Charlie0108 said:I really like the attempts to diversify Normal type over the last 4 gens but I do get confused as to what a Normal type is actually supposed to be now.
For example, what differentiates Deerling and Sawsbuck from Skiddo and Gogoat? They’re both ungulates with Grass elements so why is one Normal and the other isn’t?
What makes Helioptile and Heliolisk Normal? Similar with Cyclizar, what make that Normal?
And the most confusing of all, why are Smoli, Dolliv and Arboliva Normal?
I appreciate the answer it most likely just ‘because we wanted to and it would be good for game balance reasons’ but I’d still like to understand what exactly Normal is meant to be!
There's two types of normal mons, "Just an animal" and "gimmick".* And for most of the early generations, these two categories were very difficult to combine with any other types. Ignoring mons whose type changed later(and birds), pre-Unova, the only dual-type normal is
Girafarig.
Then Unova, with
Bibarel,
Deerling/Sawsbuck, and
Meloetta. Meloetta and Deerling/Sawsbuck are pretty clearly gimmicks which gets them the normal type, and Bibarel evolves from a pure-normal. All justifiable, but I think this was an experimental shift in design philosophy that they liked.
And then Kalos happens.
Litleo/Pyroar,
Helioptile/Heliolisk,
Diggersby. All justifiable, sure, but definitely stretching the gimmick definition somewhat to justify the normal type. They also added a bunch of additional types to previously normal pokemon here(
Mega-Lopunny,
Igglybuff/Jigglypuff/Wigglytuff,
Azurill,
Mega-Audino). Again, you can argue it's justified since they don't want to 100% change something's typing(even though they also did that with other fairy mons), but it's suddenly 11 part-normal lines instead of 4.
Since then, Gen 7 added
Aloalan Rattata/Raticate,
Stufful/Bewear,
Orangruru, and
Drampa. Gen 8 gave us
Galarian Zigzagoon/Linoone/Obstagoon,
Indeedee,
Hisuian Zorua/Zoroark, and
Wyrdeer. And Gen 9 gave us
Ursaluna,
Smoliv/Dolliv/Arboliva,
Shroodle/Grafaiai,
Farigiraf, and
Cyclizar.
Yeah, listed like that it's pretty clear. They NEVER did Normal/Anything except Flying for the first 4 gens. Then they added 3 pretty safe options in Gen 5, liked the result, added a bunch Gen 6(many tied to Megas or the new Fairy type), and then went with 4ish lines per gen after that. So I think you really can't compare a dual normal/anything from Gen 7+ to a monotype from Gen 5 or earlier and find a logical difference, the explanation is that the devs were afraid to try something and then changed their minds.
*Also Normal/Flying, which I will be ignoring throughout this post because that's a whole other discussion.