So corny of me to have this post be longer than my original, but whatever. I want this pokemon unbanned.
My general arguments for the tl;drs are: 1) it checks most currently trending pokemon, making team composition less top-heavy 2) it's not as OP like before with tera blast that it can even play around zama/ 3) it checks most hyper offense which is always a good thing 4) balanced teams can properly deal with it now
But i'll go further and say that it actually de-centralizes the meta now, at least given the current meta trends that Roaring Moon does check. I'll expound further in the next quote.
My general arguments for the tl;drs are: 1) it checks most currently trending pokemon, making team composition less top-heavy 2) it's not as OP like before with tera blast that it can even play around zama/ 3) it checks most hyper offense which is always a good thing 4) balanced teams can properly deal with it now
moore's law said:I disagree with your characterization of my post. I wasn't arguing (indirectly?) for centralization per se, just that balance can deal with Roaring Moon just fine now.I don't think this helps your argument as much as you think it does. You are arguing for centralization around a few defensive pieces.
But i'll go further and say that it actually de-centralizes the meta now, at least given the current meta trends that Roaring Moon does check. I'll expound further in the next quote.
moore's law said:- Each and every one of these can be beaten by Taunt or Sub Moon. Moltres and Zap are food for Moon, what do they even do against it if it taunts them or sets up a sub? Moltres can't roar (if taunt) or wisp it, and flamethrower does pathetic damage.
- I haven't seen the sub sets that often. But if they have either taunt or sub, that is more likely to be an invested phys def/max HP set with less attack/speed investment.
It'll be Sub/Taunt, DD, (your choice of Knock off, Acrobatics, Earthquake, Dragon Claw, Jaw Lock). Even at +1 proto they seem to be very counter-able now.
- Back then a lot of people complained about the bulky tera fairy sets, because they could even 2HKO the pokemon that would normally counter them (zamazenta/ting lu), which just makes it less counter-able then.
- (To go back to my earlier point), in this current meta though, Roaring Moon is checking a lot of currently trending Pokemon while at the same time not able to overpower past even their own checks:
- It checks currently trending pokemon like Ceruledge. Ceruledge is surprisingly good vs. most special attackers right now, especially if you get Weak Armor's eff off.
- In general, there has been a trending prevalence of special attackers. Special Attackers usually don't have Phys Def Bulk (exception Iron Valiant which is more of a mixed attacker). Not sure if this is an argument for or against making Roaring Moon more centralized, but at least it disrupts the meta in that fashion and makes physical attackers the wave again.
- It will need at least 366 speed to be faster than Iron Valiant, so if you have Valiant with the proto speed boost (most common set), you should be able to at least stop Roaring Moon from setting up if not putting it within OHKO range of your priority attacker. Iron Valiant has around 200 base defense at level 100, so it is playable even with Roaring Moon at +1 and proto ATK.
I've also been seeing Scarf Valiant much more often at around the 1500s-1700s. Not sure if that was because of Roaring Moon or it's just trending, but Roaring Moon can't really do anything about it after the proto use.
- It checks currently the trending pokemon Cresselia somewhat, or at least chips it down significantly. Roaring Moon's SPD is pretty good, and at least makes it so that Cresselia would need to set up to +2 to just straight up OHKO Roaring Moon on a tera. Even without Tera, they have Moonblast like 25% of the time, and Ice Beam like 30% of the time (citation needed but Calcdex has proof).
- Right now, Screens Zamazenta is trending so him and Roaring Moon don't even interact that much. But if First Turn Roaring Moon were to happen in that scenario, Screens Zama is usually max speed so there's 0 chance of a 2HKO with a proto-boosted Roaring Moon, because Reflect would be up already. So that's a counter to Roaring Moon that is still very viable.
- Scarf Gholdengo has been very prevalent recently (personal anecdote). At least now the Razzle Dazzling Gleam will have to be their 4th move instead of something like Nasty Plot/Thunder Wave, moves which IMO makes it more annoying and harder to deal with.
- It checks currently trending pokemon like Ceruledge. Ceruledge is surprisingly good vs. most special attackers right now, especially if you get Weak Armor's eff off.
- With all things above being true, that is, in my opinion, a more varied meta than what we have now.
Last edited:














