Ok I owe you guys some elaboration.
I'll start with the two easy ones: Milotic and Moltres (since some people actually borderline agree).
Milotic:
The reason I want to nominate Milotic is that it is consistently the hardest Pokemon to take out, but that our current defensive characteristic makes it too hard to nominate. We have nominated and banned Pokemon such as Cresselia, who may have been broken under the defensive characteristic, but I still think it was mainly banned because of the SubCM set. Milotic doesn't have some crazy stat boosting move to sweep a team with, so Cresselia is not the best comparison despite their similarity as mainly defensive Pokemon.
I think we should look at Milotic compared to Crobat. Crobat was banned even though there wasn't really a definite characteristic for them (we just called it support and offensive). Crobat checked an absurd amount of Pokemon and could pull off a sweep late game. Milotic isn't that different. It exchanges its ability to sweep to check even more Pokemon across the board, where as Crobat only checked specific ones (even if it was a lot). Crobat was destroyed by Pokemon such as Regirock. The only offensive Pokemon that can safely switch into Milotic is Synthesis LO Venusaur, otherwise it's base 100 SpA hits too hard for others, or they risk getting hit by Toxic. So with Crobat in mind, I think Milotic should be the first Pokemon to be nominated purely under the defensive characteristic.
Why now? Well Raikou's gone and easy Spikes are gone. Those were the two things keeping Milotic at bay in my opinion.
Moltres:
There's not much I can say about Moltres that isn't common knowledge, but its combination of bulk, Speed, and power is simply too much. I think we should compare it to Shaymin. The similarities of Moltres's most powerful set and Shaymin's most powerful set are too hard to ignore, they both ran a 120 BP STAB move, Air Slash, a coverage move, and a recovery move accompanied by Life Orb. In fact, it's hard to argue that Shaymin was that much better than Moltres. Let's look at their relevant base stats:
HP / Def / SpA / SpD / Speed
Moltres: 90 / 90 / 125 / 85 / 90
Shaymin: 100 / 100 / 100 / 100 / 100
While Shaymin has a mere 10 base stat points over the majority of Moltres's utility stats, Moltres packs a whopping 25 Base SpA points over Shaymin. This is amplified by the fact that STAB Fire moves are far better than STAB Grass moves, and Moltres's Air Slash hits even harder because it gets STAB (in addition to the 25 extra Base SpA). Shaymin is obviously tougher to take down and poses a major threat with Seed Flare's secondary effect, but it is hard to argue that Moltres isn't close behind.
The main thing holding Moltres back is Stealth Rock, but this round Rapid Spinning got much easier. There is no effective way to run Spikestack + Double Ghost, and in my opinion it's simply not worth it for just Stealth Rock. The fastest Spin Blockers are undeniably frail, and Spiritomb is still Spiritomb, it's going to lose to the same Pokemon as it always does, and it's hit by Spikes.
With Shaymin in mind, I think Moltres deserves another nomination under the offensive characteristic.
Why Now? Moltres's main check, Raikou, is no longer around to stop it from destroying offense, and stall is still semi-easy to Spike against.
Torterra:
Torterra deserves a mention at the very least because it functions a lot like Raikou for me (which sounds stupid, but let me explain). Raikou was too hard to stop because it set up Calm Minds on special attacks, and physical priority moves don't even 2HKO it. Torterra has exceptional bulk, moreso than Raikou, and it takes even less damage from priority. Torterra has many chances to set up Rock Polish, and after this there are far too few Pokemon who can beat it on offense. This was the issue with Raikou, you were forced to use stupid shit like Scarf Venusaur Earthquake to beat it. While Scarf HP Ice Rotom isn't as stupid as Scarf Venusaur, it is not a hard argument to make that HP Ice Rotom is dumb.
I mean, I don't think I'd actually vote Torterra BL, but I would kind of like to discuss why Torterra always seems to be the most dangerous sweeper in the metagame, as if it's anti-metagame.
I'll respond to some counter-arguments:
Listing two Pokemon that are easily passable through other means does not mean much (think: Raikou).
Forcing Moltres out isn't really that big of a deal, but Raikou could switch in and KO it, or come in on the revenge kill and actually set up on it. None of these Pokemon can do that. Even if you predict right, Manectric is still 2HKOed by Moltres. Fire Blast OHKOes all of the Pokemon you listed, unlike Raikou. CB azumarill is the only exception, but if you've used it you really dislike using CB Aqua Jet as a crutch.
You listed one Pokemon that can switch into Milotic safely and force it out. I don't see how this proves anything against Milotic.
I'll start with the two easy ones: Milotic and Moltres (since some people actually borderline agree).
Milotic:
The reason I want to nominate Milotic is that it is consistently the hardest Pokemon to take out, but that our current defensive characteristic makes it too hard to nominate. We have nominated and banned Pokemon such as Cresselia, who may have been broken under the defensive characteristic, but I still think it was mainly banned because of the SubCM set. Milotic doesn't have some crazy stat boosting move to sweep a team with, so Cresselia is not the best comparison despite their similarity as mainly defensive Pokemon.
I think we should look at Milotic compared to Crobat. Crobat was banned even though there wasn't really a definite characteristic for them (we just called it support and offensive). Crobat checked an absurd amount of Pokemon and could pull off a sweep late game. Milotic isn't that different. It exchanges its ability to sweep to check even more Pokemon across the board, where as Crobat only checked specific ones (even if it was a lot). Crobat was destroyed by Pokemon such as Regirock. The only offensive Pokemon that can safely switch into Milotic is Synthesis LO Venusaur, otherwise it's base 100 SpA hits too hard for others, or they risk getting hit by Toxic. So with Crobat in mind, I think Milotic should be the first Pokemon to be nominated purely under the defensive characteristic.
Why now? Well Raikou's gone and easy Spikes are gone. Those were the two things keeping Milotic at bay in my opinion.
Moltres:
There's not much I can say about Moltres that isn't common knowledge, but its combination of bulk, Speed, and power is simply too much. I think we should compare it to Shaymin. The similarities of Moltres's most powerful set and Shaymin's most powerful set are too hard to ignore, they both ran a 120 BP STAB move, Air Slash, a coverage move, and a recovery move accompanied by Life Orb. In fact, it's hard to argue that Shaymin was that much better than Moltres. Let's look at their relevant base stats:
HP / Def / SpA / SpD / Speed
Moltres: 90 / 90 / 125 / 85 / 90
Shaymin: 100 / 100 / 100 / 100 / 100
While Shaymin has a mere 10 base stat points over the majority of Moltres's utility stats, Moltres packs a whopping 25 Base SpA points over Shaymin. This is amplified by the fact that STAB Fire moves are far better than STAB Grass moves, and Moltres's Air Slash hits even harder because it gets STAB (in addition to the 25 extra Base SpA). Shaymin is obviously tougher to take down and poses a major threat with Seed Flare's secondary effect, but it is hard to argue that Moltres isn't close behind.
The main thing holding Moltres back is Stealth Rock, but this round Rapid Spinning got much easier. There is no effective way to run Spikestack + Double Ghost, and in my opinion it's simply not worth it for just Stealth Rock. The fastest Spin Blockers are undeniably frail, and Spiritomb is still Spiritomb, it's going to lose to the same Pokemon as it always does, and it's hit by Spikes.
With Shaymin in mind, I think Moltres deserves another nomination under the offensive characteristic.
Why Now? Moltres's main check, Raikou, is no longer around to stop it from destroying offense, and stall is still semi-easy to Spike against.
Torterra:
Torterra deserves a mention at the very least because it functions a lot like Raikou for me (which sounds stupid, but let me explain). Raikou was too hard to stop because it set up Calm Minds on special attacks, and physical priority moves don't even 2HKO it. Torterra has exceptional bulk, moreso than Raikou, and it takes even less damage from priority. Torterra has many chances to set up Rock Polish, and after this there are far too few Pokemon who can beat it on offense. This was the issue with Raikou, you were forced to use stupid shit like Scarf Venusaur Earthquake to beat it. While Scarf HP Ice Rotom isn't as stupid as Scarf Venusaur, it is not a hard argument to make that HP Ice Rotom is dumb.
I mean, I don't think I'd actually vote Torterra BL, but I would kind of like to discuss why Torterra always seems to be the most dangerous sweeper in the metagame, as if it's anti-metagame.
I'll respond to some counter-arguments:
I'm fine with Torterra who isn't getting past Leafeon and Tangrowth... ever.
Listing two Pokemon that are easily passable through other means does not mean much (think: Raikou).
PK Gaming said:And for offensive Moltres checks, like it or not Manetric and Raichu force it out every single time. (so that's something) and I think Zam and Guts Swellow have the power to do so as well. CB Azumarill is a given.
Forcing Moltres out isn't really that big of a deal, but Raikou could switch in and KO it, or come in on the revenge kill and actually set up on it. None of these Pokemon can do that. Even if you predict right, Manectric is still 2HKOed by Moltres. Fire Blast OHKOes all of the Pokemon you listed, unlike Raikou. CB azumarill is the only exception, but if you've used it you really dislike using CB Aqua Jet as a crutch.
PK Gaming said:As for Milotic? You can always pull 1-2 combo with Venusaur and Dugtrio. Weaken it enough so it can switch out, and trap it on the next switch in. Speaking of Milotic sets, I don't bother running physically defensive. SD Ken is an awesome lure as it literally cries.
I'd run a physically bulky teammate like Leafeon or Torterra.
You listed one Pokemon that can switch into Milotic safely and force it out. I don't see how this proves anything against Milotic.