+2 252+ Atk Silk Scarf Arceus-Normal ExtremeSpeed vs. 252 HP / 0 Def Arceus-Fighting: 279-328 (62.83 - 73.87%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Not really. I suppose you mean max hp by bulky variants. I have never seen an impish Fighceus, that would be wasteful.
As long as he can come on Arceus and take Extrem Speed LO
after he used Sword Dance and still being alive is something i can call "taking ES all day" since you are coming on the turn he use SD. If he try to kill you without it, you are still taking
33.56 - 40.09%, which is far too low even with double max damage, one layer of spikes and stealth rock.
Also, you don't need to be impish to be bulky, I think you already know that, let's skip to your next argument.
Koing it all day?
4 SpA Fist Plate Arceus-Fighting Judgment (Fighting) vs. 232 HP / 32 SpD Arceus-Normal: 254-300 (57.85 - 68.33%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Not really. I don't what set you are running, but I assume standard utility counter. Will o wisp is not a reliable way of checking E-killer. A quote from a friend of mine.
My Fightceus is doing
71.96 - 85.35% with Judgement, which is enough to kill him with one layer of spikes, stealth rock and one turn of Life Orb (well actually, you need to do 72% since you are peaking to 99% if you do a min damage, w/e).
Fightceus is okay, but not the best E-killer check in the game.
As you can see with my previous arguments, Fightceus is one of the best offensive check for EKceus since he can come on him, take a hit with double layer of entry hazards and still fire back with a Judgement who cut both of his arm. In the worst case, you die along with him, but we are talking about Arceus so yeah, it's obviously a big threat who need some preparation before trying to take him one-on-one.
Now, I bet you are thinking "where this calcs come from ? I dont have the same numbers", well, it's called
Teambuilding. I used my own spread which came from a team I built during BW1 on Fightceus since he was incredibly strong during this meta pollued by rainstall, he is still an excellent Arceus type, even though Lugia&Ho-Oh new ability hurt him a lot. Look at your spread in the calcs, they are all (or almost) 252/252/4. When you build a team, you have to make sure your spreads are suited for your team, not just taking a random 252/252/4 or a spread from the analysis without testing it like a deadbrain. Adjust it, change it so it allow you to take / do enough damage for what you have to do.
I didnt quoted your argument about better defensive typing, there is no reason to compare Fightceus, Lugia, Giratina and anyone else, they are not the same. Fightceus is a bulky mons who can act as a sweeper, the 2 other are pure stallers.
Peace and have a nice day.