Today I'm going to talk about a very small detail that very well may not have been intentional, but I really hope it is and if it is I think it's very cool.
So, as you probably know, one of the big moments in Pokemon Platinum is the appearance of Giratina at Spear Pillar. For the two of you who don't know, Cyrus is up there with his plan to create a new universe and destroy the old one, using Dialga and Palkia which he has taken control of with the Red Chain. Before he can do this however, Giratina appears and sucks him into the Distortion World.
This is a very cool moment, but a question that it brings is of course, why? And the official answer seems to be a bit disappointing. I asked why Giratina did this a while back in the Mysteries and Conspiracies of Pokemon thread, and the answer I got was that Giratina intervened not to protect its siblings or to save the world, but because Cyrus' plan endangered the distortion world too.
But when watching the cutscene again, I noticed something that suggests another motivation. Now, I'm not disputing that Giratina showed up to protect the Distortion World. But when looking at how exactly this all goes down, it seems to suggest another layer to Giratina's character.
So, let's set the stage. Cyrus is doing his thing, going on how his dream will finally be achieved. Then, the world darkens, and Cyrus says "What is this presence I feel...? Something... is enraged?" And then Giratina slowly emerges from shadow. This is clearly very big. Dialga and Palkia, despite apparently being under the control of the Red Chain, step back, as does Cyrus despite his attempt to put on a calm demeanor. We can see a wave emerge from Giratina's protrusion into this reality. Giratina is evidently very powerful, and a force that is very clearly feared. Even before Giratina made its entrance to this dimension, Cyrus could feel how it was enraged.
But I need to emphasize what exactly its vibe is right now. Giratina is clearly displayed as an eldritch, shadowy force that you should fear. But what isn't clear is its intentions. Yes, Cyrus felt it was enraged, but aside from that, nothing really suggests Giratina has any ill intentions here. The scary part is Giratina's existence, not what Giratina plans to do. Giratina has this aura just by appearing, and isn't evidently hostile yet. Look at its body language.
View attachment 858373
It isn't taking any action yet. It's more observing than anything. Cyrus does pick up on its intentions to stop him because... I mean why else would it be here? Then, Giratina stands out more, and manifests its wings, as if it's trying to take foot in this world.
View attachment 858374
It's just staring at Cyrus, not taking any action. And the music seems to reinforce this.
This music isn't exactly inviting, but it also isn't that of an active threat. It is off-putting, it is bizarre, it is alien, it is scary, but it is not actively hostile. This is the theme of a powerful otherworldly force that is imposing and dangerous, but not that of one that necessarily has any bad intentions. It is the rumbling of the storm on the horizon, but the storm is not here yet.
And I am emphasizing the fact that very little conveys that Giratina is aggressive here, because very shortly this completely changes. When Giratina appears, Cyrus goes "Interesting. So there is a Pokemon that can only appear as shadow." Then Giratina spreads its wings. And pay very close attention to what happens next. Cyrus says "Regardless, the effort is rash and foolish. I have harnessed the powers of DIALGA and PALKIA..."
And that is where the statement cuts off. As evidenced by the ellipsis, it seems as if Cyrus wasn't finished with his thought. Because as soon as he says the names of Giratina's siblings, a very noticeable shift happens.
This track starts to play. First of all, the fact that this track exists is noteworthy in my opinion. The developers deemed it necessary to have two different tracks for Giratina's entrance. And this track is also different from the previous one. Unlike it, this track is more active and immediately threatening. There is action in it. There is a distinctly different type of fear in it. This is not the theme of Giratina's entrance. This is the theme of Giratina going on the attack. And indeed, at the very same time this track plays, Giratina's demeanor changes.
View attachment 858394
For some reason, it seemingly backpedals on the idea of having wings. Instead, it shapes the appendages into something more resembling hands, with the points being arranged at the end. At the same time, Giratina leans in toward Cyrus. There is very clearly a change here. Giratina went from observing and trying to enter the reality to very clearly readying to attack. And this time, Giratina does not wait for Cyrus to finish his thought, or as far as I can tell even the player to press the button to proceed, before attacking. This further suggests that before Giratina was watching and observing, but now Giratina is going on an offensive. And this change happened on a dime specifically after Cyrus talked about how he was controlling Dialga and Palkia. Is it possible this was all unintentional and a coincidence? Yes. But I believe that this seems a little too deliberate to be unintentional. I believe this may be an intentional story decision that suggests Giratina's attack was a reaction to Cyrus capturing its siblings. And I think this small detail that suggests more depths to Giratina's character is rather neat.