Karxrida said:Hidden Power was probably removed to prevent Dynamax Max Moves bullshit. There might have also been issues with programming it idk.
Worldie said:To iterate on this:Pretty sure the consensus is that it was removed because it was one of the top 2 reasons for hacking pokemon, expecially legendaries. Lord forbid you needed a legendary with more than a viable single hidden power.
Other than the whole hacking issue, I don't think it had to do with power level per se.
Hidden power was in fact a very poorly balanced move, most of the time useless except for extremely specific cases (hitting a 4x weak target usually).
Even as coverage, we're talking of a 60 BP non stab move, rarely worth the slot expecially in VGC, and also restricted to special attackers. There was never a real concern about Hidden Power being OP and you didn't really hear people complain about "omg i got sniped by random hidden power X", since usually the moveslot cost of running a very specific hidden power over another move was so high that you could usually know which mons are likely to run it (generally due to either having literally 0 coverage options, or by virtue of one of their counters being suspiciously 4x weak to something).
Meanwhile, they were not afraid to introduce "hidden power but better" in gen 9 as we all know.
So no, I am quite sure it was never a balance concern. Though I can buy the whole "don't want to give everything Max Airstream", there's a possibility that was part of the reason, I am quite confident the main reason was that it was basically a massive incentive to hack pokemon if you wanted to save your sanity and time.








