Aasgier said:That being said, it is very likely, that when you make a team, you will not get to use a D-Rank Pokémon. D-Rank Pokémon are Pokémon, which are only useful on very specific teams because they can either fulfill a specific niche that team needs in the fifth or in the last slot, or because those Pokémon are only effective when you build your entire team around them (like Pikachu).
I only found an use for Leavanny and Noctowl which are currently E-Rank, so I can tell people about why they can be useful, but also why they can be useless/outclassed on so many teams. But now I think more about it while writing this rather long post, more Pokémon which currently reside in E-Rank can be useful on specific teams, which automatically means they are no longer E-Rank but D-Rank, according to the definition of D-Rank I quoted above.
With this in mind, it looks like D-Rank has very few Pokémon, and that many Pokémon fulfilling the definition aren't D-Rank but E-Rank instead. There are many outclassed Pokémon in NU which are outclassed - the name says it all - at everything, but one or two things, and thus serve a specific niche on a few teams. That being said, it can be that you have to use that D-Rank Pokémon in the last slot, though in many other cases that Pokémon will be useless, and it might very well be the case that you never find an use for that Pokémon again.
Noctowl (special tank /w Imsomnia), Leavanny (Grass type that can kill Psychics and doesn't mind taking a Focus Blast (looking at Sawsbuck there)), Octillery (Trick Room sweeper/Baton Pass recipient), Machoke (DynamicPunch, and greater bulk than Gurdurr), Heatmor (fire type with a somewhat unique movepool), Sneasel (anti-meta, fast) and probably a few others I forgot about.
They are by no means good Pokémon, as there is really no way you can just slap them on a team and expect your team to be better, but they all serve a specific niche and can be used without being outclassed at everything they do.
Then, if we take the Showdown ladder and not tournaments between better players as a requirement for being useful in competitive Pokémon, things with pathetic stats but large movepools, like Castform, become better because of their surprise value potential. D-Rank? Probably, probably not, as walls hardwall those Pokémon with a passion and they are still useless as they will only get you stuck at a certain point in the ladder, because the skill level becomes too high for the Pokémon to be usable.
Does that mean they can be all in D-Rank? I'll leave that to others to decide. But I think this is something to think about. As I just said, it might be very well that they can be useful on a specific team and I've seen quite a few cases of this with pretty much all of the Pokémon I mentioned above, and yes, that includes Castform.
Alright, I get what you're saying. If it is justifiable to place one poke on one specific team that will work, it will automatically be D rank. So I can place a level 1 rattata on a team with focus sash, endeavor and quick attack, and can kill a poke, so rattata should be D rank. Or I need a bug special wall, I'm going to use shuckle (sorry) vespiquen (sorry) or ledian (you suck). Or I'm going to use a trick room team, and watchog has analytic, so i should use that. So all of these pokes could function on these teams. Great. More power to you. Too bad you're probably going to lose. I completely agree with Celever, just because you can find a poke good for one team, doesn't justify it for D rank. Otherwise, hypothetically, every poke would be in D rank. At least the current D rank pokes can either place dents on teams, set up hazards, attempt to sweep, or have one specific job, like trapinch.
Noctowl with Insomnia: Sub BU braviary can avoid sleep as well, and be an offensive presence. Altaria can somewhat take a sleep and switch out, while having more helpful resistances. Who uses sleep anyway? Jumpluff, exeggutor, tangela, butterfree? All of these poke minus Jumpluff are handled by braviary, and these pokes cannot really touch altaria, except maybe butterfree with quiver dances. Plus, Hypno does the same job so much better, and with 85/70/115 is better than 100/50/96, is not weak to rocks, and can somewhat handle fighting types and choiced electrics.
Leavanny: Extremely predictable, which is not necessarily a bad thing, but you know it has sd/x-scissor/leaf blade/filler. So why not just switch out when a psychic type is in? Plus Pinsir can do the job so much better at taking out psychics, and has additional uses such as choice scarf and stealth rocks. Exeggutor can also take focus blasts, but it can also take psychics, where leavanny cannot really take too many of those as it is sr weak. Plus the 3 clauses you used in order to justify using this poke is a reason why you should consider looking else where.
Octillery is strong under trick room, but that's about it. Why not switch into a special poke like Gardevoir, Samurott or Charizard, who boast very high special attack and have speed, unlike octillery who would probably need at least +3 to be effective. And trick room is fairly hard to use and, by experienced players, easy to stall out. Plus its defenses aren't that great, though it can take a hit or maybe 2
Machoke: Doesn't have greater bulk than Gurdurr (80/70/60 machoke vs 85/85/50 Gurdurr). Plus, both pokes cannot really take special moves/psychic anyway. Machoke is somewhat similar, and the confusion rate is nice if you want to risk that. But gurdurr has priority, great abilities in iron fist and guts and can recover without resting, things machoke wold die for. Machoke isn't bad, just gurdurr has so many more opprtunities to help your teams and doesnt always need the bulk ups to be effective. Plus, dynamicpunch Golurk is more threatening if you want to rely on hax. Or liepard lol
Heatmor: Pathetic defenses. 85/66/66 is pretty bad, and consider losing 25% from stealth rocks, you are screwed. Maybe you can get a sucker punch off. Because it is too slow to actually use its impressive attacking stats. Unless you want trick room again. Charizard is better special attacker and is faster, rapidash better physical attacker and faster, and magmar is bulkier with eviolite-- and faster.
Sneasel is C rank and can be a very late gate threatening poke with priority. is cannot take any hits though. But I can see it being C rank.
Look at the Dark Horse Pokemon for example. All pokes that are in Hall of fame are all on the threats list minus Dodrio. This shows that even the pokes not used very often can be still pretty good pokes, hence why they are on the viability list. It is a pretty impressive feat to get these pokes to the guidelines set because of the lack of high tiered pokes on your team. However, the pokes you mentioned have such a small niche that's its not worth letting a player considering playing the nu tier to think that those pokes mentioned are even somewhat viable.