effyouzion said:Keldeo is really good but I don't think he's worthy of a ban. I have a team where my strategy is to take out Celebi/Jelli/Tenta/Amoongus/Gyara/Latias/Latios, make sure I win the weather war, weaken everything else that resists water to the point that it can be KO'd, and then let my scarf Keldeo loose and spam surf or hydro pump for the win. I played a game just today where I was down 5-2, but everything the other guy had left was sufficiently weakened and my rain was up so I was able to spam surf for the win. It reminds me of RBY Tauros in a way. If you let him out too early, he might barely kill one poke, but if you play it right he can clean up entire teams.
Tauros didn't even have any hard counters, but Keldeo has at least those 7 I named. Granted, it's a little different now because the pony can get around those counters with hidden power, but you only get one hidden power. He doesn't have an answer to everything, and it's possible to outplay the person using Keldeo. Not worthy of a ban imo.
Tauros isn't a good example for a variety of reasons, the first being that the RBY metagame is almost entirely different than today's OU outside of the name, you might as well be trying to make a comparison to Hackmons or Little Cup. Secondly, while Tauros has no hard counters (bar Cloyster) there are certainly a variety of Pokemon which can take a hit rather well and weaken it down or even kill it, like Exeggutor and Snorlax. More importantly though, pretty much every use able Pokemon in RBY can combat Tauros in some way or another, even Chansey can cripple with Thunder Wave or KO with Counter.
In the future, avoid making comparisons to early generations, as not only are they treated differently than today, existing before the modern definitions of checks and counters or even Ubers, but in RBY's case, even the basic mechanics are different.


















