a significant portion of [PREMIER LEAGUE]’s slots involving its respective current gen or OU metagame, but look at it this way: if we guarantee that OU gets four slots in next year’s ADVPL, the difference between four and six (or even eight but I understand that’s very ambitious) lower tier slots has no innate effect on the quality of those OU games. Does the (yet arbitrarily defined) prestige of ADVPL diminish due to greater inclusion of lower tiers? Honestly, I think you could make a solid case that the answer is yes, but I don’t know how exactly to make that case, and either way I don’t believe for a second that the prestige would diminish by very much, short of having like ten lower tier slots.
By the way, if we care so much about the “historical inclusion” of these tiers, why in the world is Draft in ADVPL? Yeah, I get that “It is also especially popular”, and Draft players are maybe louder than anyone else when it comes to getting their format into these tours, but you could have just as easily given that slot to another tier based on this criterion. To put it lightly, this feels selective, and plenty of other ADV tiers have just as dedicated followings as Draft (based on my experience with those tiers, I should make clear I am completely detached from Draft).
If having a break week to write PR’s while running the drafts is as major of a reason for its inclusion as the OP makes it out to be, then I must say I find it ridiculous that we are putting PR’s and that sort of content as such a high priority. We’re here to actually play the game, so that kind of stuff should be tertiary, maybe secondary matters compared to everything else. I may not be able to tierbash here (AND I’M NOT) but I can certainly PR-bash: I have never teamed with a single soul who’s seriously invested in PR’s and doesn’t help produce them. Maybe some of the spectators care a little about PR’s, and I highly doubt that number of people is as high as what the OP is written with in mind, but again, it feels like less focus on the game itself is being taken here.
I’m not calling for Draft to be removed from ADVPL, in fact I think it’s a fine addition to team tournaments, with DPPPL finding success including it in their format this year (even if Farc had to die for the cause…), but I just think if you’re going to include Draft in ADVPL despite your reasoning outlined elsewhere in the post, that should absolutely warrant at least two other unique lower tier slots.
going back to ou stuff…
SSPL, for example, has used a 12-slot format with 4 OU slots for the past two years, and I haven’t seen any major complaints about that from a significant amount of people. I’m really trying not to cross-reference generations here, but I think that’s a great example of how focusing on the number of OU slots rather than the percentage can still make for a great tournament.
Yes, I am aware “[t]he custom avatars of this subforum are meant to serve the ADV OU community”, but when an absolute bare minimum of 32 players will play OU in the next ADVPL, assuming we stick with four OU slots, that seems sufficient to me. Most other generation or tier premier leagues feature a similar number of slots for their current gen/OU metagame, and they seem to have no problem giving out custom avatars despite not meeting that 50% threshold. I don’t think you can tell me in good faith that ADV is particularly special such that the 50% rule has to apply to ADV but doesn’t have to for other subforums. Of course, I’m a lower tier player saying anything about OU, so I’ll be sure to take a drink for every haha react I get here as a result.
But seriously, with all of this context in mind, I have to ask:
the lower
Why does ADVLTL get a custom avatar exactly?
(if that question sounds a little out of context to you just read the last paragraph of the previous section)
Again, this just seems contradictory. I wouldn’t put it past myself to get too deep into semantics, but if these custom avatars are meant to “serve the ADV OU community”, then giving one to a lower tier tournament feels out of place. I have no issue giving a custom to ADVLTL; I think it’s a great tournament and people should be rewarded for their success in tiers like UUBL or ZU (yes ZU has other custom avatars but that’s not really the point I’m getting at anyway). I have issue with having your reason for changing ADVPL so drastically being derived from a custom avatar policy that falls apart when this tournament is considered. A player only interested in OU is not served by this in the slightest. If you’re going to move things around like that, I think a sounder reason is owed.
You could look at this with the idea that it’s a trade-off: ADVLTL gets a custom avatar, so ADVPL cuts down on lower tiers. Honestly, this is probably the most logical counterpoint to my criticisms here. With an even further projected increase in prestige of next year’s ADVLTL, we can more easily justify moving the higher-level competition in RU/PU/LC to that tournament. The people who play those tiers can still vie for a respectable prize, and ADVPL remains pure with only the most official tiers + Draft & Knuckles…
But it’s not like ADVPL was worse off for including those lower tiers. I wouldn’t say the prestige of winning ADVPL is much less, if at all, now compared to when it only featured Ubers/OU/UU/NU, especially given the amount of growth ADV has seen within the past few years. To me, it feels like trying to solve a problem that never existed in the first place, at least to most people.
However, I don’t find custom avatars nearly as interesting as the actual game, so let’s discuss the proposed format for ADVLTL. I think the idea of excluding Ubers/UU/NU due to their inclusion in ADVPL is very interesting, but this goes back to the issue of those tiers not having a negative effect on ADVLTL in the first place. Sure, cutting ADVLTL down to 10 slots does make things more difficult with deciding which of the many, many ADV lower tiers to include, but Ubers/UU/NU have at least just as dedicated playerbases as the other metagames competing for one of those slots.
I have outlined at the bottom of this post what would be my ideal tour formats for these tiers (without going totally scorched earth on ADVPL), but I think Ubers/UU/NU absolutely deserve a spot in ADVLTL. This would have what is potentially a drawback of reverting to the first ADVLTL format, and while I don’t have enough of a stake in the other tiers that would get snubbed as a result to say without bias, I don’t think this would be the end of the world.
On the subject of giving these metagames more chances to be played in team tournaments, I’d like to address a point made by THE_CHUNGLER regarding the quantity of games these tiers get. His post in particular stuck out to me due to how few other people were talking about that subject, and it’s a bit misrepresentative. His idea is that these tiers already get plenty of coverage in other team tournaments, but the way he cites them isn’t accurate.
“Ubers: UPL, UCL, UWC, UWL, ALTPL
UU: UUPL, UUCL, UUSRPG (or UUFPL), ALTPL
RU: RUPL, RUCL, RUWC, RUFL”
This is what I take issue with most because it inflates the apparent number of times these tiers get played. He mentions UWC and UWL for Ubers, but those tournaments have never both been run in the same year, as they both serve as the Winter team tournament for that subforum. Additionally, UCL uses a system similar to other farm leagues, restricting the amount of people that can play a given tier based on whether they played it in UPL so far that year. While this does let more people participate in team tournaments by playing those tiers, the quality of games does take a not insignificant hit, and while that’s not the biggest factor ever here, I think it should at least be considered if we’re going to look at this critically.
Same thing applies to RU, with RUCL and RUWC having never been held during the same year, and RUGL (not RUFL, a clear erratum) using the farm league system. UUSRPG and UUFPL also have no business being here, because neither tournament plays with standard ADV UU, allowing varying numbers of UUBL pokemon each year. Yes, these tiers get played in team tournaments year-round, but ADV subforum tours are a major contributor to that, and removing some of the more important tournaments for those tiers is a step backwards in my opinion.
the idea
For as much griping as I’ve done about these proposed changes, the whole point of this post and this thread is to be solution-oriented, so here are each of the tournaments (that I’ve discussed) in formats that I think are perfectly reasonable and improvements on what the OP suggests:
ADV Slam: keep unchanged, or maaaayyyyyybe get rid of ZU and/or LC if you deem such action absolutely necessary (which personally I don’t)
ADVPL: Ubers/OU Bo3/OU*3/UU/NU/Draft/Two of (RU/PU/LC, yes im aware making this choice will get one playerbase really mad)
ADVLTL: Ubers/UUBL/UU/RU/NU/PU/ZU/LC/DOU/ORRE
if you want to further discuss these matters with me my discord is moochem please friend request me and dm me there
thank you for reading