NOTE: This is taking me a while to write, so if some of my statements are completely ninja'd by others then I'm sorry.
I feel like an asshole for running Golurk, Cinccino, and Alomomoonguss all on the same team this round. However, that has granted me quite a bit of experience with each Pokemon. I can honestly tell you right now that none of these Pokemon should be banned from NU. Quite a bit of discussion should be based around them, as they are indeed very powerful Pokemon right now, but again, they are not ban-worthy. Neither Cinccino nor Golurk have the ability to sweep prepared teams, and neither are very hard to kill; likewise, the Alomomoonguss core cannot fully wall teams that are packing the right coverage moves (let alone can they do much significant damage on their own). These aren't things like Jynx, who could easily incapacitate a counter and then proceed to sweep fully prepared teams. For any of you who played during Jynx's last round, please compare her to current suspects. Nothing we have now is half as frightening (except Combusken, that thing always scares the shit out of me when I have to play one).
First off,
Hide
BAN GOREBYSS.
Kidding, of course. Now, onto the actual serious stuff. FLCL has basically stated everything I would have said (and probably more), but I'll try to state my opinion on things without rehashing his ideas
too much.
Cinccino: SHIT'S WEAK AND STRAIGHT COUNTERED BY ROCKY HELMET AMOONGUSS.
Hide
Cinccino has been pretty fun to abuse lately; it's tied with Sneasel, Floatzel, and Persian for 5th fastest Pokemon in NU and it can work as a cleaner, revenge killer, or even a semi-decent wall breaker. Its base 95 Attack stat has provided just enough power to make Cinccino extremely threatening with a Life Orb set. Its base 115 allows it to outspeed and KO even the weather sweepers if it is equipped with a Choice Scarf. It has (in my opinion) been one of the sole reasons for the virtual disappearance of Golem from our metagame. Skill Link provides it with three moves that all sport a base power of 125. If that's not enough, Cinccy can U-Turn out of almost any situation that it might face trouble in. If this thing gets a super effective hit, that usually means it gets the KO.
Sounds perfectly ban-worthy when you don't think of all the negatives, doesn't it? The problems faced by Cinccino are many, and it can't really do anything about them.
First and foremost, Life Orb recoil is a bitch. In all my time playing NU, I have never used a Pokemon that is hampered by its item as much as Cinccino is. Of course, this is also due to the fact that you're constantly having to switch around with Cinccino, causing you to take wasted recoil on attacks that hit switch-ins who resist your moves as well as Stealth Rock damage (Spikes aren't as common, but they'll fuck you up pretty bad, too).
Second, fuck priority. As frustrating as it already is to have to constantly switch this little thing in and out of battle, priority makes it so much worse. Virtually every priority in the tier will do about 40% to Cinccino. 40% might as well be all of its usable health considering all the other passive damage Cinccy is going to be taking.
Cinccino's LO set is the only thing even close to being suspected, as its other sets are a bit "meh." Choice Band suffers due to locking Cinccino into a single attack, but at least it doesn't lose all of its HP within three turns. It's definitely powerful, but Life Orb is ultimately more useful. Choice Scarf is Cinccino's second best set, and functions as an effective revenge killer, that's all it's going to do for you though.
So yeah, this thing is great, and can definitely clean up against a team that foolishly came unprepared for it, but the cons to it definitely balance out the pros.
Golurk: STRONGTHER THAN SD TENTACOOL.
Hide
Golurk is another Pokemon that received a shit load of hype this round, and I do believe it was well-deserved. Golurk's Attack stat is huge (base 124, 6th highest in the tier) and its Choice Band set is horrifying. When Golurk came down to NU, he greeted us all by saying "fuck all of your remaining spinners" and making Spikes-stacking much more of a real threat than it was in previous rounds. Overall, Golurk is an excellent addition to NU, and an outstanding Pokemon. However, there is no reason Megatron needs to be banned. Golurk's problems hurt it worse in some situations than Cinccino's hurt itself.
Being choice-locked can absolutely kill Golurk's momentum. Shadow Punch is a good STAB move, especially powered up by Iron Fist; unfortunately, Normal-types are more common than crime in Detroit. Drain Punch is awesome for healing and adds to Golurk's coverage; saddening when you realize this welcomes every other Ghost-type in the tier into a free switch. Earthquake is another powerful STAB attack, Golurk's best choice in most situations; the pattern continues, however, as many common Pokemon either resist the move or are simply immune to it. Ice Punch is the only move in Golurk's main set that will always hit, and plenty of things resist that. Tl;dr, Golurk will almost always have to switch after landing 1-2 hits, as almost every opponent has something immune to one or two of its attacks.
Golurk is also extremely easy to revenge kill. Anything faster with a powerful special attack can put it away without much effort. If you aren't running Drain Punch, you have no way to heal, which is significant when you realize how average Golurk's bulk can really seem in most matches. Most super effective moves either OHKO'd mine or brought it down to laughable HP. I had to learn pretty fast what the right conditions were for Golurk to be brought in safely. These tended to primarily be when I predicted an Electric or Normal move, as otherwise Golurk would take a pretty heavy hit and be too slow to do anything before being 2HKO'd.
I've gotta admit, Golurk's been one of my favorite Pokemon to run since I joined up with NU in Round 0, and I'd hate to see him get voted out after being here for 1 round. Personal feelings aside, as a competitive player I feel that there's no reason that this thing should be banned. It's just not game-breaking. At all.
Alomomola: FUCK LUVDISC.
Hide
Of the four Pokemon I plan on covering with this post, Alomomola is by far the least deserving of a ban. Alo can't even reach her full potential on her own, as she's best used in conjunction with either Amoonguss or Audino (or both, for the more defensive users). Yes, Alomomola is extremely bulky and can pass some of the largest wishes in the game, but that's all it has going for it. Most special attackers rip her apart, her offense is virtually nonexistent (although occasional Scald burns are cool...er, hot), and it's extremely easy to predict what she's going to do. Regenerator adds to her ability to annoy, but it doesn't make her impossible to kill.
By itself, there's no reason you shouldn't be able to take this thing down, even if you haven't specifically prepared for it. Special attacks and Toxic completely stop it in its tracks. Let's not forget about sets such as Mixed Emboar, which were made specifically to take things like Alomomola down. I would go as far as to say that banning Alomomola would break the entire NU metagame, as many of our strongest physical sweepers would have one less wall to worry about in a tier where we only have about 5 worth mentioning (I'm sure it wouldn't be that serious, but you never know).
Amoonguss: NU'S PREMIER DOUCHEBAG
Hide
Okay, so it looks like everyone wants this thing gone just a little bit, and I can't say they aren't justified in thinking so. Amoonguss is one of the best defensive Pokemon in the tier, and its access to Spore makes it very hard to completely play around. It has also caused the complete elimination of Toxic Spikes due to its Poison-typing. Regenerator keeps its HP up, while it's got enough bulk to switch into something, attack / Spore, and then switch out with most of its health. Fortunately, just like every other Pokemon I've covered so far, Amoonguss has plenty of negatives to balance out the positives.
Base 30 Speed is about as impressive as it sounds, and even with a decent amount of offensive investment its special attacks aren't going to be doing loads of damage to much, even if they're super effective. Sap Sipper Pokemon such as Miltank don't care about Amoonguss at all, and can easily force him out. Pokemon that inflict status on themselves for a boost, such as Swellow and Zangoose, don't have to worry about being hit with Spore and can heavily damage Amoonguss to either KO or force it out. I think Drifblim deserves a mention as AcroBlimp can Substitute before a Spore and then OHKO with Flying Gem-boosted Acrobatics. We've also got a few viable Pokemon that run abilities which directly prevent sleep from affecting them that can force Amoonguss out (Vigoroth, Hypno, and Banette are all somewhat good). The reason I'm pointing out all of these Pokemon is because I think the biggest reason Amoonguss is being attacked by everyone is because it currently fucks with a metagame that we've solidly established and don't want to change up too much. The same thing happened with Gorebyss; everyone cried out for a ban the round that Gory got popular, but after we adapted to its offensive powers it dropped in usage and we virtually forgot that it existed.
Amoonguss is definitely the most controversial Pokemon in our current discussion. After using it for the entirety of this round, I can say that it isn't broken, furthermore it shouldn't be banned. Give yourselves time to adjust to it rather than calling for it to be immediately removed.
The Core of Alomomoonguss: WHOA CHAOTICA, WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING.
Hide
This core deserves serious discussion, because these two Pokemon are an entirely different monster when used together. This is arguably the best defensive core in NU right now, and extremely tough to deal with unless you know how to predict and carry Pokemon to specifically deal with it. A primarily offensive team carrying this core can easily go on the defensive and stall things out if it loses one or two of its main sweepers, which can be significantly annoying at the least. Proper prediction and the use of Toxic + Clear Smog can make this core almost impossible to muscle through (or at least, this is what I've found from quite a few of my battles on the ladder). The fact that both Pokemon have Regenerator adds yet another level of the stress that these two can cause for their opponents.
By no means am I suggesting we ban the core; that's stupid. However, I do think that Amoonguss is much easier to hate when facing it paired up with Alomomola, and that's where the real problem is. I would never say that Amoonguss should be banned just because of what it can do on its own, but I'm definitely on the fence after seeing how damn effective it is when used with Momfish.
Okay, so this post is officially completed.
I'm going to make new posts concerning the other potential suspects as well as become more involved in the actual discussion.