Champ. Gary Oak said:Reasons given for banning Mega Mawile and why they're wrong:
>Its only counter is bulky will-o-wisp Arcanine and there aren't any real checks for it
Wrong. It only has 50/95 special bulk, so most special attackers can finish it off no problem. Along with that, almost any fire type or ground type in OU is capable of 1HKOing it.
The pro-ban arguments are generally that its near impossible to counter, no one is denying that Mawile has checks. Saying a mon has checks is an incomplete no ban argument, every mon has checks.
Champ. Gary Oak said:>b-but it can run subpunch to counter heatran
Subpunch Mawile is a set made specifically for Heatran. It's not nearly as viable as SD Mawile, which is the only set that is arguably OP.
Getting around one of its traditional checks can hardly be considered unviable since Sub lets it get essentially a free hit on whatever decides to switch in. Not to mention it still OHKOs Ferro, and it prevents Skarm from Roosting since it will OHKO if it chooses to do so.
Champ. Gary Oak said:>I-It can sub on will-o-wisp users though
Every single WOW user in OU outspeeds it considerably. It would have to use EVs in speed in place of HP/Attack, making it way worse.
Mawile indeed hates WoW users, but none of them can safely switch in on Mawile, implying something was sacked/the opponent predicted correctly and was able to switch in without being OHKOd. (it can be argued that heatran comes in safely on mawile, but with the subpunch set gaining popularity its by no means a perfect answer anymore).
Champ. Gary Oak said:>It has great typing
But not offensively, and its offensive presence is the reason it's being suspected.
Fairy type is amazing offensively O_o but if you're inclined to believe differently then I guess I can't sway that.
Champ. Gary Oak said:The only legitimate reason I've seen for the ban has been the fact that Mega Mawile is better offensively now that Aegislash is gone from OU, so it's harder to build a balanced team while keeping Mawile in check; however, you shouldn't ban a pokemon for the sole reason that you banned another pokemon, and mega Mawile still has plenty of viable checks and counters in the OU metagame.
Yes, it has checks. But plenty of counters? Name a few mons that can consistently counter the majority of Mawile variants (they are few and far between).
Although this may seem pro-bannish, I'm not swayed either way yet. I just feel that your arguments are generally flawed (but no disrespect meant by any means)
EDIT: A TON of posts popped up right before I posted... as a general comment to those responding to other posters, being rude/condescending towards other people doesn't help in proving your point, even if you arguments are better/more informed than who you're responding to.