It seems to me that a lot of these new propositions have 2 main flaws- they are annoyingly complicated ways to ban whatever is bothering people, and they're based on TCG rules. So I present a tier reshuffle that passes both qualifications:
Merge BL into OU.
That's it. BL is just OU pokes who are currently unpopular, right? Bringing them to OU proper would boost their usage somewhat, expand the metagame, and eliminate the silly faux BL tier. I'm not trying to address the problem of ubering here, this is just a simplification fix. IMO all we need are fewer, larger tiers, and they will balance themselves more easily because of more available counters.
Eh? Wonderful? Junk? I think we do need a reorganized tier set for D/P, so we need to have as many suggestions as possible to find a good one.
Merge BL into OU.
That's it. BL is just OU pokes who are currently unpopular, right? Bringing them to OU proper would boost their usage somewhat, expand the metagame, and eliminate the silly faux BL tier. I'm not trying to address the problem of ubering here, this is just a simplification fix. IMO all we need are fewer, larger tiers, and they will balance themselves more easily because of more available counters.
Eh? Wonderful? Junk? I think we do need a reorganized tier set for D/P, so we need to have as many suggestions as possible to find a good one.