alexwolf said:You described a scenario where Trevenant got two free turns, one to get a Sub and another one as he forced a switch. Those scenarios almost never happen against competent players, so basing your reasoning about Curse being good on this doesn't help your argument. Assuming one free turn is fine, assuming two isn't. So, as the opponent brings in their answer to Trevenant, Trevenant goes for a Sub. Next turn, you use Curse and the opponent breaks the Sub. At the end of the turn you are naked against an opponent that can OHKO you, the opponent is at 75% health due to Curse and Trevenant is sitting somewhere between 50% and 75%, depending on if you gained a second Sitrus Berry after consuming the first one. What's so great about this? I would much rather cripple the foe permanently with WoW or help an ally switch in by using Leech Seed, or do both if the foe is already burned. When Leech Seed + WoW are some of the best crippling moves available and Trevenant gets them both, i just can't justify using a third crippling move that needs 50% of your life to activate. Spamming Leech Seed and WoW is just way more productive, and even if the 50% health loss is mitigated by Sitrus Berry (which doesn't always activate), you just don't find the time to use Curse because WoW and Leech Seed are both more spammable and usually more rewarding.
Oh and you say that WoW and Leech Seed can't always be relied on, which is wrong. If the opponent has a Fire-type use Leech Seed, if not use WoW, simple as that.
Together they can be relied on, but separately, they cannot, that was the point, you need both of them to match the damage, and if something is immune to either one, you're weaker. WoW doesn't really "cripple" special attackers either.
Secondly, the whole Trevenant stall set comes down to just that, stalling, and often gets to the point you can sub stall them, which is when they decide to switch, leaving the possiblity to have a sub up when cursing easily possible. Hell, if the opponent finds out it can't break your sub, there is your situation right there.
Thirdly, even if the opponent never puts themselves in that situation, the scenario you laid out is that the opponent is on 75% health, and so are you... You know you can just switch? You go into something that can take hits, and he takes 25% for just staying in, that leaves him at 50%, and for the hell of it lets say you switch into a rocky helmet Ferrothorn, he's now down to what, 20% HP? That's excluding any entry damage in the first place. Regardless of the scenario, the fact is he'll be at 50% at least (most likely lower, because if you're using this Trevenant, you'll be abusing hazards), and won't really want to stay in to take even more damage, which forces a switch, meaning they take even more hazard damage. Leech Seed and WoW are more spammable in terms of cost to use, but they are also blocked easily. Against other stall teams, if you don't have curse, you won't be able to do much, since aromatherapy can cure those burns and leech seed damage is negligible on it's own, while curse damage is not.
Hell, if you're using toxic spike support, will-o-wisp will be limited in its use right there, any team with Gliscor isn't going to care about your Trevenant without curse, curse can't be blocked by protect, magic coat users or substitute, meaning you can also effectively counter other Trevenants with it, use it on anything trying to wish + protect or just protect scouting if the first place, and get past magic coat users.
If you can't justify it's use for your particular team, that is fine, if you'd prefer another move over it, fine, but to talk about curse as if it's a vastly inferior option, that it can not be justified to be put on any set, well, that I will massively disagree with.