[Standard] NOC Desktop Dungeons Mafia GAME OVER

Oh, and I also agree that Ditto and J-man need to speak up a bit...though honestly, with Ditto it makes more sense why he's quiet (perhaps some issues going on in his social life? After all, finals are going on everywhere right now, so I wouldn't be surprised why some people are quiet).

But J-man should talk a bit more if you ask me...
Vote J-man
 
Acklow said:
Oh, and I also agree that Ditto and J-man need to speak up a bit...though honestly, with Ditto it makes more sense why he's quiet (perhaps some issues going on in his social life? After all, finals are going on everywhere right now, so I wouldn't be surprised why some people are quiet).
Click to expand...

I'm still pretty adamant about ditto avoiding this thread. He's hasn'y posted anything even though he's been pretty active on he forums. I think he should at least tell us why he's been silent.

Anyways, I rarely wander into a forum or cm so I don't really know what to expect from J-man... I'm just going to assume what the experienced players say is true.
 
Answering billymills' post. Since everyone wants it.

-Why have you contributed so little to the discussion?
-- I find that there is little to contribute. Right now we are just doing a little blame game. I find little actual discussion being done. I am just having trouble really trying to decide based solely on what are probably incorrect overanalizations of another person's post and no actually facts.

-Why have you mainly followed bandwagons with little to no original thought?
-- I haven't bandwagoned today. I bandwagoned first day due to a misconception about NOC on my part that DLE talked about. I wanted to get Day 1 over with, but now I am trying to put more thought into things. Hence observing more.

-Why have you been avoiding this thread like the plague?
-- I don't avoid the thread. I read through it, I just don't post.

-What are your thoughts on each of the following users: Isaac, Spiffy, masterful, polelover44, and fatecrashers?
-- Isaac: Well he claimed BG. Another power role, so it would be really if we did lynch him. Although to that end he probably knows that we are less likely to lynch him if he claims power role. Also BG is kinda tough to prove cause you are never sure who the mafia is targeting.
-- Spiffy: Quite fishy. If he's gonna claim a power role, he should be able to deliver. It's possible that he could have gotten hooked, but I definitely have my doubts.
-- masterful: Seem to be bandwagoning. While everyone thinks that is a sign of mafia, I think it is more likely a sign of trying to a) not look inactive and b) unsure of what to do in a possibly new playstyle.
-- polelover44: Another bandwagoner. I'd be more suspicious of him than of masterful because I think he is more experienced, although I have not done outside research on either.
-- Fatecrashers: I originally suspected him and DLE as Mafia because of some of their actions on the first day, but after the first lynch results I think he's clean. I am always a bit wary of him.
 
Well, if you really are vigi, feel free to kill one of the people who everyone's been suspecting. My powers can only be used once every two nights though, so, you might be the maf's kill tonight.
 
Spiffy said:
Hey guys who should I kill tonight?

And Quagsires has been active on IRC but hasn't posted in the thread until the beginning of the day!
Click to expand...

tbh I've been waiting for someone to point out that, since Ditto was voted for the same reason, and it's almost unfair to vote for him using that when I've done the same thing.

Although Issac, Yeti's right. Claiming a role under pressure is EXTREMELY suspicious, but it's worth trying to give you another chance. In fact, the only thing suprising about it is Yeti not complaining about being called male (she's not). Your supposedly nerfed role isn't helping you any...

And I'm pretty certain that US is village based on what he's saying, but I wouldn't put it behind him to still be mafia. I disagree only on Detroitlolcat for being trusted, as it remains to be seen what Spiffy is. If SPiffy is mafia, then I would single out Detroit as a likely partner immediately.

Masterful, quite a few of us have AP tests, I'm leaving for one in about an hour even. It's not entirely a legitimate excuse if you don't post yet everyone else can. Make your own arguments as well, it at least looks better than bandwagoning.

Spiffy's wrong to an extent on Peace NOC, but mainly since me and him were mafia then there might be a slight difference in how we play mafia and village.

So I see a vote today between Masterful, J-man, and Polelover44. Out of the three, I will quote:
J-man said:
If anyone has played with me (Finn), you'll know that i'm ultra sensitive and pounce on things the moment i see them.
Click to expand...

He's so pouncy, he's barely posting after we're nearly four times the posts he could've responded to in Peace NOC! And he's only posted a third of what he overall posted there! Yay consistency! Don't we love it?!

Vote: J-man

Seriously, what are you doing?
UncleSam said:
How about an explanation for the total lack of activity?
Click to expand...
polelover44 said:
Having a life?
Click to expand...
While I'm not as suspicious of Pole as US, I love these quotes together.
 
Judging by everyone else's posts, J-Man is acting outside of his usual behavior by not reacting. I'm not voting for him yet, because I want to see if he responds to any of this soon.
 
lol quag I didn't notice he screwed my gender up
probably because his posts have made so little sense...........

vote: j-man

start talking or we'll get majority.
I don't like how he has absolutely NO defense this time around.. makes it look like he's struggling to come up with something
 
sorry for the inactivity. It's that crazy thing called life, and it's taken up more time than i thought it would. I've been doing my best to keep updated on the game despite all the obstacles that have been preventing me from doing so (as i previously mentioned). To explain my sudden departure from stupidity, i've been cutting down on posting and making sure i don't say stupid stuff (as well as deleting things i deem too stupid to leave on any given thread i've posted in). My rep is damaged, but there's no point in giving up trying to salvage anything. So, i don't see any reason why i should be lynched. I'm heavily leaning towards Isaac 2.0, but then again, pressure does crazy things.
 
Inspector should check one of polelover, masterful, Detroit, Spiffy, J-man or me imo. I have a feeling I might be kept alive and Spiffy might be nightkilled (if he is vigi), and if a lynch pushes on me tomorrow, town will have lost 2 power roles unless inspector can prove I'm inno.

I'll keep my vote on myself for now, I don't wanna get called out on for BWing again. x_x
 
isaac, from your perspective, you should know who you are allied with. if you're town, why the hell would you vote for someone who is (from your perspective) confirmed town? your vote being on yourself is anti-town (note that i do not say a scum-tell; there's a difference although keep it up and there won't be) and honestly really stupid. stop being so afraid of being called names for voting someone. vote who you honestly feel is mafia, regardless of how many other votes are on that person. give some good reasoning behind it, and we can discuss it and that person can attempt to defend their votes, etc. that's how town wins games, not by having their bodyguard vote himself.

i really want to lynch billymills from the little i have read in this thread. but that might just be because i love billyrolls and less the actual voting. I will actually dedicate a fair share to this game tomorrow and read through shit, promise!

in the meantime,

Unvote

just in case i already voted before, although i don't think i did.

Vote: rickheg

die mafia scum
 
I'm voting for myself to try and clear myself as being town. If I'd had to vote, I'd go with one of the lurkers because of the reasons I've explained in previous posts. My initial vote would go to Fangren (as mentioned earlier), but, I'm fine with J-man as well. Lurking is anti-town imo, because maf generally avoid killing lurkers as they're the ones who don't pay attention.

Unvote
Vote: J-man

Call me a hypocrite for BWing yet again, but, at this point, lynching a lurker is our best bet.
 
If anyone is wondering about my lack of an explanation it's because I was posting at school of my phone. May post real reasoning later.
 
by my count there's 9 votes on j-man

unless Vote j-man doesn't count and it needs to be Vote: j-man

could've counted wrong

if our host would like to confirm??
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top