What I'm saying is that both what Guy 1 and you are saying is true; there will still be surprise and the cake is kinda like chocolate. Its just nobody gives a crap. Yes, some pokemon are diverse. Big fucking deal when you see the rest of the opponent's team. You can probably get a general idea how his team is set-up from that etc.
If that's what the poop analogy means I think your friend lives under a rock and has a problem with speaking for entire groups of people