Porcupine Tree - Fear of a Blank Planet

Altmer

rid this world of human waste
is a Site Content Manager Alumnusis a Top Contributor Alumnus
Porcupine Tree - Fear of a Blank Planet



Genre: Progressive Rock/Metal
Rating: 4.5/5


A lonely teenager sits on a couch, watching the TV and zapping with his remote. He's just gamed his fingers to death with his new Xbox. His parents try to talk him out of his lazy habitual lifestyle. He does not respond. They try again, but he ignores them no matter what, his eyes blank and still staring straight at the electronical screen before him. Eventually his parents just give up, leaving him to wallow in his own self-absorbed terrible way of living.

This is the picture of youth Steven Wilson of Porcupine Tree sketches in the opening track of his latest release, Fear Of A Blank Planet. His decidedly haunting lyrical poetics set the tone for what now already is about to become one of the best albums of the year, not in the least because of the strengths of this album, which lie where they have always lain for this band: the invoking of atmosphere and a sense of psychedelia, layered with thick bass lines, complex drum patterns and melodic guitar riffs.

The aforementioned riffs are definitely what make the atmosphere on this album. Wilson chugs out riffs that are louder, darker, more atmospheric, harder, just overall more evil than they usually are. Aided by some cutting edge lyrics of angst and harsh social criticism interwoven in the songs, the album's moods range from melancholy to raging to clinically depressed. This is the first Porcupine Tree outing ever that I have seen that has gone full throttle on the dark side of life like this. The whole disc retains this atmosphere due to the lyrical content of the album being themed around one thing: the sorry state of youth. It is a miserable ride through destroyed teenage lives all the way through.

And his riffs are not just atmospheric or moody. They can be plain monstrous at times. If you have been impressed by Opeth or Dream Theater riffs, just wait till you hear the musical orgasm that is Anesthetize. Containing all the core elements of the PT sound in one seventeen minute plus epic, it begins in a psychedelic mood more reminiscent of Pink Floyd with too much mellotron-esque feel. It slowly moves on and on, until it breaks into a middle part which shows a panorama of metal riffs that would make Mikael Akerfeldt accuse Wilson of blatant plagiarism, that's just how badass and evil this piece is. And it's not just Wilson who shines on here. The band brought in Alex Lifeson (yes, the famous Rush guitarist), who delivers a top-notch guitar solo in the song, and additionally, Gavin Harrison's drumming is just jaw-dropping. It's incredibly tight too; when at the eleven-minute-mark Wilson throws open the guitar sound full throttle it sounds like all hell breaks loose, but due to the drumming not a second of this outburst of violence can be regarded as misplaced. To put it in one word: astounding.

Next to Anesthetize and the title track, which show some of the heavy sides of the band, Porcupine Tree know that they are not a complete all-out metal band destined to kick your ass. They let down the tempo on two tracks. While My Ashes is a decidedly dodgy ballad in the sense that it tries to be Trains, but fails, Sentimental is a more than adequately upgraded version of Lazarus. A great ballad that allows you a breather in between two of the heaviest tracks of the band's impressive catalogue. As Wilson croons out how he doesn't want to really go anywhere and sees that he can't blame his parents for his mistakes, he inadvertently conveys the message of hopelessness and emptiness that besets the whole album.

He follows that up with the plainly disturbing Way Out Of Here, which begins with a soundscape from another guest (Robert Fripp of King Crimson fame), but also turns out to have some lyrics that would make Cobain's sense of angst hide in fear of being called a wuss. Especially the verses are heartbreaking and flow along so nicely with the atmosphere of fear and anxiety that once again weaves its threads all through the song. It may be best illustrated by an example:

"I can't take the staring and the sympathy
And I don't like the questions:
"How do you feel?"
"How's it going at school?"
"Do you wanna talk about it?"


The prime example of an alienated teenager right here folks, and without a mention of self-harming activities. We don't need explicit imagery to show us how just how messed up we actually are. Just an insight into a troubled mind refusing to answer to the essential questions of life will do, and excellently at that.

The album ends on a decent note with Sleep Together, which comprises the end. It's not bad by any means, but here I have the feeling that it's something I've already seen before, but the chorus more than makes up for it; even if Porcupine Tree are not going to get a gold star for originality they will at least obtain an award for sheer consistency and class.

So if you are ready for a ride through the dark side of the adolescent mind, spend your bucks on this baby, and sit back and enjoy. Steven Wilson and companions have no doubt created the album of the year with a deftly crafted, varied, yet continuously haunting at atmospheric disc that will leave you begging for repeat plays for weeks after and continually referencing when dealing with teenage angst. Just one last warning: if you're not down with modern metal, this album just may be a little too much to digest. Nevertheless the lyrical concept and the atmospheres still ring true in a world which just exemplifies the stage the band subtly sets. Ergo, I still believe this could be a timeless album due to its relevancy, and I recommend you pick this up first thing in the morning.
 
I had to order my copy that comes in tomorrow, so I haven't been able to listen to it yet. looking forward to it, though.

I'm sure it's a great album (PT is my favorite band), but I'm also really wary because as most people here know, metal is not my kind of thing. the thing I'm scared of here is exactly the reason why I don't like 99% of metal/progressive rock--that is, solos and displays of technical ability that are done simply to "show off" and take away from the quality of the song.

of course, that other 1% is Steven Wilson's work; he's always made the music, despite its complexity, accessible and enjoyable to people like me. of course, it's the soft side of PT that I love the most--Lazarus, Heartattack in a Lay By, etc.

from the sample of "Sleep Together" I've heard, it's kind of disappointing that they broke their trend of ending albums on a downkey, pretty song.

also on the comment about "I feel like I've heard this before" on the last song...I've noticed that some of PT's songs can almost sound like reworkings of older songs. for example: Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth... and Trains, or the title track on Fear of a Blank Planet (the only song I've heard) and the title track on Deadwing.

even if this doesn't become a favorite like all the other PT albums, I still have Blackfield II and the upcoming No-Man CD, so I'll get my Steven Wilson fix somewhere.
 
for me this rivals In Absentia for best PT album. Steven Wilson is a musical genius!

top tracks: fear of a blank planet, anesthetize
 
Aneshetize is a phenomenal track. Love Lifeson's solo not to mention Harrison's drumming throughout. By far the best track on the album. Hard to decide if this is better than Arriving Somewhere But Not Here from the previous album.

Favourite PT albums are as follows:

Up The Downstair
Signify
Stupid Dream
In Absentia
Deadwing
Fear of a Blank Planet

If you all like Steven Wilson so much check out Blackfield. Some beautifully written laid back tunes. Blackfield II was released last month.
 
Havoc, this definitely isn't Dream Theater wankery.

For me (although I've only heard the last three) it's

Fear of a Blank Planet
In Absentia
Deadwing
 
Yes, Anesthetize works on your nerves after a while.

I love the title track though. And the lyrics throughout the album are killer.
And I love Opeth. =P
 
also, after listening more, two of my favorite things about Porcupine Tree, the beautiful vocal harmonies and use of the E-Bow, are almost entirely absent from this album :[
 
also on the comment about "I feel like I've heard this before" on the last song...I've noticed that some of PT's songs can almost sound like reworkings of older songs. for example: Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth... and Trains, or the title track on Fear of a Blank Planet (the only song I've heard) and the title track on Deadwing.

the main thing recycled are how they arrange different sections of a song... which pretty much everyone does. however there is this one acoustic guitar strumming thing that they have on a ton of songs, let me give you a timestamp, listening to anesthetize right now.

got the album yesterday, after listening to it:

~Anesthetize really didn't do it for me. double bass drum is just too much going on and distracting, and the metal riffs got repetitive to me. it may not have been wankery on the level of DT, but it still was wanking to Opeth imo. the last part (which should have been a separate track) was by far the best.
~metal riffing got close to being too repetitive in Way Out Of Here too, but the first part really blew me away
~my personal favorite track is Sentimental
~other 3 songs were pretty top notch
~SW seemed to do a lot more "talking in tune to the music" then just straight singing

maybe this is an album that will have to take time to grow on me, but I don't know. if you're really into the progressive rock/metal thing (which a lot of people here are), this will be great, but I can't help but feel like SW was a tad too focused on his message. I'd recommend the album, but it just doesn't speak to me the way their past 4 albums have. different strokes, I guess.

i thought i was the only one not too into anesthetize. it's good but not as good as arriving somewhere but not here. also, i think steven wilson always talks to the tune of the music, he rarely really sings.

overall, i would rate it above signify/stupid dream, and below their last three albums. it flows better than lightbulb sun though.
 
I really like Way Out Of Here, the metal parts are pretty brief, and Wilson's vocals are superb. Overall, it just rocks.
 
after not listening to this album for almost 2 months, I decided to put it back in and try listening to it, and I guess it took a while, but now I really really enjoy this album.

I still wouldn't rate it any higher than I originally did (~3.7/5), but certain songs (ie Way Out of Here) really grew on me. Sentimental is still my favorite, but Way Out of Here and Sleep Together are great as well.
 
Yeah after repeated listens I've realised that Anesthetize (while still being amazing) is a bit too long.

But Way out of Here is amazing, so is Sentimental and the title track. I love this album. No bad songs, not too long...
 
Quality album, but not their best work. It flows well, it sounds good... but just not as good as most of their other stuff. I thought Sleep Together was excellent; it's definitely one of those songs that's 'out there', but it sounds awesome. Deadwing, in my opinion, was much better (as was Up The Downstair).

Just my two cents here, but pre-Signify PT and post-Signify PT sound completely different (which makes sense, as it was just Wilson on his own before then).

Speaking of other SW projects, go listen to No-Man. Now.
 
this album is surpisingly boring after you listen to it once or twice. it sounds really great first listen though then the music started sounding flat. just like other Porcupine Tree, if only they were able to condense songs like Anesthetize they would be so much better. yeah, it's really ambitious to do 17:00 and I appreciate that but if its just repeating mostly the same thing over and over without much change, it's not even taking advantage of it's length. to hear a true epic listen to Gates of Delirium by Yes, Octavarium by Dream Theater, or Omnio by In the Woods...
 
Wow I haven't listened to any of the music I listened to when I used to come here. I guess being seperated from an active musical community as a whole has kind of blocked me from doing my musical thang, haha.

I'm gonna try to get this soon and I'll post what I think, I'm actually really happy PT has something else out... heck I haven't listened to them in such a long time anyway.
 
this album is surpisingly boring after you listen to it once or twice. it sounds really great first listen though then the music started sounding flat. just like other Porcupine Tree, if only they were able to condense songs like Anesthetize they would be so much better. yeah, it's really ambitious to do 17:00 and I appreciate that but if its just repeating mostly the same thing over and over without much change, it's not even taking advantage of it's length. to hear a true epic listen to Gates of Delirium by Yes, Octavarium by Dream Theater, or Omnio by In the Woods...

Really? I keep finding new stuff I didn't hear before. I don't listen to it as much as when it came out, but this is probably one of my favourite albums this year.
 
posting to say as one who is currently strung out constantly on prescription medication (sedatives and antidepressants)
"Don't try engaging me
The vaguest of shrugs
The prescription drugs

You'll never find a person inside
My face is mogadon.."

and who absolutely despises therapy
"And I don't like the questions:
"How do you feel?"
"How's it going at school?"
"Do you wanna talk about it?"'


(I genuinely have to leave the room should the latter or former question ever be asked except in the most knowing and ironic of ways)

this is a wonderfully accurate record, or would be if FOABP substituted the word "DS" for "Xbox".

Emo yes, but it does capture wonderfully the sense that your mind, emotions and thus who you basically are as a person are being artificially changed and thus lost by these head-fucking meds, the constant sense of numbness and general dysphoria..

Valium in particular is notorious for this (and thus the line about mogadon, a similar but slightly stronger sedative) since you really do just wander around not giving a fuck about anything, feeling entirely and quite unpleasantly blank.

In this state - and ones of depression - I and others I know of in a similar state have tried to gain all sorts of artificial feelings of happiness, excitement and the like and this not only pertains to the character's drug abuse but also to the shoplifting - self destructive things you do just to feel a rush (and believe me shoplifting is like doing a line of very high grade coke).

Emo and overlong I know, but basically yes, Wilson has captured the mood of an emo bitch who's fucking about with her meds to an almost perfect degree..
 
yeah I know what you mean by the "blank" feeling, I do it too, I really relate to this record.
 
I don't like it as much as In Absentia or Deadwing(the only two PT albums that I have listened to extensively, although I've heard their others), but it's not bad. I personally am not a huge fan of metal, so maybe the 45 minutes of complete evil just didn't appeal to me unlike In Absentia or Deadwing which has some easier-listening parts.

Either way, Porcupine Tree is a great band that makes incredible music. I probably would have never started listening to them if Justin or whoever that was wouldn't of posted a review of In Absentia all those months ago.
 
Back
Top