-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
[Standard] NOC Desktop Dungeons Mafia GAME OVER
- Thread starter Alpha Werewolf
- Start date
Just noticed something: billymills has randomly changed his vote in every post he's made. Why?
I dunno, just seems odd to me.
and we can get rid of spiffy
unvote
Vote: J-man
I warned you.
Vote: J-man
I warned you.
I'm not positive about this Spiffy bandwagon? I know people don't like him, but what are the arguments that he's mafia?
What is the difference between Spiffy's old post and his edited post?
nothing.
the whole point of editing a post is to alter the content of the post
only spiffy could fuck that up
only spiffy could fuck that up
Ok what does this mean and what does it have to do with lynching me.
UncleSam, I really appreciate you ignoring this:
The host even confirms that my role and alliance had nothing to do with his decision.
And what makes me priority over bandwagoners like polelover44 and J-Man, who give no reasoning whatsoever in why they're voting.
unvote
vote Rickheg
So basically what you're saying is that it's better to lynch someone who isn't mafia and start using night roles to uncover information than take another look at who's mafia?
There's no time limit today, so you want to endanger the town simply to speed the game up. Not flying with me.
vote Rickheg
rickheg said:
So basically what you're saying is that it's better to lynch someone who isn't mafia and start using night roles to uncover information than take another look at who's mafia?
There's no time limit today, so you want to endanger the town simply to speed the game up. Not flying with me.
Here. Skimmed because we have a scum already.
Vote: billymills
I don't care about the revoting the same person. I do care about the opportunistic wagon hopping that you were doing earlier. What is the point in voting someone if you are going to pull your vote on them just as pressure starts to rise? Why would you feel the need to change votes when there is little to no information to go on?
The reason, looking for an early foothold for a mislynch. You would know as well as anyone how easy it is to nab a quick mislynch early day 1. The fact of the matter is that you are being scummy and at the very least anti town by voiding all potential pressure building progress that is the crux of how town should be playing day 1.
Vote: billymills
I don't care about the revoting the same person. I do care about the opportunistic wagon hopping that you were doing earlier. What is the point in voting someone if you are going to pull your vote on them just as pressure starts to rise? Why would you feel the need to change votes when there is little to no information to go on?
The reason, looking for an early foothold for a mislynch. You would know as well as anyone how easy it is to nab a quick mislynch early day 1. The fact of the matter is that you are being scummy and at the very least anti town by voiding all potential pressure building progress that is the crux of how town should be playing day 1.
Please read.... Billymills does that for a reason, and i got lynched last time for
And spiffy, i'm lynching you cause i don't like you, that should have been obvious.
It's a day 1 lynch. I was just saying what a normal villager would say. Sorry if I'm wrong for the lynch as I'm just following my FoS. If we're right, the hooray.
I'm also a new player, and this is my first mafia game on a forum, so I'm trying to tread carefully.
Btw, I find that a some of you are overthinking things. Analyzing harmless comments and reading between the lines will only get more of the village killed. That should only be done I believe when everyone you're playing with is experienced and can use their posts to manipulate the vote, convey something else, etc.
Unclesam, you look too pro-town. While lynching you is obviously a bad decision, I ask the cop (if there is one) to check on Unclesam tonight. If he's clear, we have a smart villager who can lead us on, if he turns out guilty, then, we get rid of a really smart player who's really good acting. He's obviously smart/experienced with mafia. Win/win either way.
As for my vote, Spiffy's lynch looks logical, but if the mod clears him, I don't think we should waste a lynch where everyone (will likely) bandwagon, thus, not giving us not much to work with after day 1.
Unvote
Unvoting for now, Galladiator looks to be in the same position as me, so I will wait a bit more for more FoSes.
I'm also a new player, and this is my first mafia game on a forum, so I'm trying to tread carefully.
Btw, I find that a some of you are overthinking things. Analyzing harmless comments and reading between the lines will only get more of the village killed. That should only be done I believe when everyone you're playing with is experienced and can use their posts to manipulate the vote, convey something else, etc.
Unclesam, you look too pro-town. While lynching you is obviously a bad decision, I ask the cop (if there is one) to check on Unclesam tonight. If he's clear, we have a smart villager who can lead us on, if he turns out guilty, then, we get rid of a really smart player who's really good acting. He's obviously smart/experienced with mafia. Win/win either way.
As for my vote, Spiffy's lynch looks logical, but if the mod clears him, I don't think we should waste a lynch where everyone (will likely) bandwagon, thus, not giving us not much to work with after day 1.
Unvote
Unvoting for now, Galladiator looks to be in the same position as me, so I will wait a bit more for more FoSes.
Opportunistic wagon hopping? I'm not sure I follow.
I led to (admittedly not very serious) lynches against J-man and DetroitLolcats. The rest of you let the pressure off them.
I have not been too interested in lynches against Masterful and Isaac, because they appeared out of nowhere and tried to redeem it on the spot. I didn't feel either of them really said anything of note.
If you are complaining about my random lynches, stop it, it hurts.
I led to (admittedly not very serious) lynches against J-man and DetroitLolcats. The rest of you let the pressure off them.
I have not been too interested in lynches against Masterful and Isaac, because they appeared out of nowhere and tried to redeem it on the spot. I didn't feel either of them really said anything of note.
If you are complaining about my random lynches, stop it, it hurts.
@ Issac: Cop should not be claiming anything unless they get a guilty.
@ billy: In other words you are switching wagons whenever you see possible. If your aim is to catch scum you're doing it wrong. Votes without backing of reasons or threat of lynch are not the kind of things that produce reactions from scum. You were doing it in the earlier pages.
@ billy: In other words you are switching wagons whenever you see possible. If your aim is to catch scum you're doing it wrong. Votes without backing of reasons or threat of lynch are not the kind of things that produce reactions from scum. You were doing it in the earlier pages.
Also @ people that have voted No Lynch:
There is ONLY ONE SCENARIO in which a no lynch is acceptable in a NOC game. In Mylo. And even then it is not always the best option. In some cases voting in Mylo is actually beneficial.
There is ONLY ONE SCENARIO in which a no lynch is acceptable in a NOC game. In Mylo. And even then it is not always the best option. In some cases voting in Mylo is actually beneficial.