Eggbert said:The argument that "BW will be centralized around something whether we have rain or not" is incorrect. Because of the power of weather, the majority of battlers are forced to use more standard and repetitive team cores, which are very rigid and leave few options for different teams. The very fact that a weather inducer is needed on so many teams already limits possibilities greatly. If you are running Tyranitar or Hippowdon, it becomes much more difficult to fit, say, Hydreigon because you already stack the weaknesses, while having Lati@s is 100% more necessary to check threats like Terrakion, sun teams, ect. There's no incentive, no point to using anything else. It forces standard team builds. Just use the standards and have a more stable team. There are a few successful weatherless teams, but these will only be good with the top battlers and are still disadvantaged. Why go uphill and fight chlorophyll Venusaur, rain dish Tentacruel, rain specs Keldeo, and the like, when you can neutralize them with a weather inducer?
This is aboslutely false and this is the kind of mindset that makes people so eager to blame Drizzle for any of their problems with the current meta. Of 'course there is a point to use something else. You use weatherless team for the following reasons that matter from a competitieve standpoint (of 'course i can use weatherless because it is harder to build than weather and thus more challening, but this is not a competitive reason to use weatherless):
1. To not use Politoed / Tyranitar / Hippowdon / Ninetales / Abomasnow. Yeah believe it or not, some people don't want to use these Pokemon. Why? Because they don't want to support and play games that revolve around a mediocre/bad standalone Pokemon (Politoed and Ninetales), they don't want a slow wall/tank in their team or don't want to take extra damage from Sand (Hippowdon, Tyranitar), or don't want to use a Pokemon that is hard to play with and has a lot of flaws to cover, while forcing a very specific teambuild (Abomasnow).
2. To use Pokemon that don't like weather or don't get enough benefits from it to care for weather support. Such examples are SubRoost Kyu-B, Forretress, Weavile, Kingdra, Latias, Alakazam, Breloom, Celebi, Gliscor, Blissey, Chansey, and Lucario.
3. To have more flexibility in teambuilding. Yeah i know that many people will disagree with this but let me explain. Imo, the team-types that limit your choices in teambuilding the most are any kind of Rain team, any kind of Sun team, and any kind of Hail team (not 100% sure about the last, but Hail is not largely relevant anyway). This means that weatherless and Sand teams give you the largest flexibility when teambuilding. While it is true that weatherless teams must devote two to three slots to deal with sun and rain, the Pokemon that can deal with them are many and the weatherless team still has 3-4 slots to work around with. Why not use a sand team someone can ask here, to better combat opposing weather... And i will tell him to look again reason 1.
Now that we are done with the reasons as to why one would want to use a weatherless team, let's look at the other bolded sentences. You say that if you use a standard team (i imagine you mean weather team here, or heavy offense with Deo-D or DragMag) you will have a more stable team. Where are you basing this? Judging from this thread one could say that by using Rain and Sun, you have a less stable team than by using a Sand or weatherless team, because your games rely a lot on match-up. Weatherless teams have more slots available to deal with their weaknesses making them potentially more stable than ''standard team-types''. Your last bolded sentence is also false and not backed up with any reasoning, as weatherless teams are not handicaped at all against weather teams. A crappy weatherless team will be handicaped against a crappy weather team sure, because the latter is easier to build, but a good weatherless team can face any weather team without many trouble (except for specific weaknesses, not weakness to the whole team-type). I don't know why some people want to underastimate weatherless team so much. Is it because they can't build them? Or is it because they just dislike Drizzle so much that they are convinced anything non-standard doesn't work? I honestly don't know, but what i know is that i play with weatherless teams a lot, and they are just fine!
Dark Fallen Angel said:Also, I am tired of being forced to carry a sturdy Water resist on every team just to tank rain-boosted Water attacks. While is true that, with or without Rain, you should always pack a Water-type resistance, on this metagame, you can't simply resist Water; this is not sufficient. You should resist Water AND have the bulk to actually take repeated rain-boosted Water-attacks. That's why things like Starmie aren't actually good options to tank rain-boosted Water attacks.
I am tired of running multiple steels and Mamoswine on my teams just to stop DragMag teams from overwhelming me, or to stop Dragons in general from destroying me. I am tired of running Rapid Spinners in my teams so that hazard-stacking teams don't eat me alive.
These are just some of the few examples that show how void of meaning your first sentence is. OF 'course you can argue that Steel-types are not used only to check Dragons, but also because they have a marvelous defensive typing, and then i can say that water-resists are also not used only to deal with water attacks and have many other useful things that they do. And fitting a bulky water resist in your team is not difficult at all anyway. Celebi, Latias, Kyurem-B, Amoonguss, Ferrothorn, Jellicent, and Rotom-W are all good Pokemon that can fit on any team and have multiple roles (most of them).
Every major threat in a meta needs to be heavily taken account for, or else you will end up losing a lot. This is why many people don't like OU. Because they are tired of using the same Pokemon to check the same Pokemon over and over again. Weather is exactly like other top-tier threats when teambuilding, you have to take account for it and use strong measures against it, or else you won't make a good team.
Sound said:I have precedence on my side here. During early BW, when HO was powerful with Deo-S, did we ban Terrakion/Scarfty/Dragonite/Scizor, or Deo-S? When dealing with a bee problem, do you fight bees off that are swarming around you, or you do destroy the hive? Rain's nature makes otherwise average pokemon so much more difficult to deal with, and already good pokemon beyond the limit (Seriously, Hurricane's low accuracy without Rain? Tell that to Moltres.)
You are comparing different situations. What made Deo-S broken was the fact that it could give any offensive Pokemon that support to sweep through teams, not a few select ones. This means that even if you got rid of the 3-4 stronger OU Pokemon, then next stronger would take their place, or a defensive Pokemon would be banned, because offense would be way too weak to break through defense. So banning Deo-S was clearly the best solution. But with Politoed this is not the case. There were 3-4 Pokemon banned because of it, and no more. The way that rain is now, it isn't broken. So the problem here could actually be solved by banning the abusers, rather than the supporter, because the abusers weren't that many in comparison to the Pokemon that found life to OU thanks to rain.
You also say something about rain being the superior playstyle, which i won't bother arguing as it isn't relevant anyway, but even if we assume it is, so what? There will always be more dominant strategies in competitive games, not anything can be equal. And as said again the way that rain teams are now they are not broken, so what is the reason to ban them?