• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Smalltown Hotel Mafia v2 Won by the Town - Postgame Up!

and even if they did on n1 what i think they did i think targeting genisu on n2 is a challenging play to compliment

OTOH like it kinda worked out i dont think des was getting voted this game, and poisoner's a strong role in the situation. they prob should have shot des to start with bc her being protected would've been hard to predict lol
 
SirFish said:
Maybe this is where I am a bit confused, or just disagree I guess?

We have only two nights worth of data on the Mafia actions, and one was seemingly blocked, the other was bussed.

You are talking about like suboptimal plays on two nights worth of data, but both those nights something happened that changed the outcome, which is to be expected when lots of roles and unknowns are at play. I guess my point here is like, you are operating off a lot of assumptions and then pointing fingers at people you are trying to fit into the narrative you are building, which I get is like kind of the game, but it feels like you are treating opinions as facts a bit.
its like attacking the failsafe of machinery and thinking it will disrupt it, would you argue that the person attacking it had experience with the machinery?
 
Peum said:
I've said thrice already that you're using your role suboptimally
I dont even know how I would supposed to use it optimally? You say I'm supposed to essentially direct traffic? I dont want to die early my first game back in 10 years? I don't even know half the terms.
 
King_ said:
I dont even know how I would supposed to use it optimally? You say I'm supposed to essentially direct traffic? I dont want to die early my first game back in 10 years? I don't even know half the terms.
the bulletproof role has to basically ragebait mafia enough so that they consider attacking them
 
Peum said:
its like attacking the failsafe of machinery and thinking it will disrupt it, would you argue that the person attacking it had experience with the machinery?
I mean no, but I also think this is not a good faith argument point. You are equating two different things together and then saying this machinery bit as a way to affirm your point.
 
SirFish said:
I mean no, but I also think this is not a good faith argument point. You are equating two different things together and then saying this machinery bit as a way to affirm your point.
I dont want to help mafia by saying it outloud but there's a clear order that the mafia kills should be
 
Peum said:
I dont want to help mafia by saying it outloud but there's a clear order that the mafia kills should be
(he's right this is why peum is town)

it's fully reasonable to approach the game eliminating people who i think would quite easily discern the optimal strategy from the scumpool im kinda doing the same

but i don't think there's a way to use that to come up with targets, there are too many people who wouldn't easily discern the optimal strategy and that's also fine
 
also what peum said earlier about scum having no reason to kill genisu if i'm scum because there's a near 0% chance genisu targets me due to not wanting to give me an ability so i can freely kill carry and tracker becomes useless is correct so he's town for that

shame people are voting me lol pulsar512b do u acc have a scumread bc u voted me while saying im not scum
 
only potential +scum thing is chickening might be scum for targeting in a way that demonstrates they also don't understand scum's optimal kill strategy, des being a better kill target than genisu anyway tbh

but that would require a scumteam who didn't realise bus drive + kill target clears whoever it's directed off of unless bus driver and kill target are scum together

which means we prob have to vote chickening at some point to confirm it

if chickening's town they seem in the same headspace as scum on kills tho so we wanna keep them around for more clears lol
 
For someone who seemingly has so much knowledge on how to play and optimal strats, your best push is on the noobtown for not playing correctly/optimally and not being outspoken to bait a mafia shot. Personally I think your insistent push on me is even more suboptimal gameplay. I guess you could be trying to get me voted so you don't take 2 nights to take out a noobtown bpv.

Vote Peum
 
Celever said:
also what peum said earlier about scum having no reason to kill genisu if i'm scum because there's a near 0% chance genisu targets me due to not wanting to give me an ability so i can freely kill carry and tracker becomes useless is correct so he's town for that

shame people are voting me lol pulsar512b do u acc have a scumread bc u voted me while saying im not scum
actually i hate this because i have a good reason to target you, if ur scum i have a chance to pick up on a kill and if ur town we just got another townsided action
 
Celever said:
only potential +scum thing is chickening might be scum for targeting in a way that demonstrates they also don't understand scum's optimal kill strategy, des being a better kill target than genisu anyway tbh

but that would require a scumteam who didn't realise bus drive + kill target clears whoever it's directed off of unless bus driver and kill target are scum together

which means we prob have to vote chickening at some point to confirm it

if chickening's town they seem in the same headspace as scum on kills tho so we wanna keep them around for more clears lol
im not going to vote chickening unless they make a scumsided bus
 
genisu said:
actually i hate this because i have a good reason to target you, if ur scum i have a chance to pick up on a kill and if ur town we just got another townsided action
i mean i agree with you but it's a question of whether you would do that

you haven't yet we've had 3 nights!

i think in practice it felt like u wouldnt target me especially if you hadnt for the first 2 nights
 
there's not actually a major cost to giving scum a tracker usage because everyone's actions are being claimed in-thread anyway so they're not gonna learn much from it

maybe they would just use it on chickening to make sure their fake claims were correct? but idk if they actually need a tracker for that idt they do
 
King_ said:
is the reason for pulsar pretty much just cus he's inactive?
idt it's just cos she's inactive it's more so that she hasn't contributed a theory yet

which are diff cos u can be broadly inactive but provide real theories when you're around
 
Back
Top