Albacore said:Ranking Honchkrow is something I brought up earlier and though I haven't used it in a while, I still think don't it's too much of a stretch to do this. It suffers huge competition from both Bisharp and Talonflame and it's kind of a weaker hybrid of both, but there are a few reasons to run it
I'll just comment on Albas points and people can read along since this is the only good feedback I've seen on what is basically a suicide Pokemon that got really hyped at the beginning of ORAS and I strongly believe is still overhyped based on what I've seen in practice. Suffering huge competition to the point of obscurity is a pretty important reason why something shouldn't be ranked or should be ranked so low.
- Why you'd run it over Bisharp : Not a free switchin for Keldeo, Chesnaught and other Fighting types, Ground immunity is really useful for a lot of teams and stop stuff like Scarf Lando-T and Lando-I from completely sweeping, 1 extra base speed lets it outspeed things which specifically creep Bisharp such as Celebi and some Lando-Ts, and usable SpA combined with either Heat Wave or Dark Pulse which lets it break past physical walls, most notably Skarmory.
I mean Keldeo is the emergency Bisharp switch in on offense, that doesn't mean Keldeo wants to be willy nilly taking Knock Offs from Bisharp especially in the case when its capabilities necessitate that it maintains its item. So Honchkrow is once again playing these Sucker Punch mind-games that it may or may not win. If you want to be realistic Bisharp can run lure sets to hit Keldeo and Chesnaught with Aerial Ace so I don't see how this is a strong selling point for using Honchkrow over Bisharp. Honckhrow is taking neutral from Fighting types, frail, and is not fast at all, so unless it's something like Conkeldurr you're playing a very shaky game against the majority of these fighting types. Ground immunity is useful for the sake of having some leniency against your general ground type users in regards to being a emergency pivot to be immune to said ground move. This doesn't change the fact that stuff such as Lando-T and Garchomp all have ways to hit the ground type immune Pokemon in some way or form, so in Honchkrows case Stone Edge from Lando-T and any relevant Dragon move from Garchomp. The creep factor is something that changes as the metagame goes along and 2-3 more evs in speed to outpace Honchkrow isn't exactly a burden that is hard to correct so another thing that isn't really a selling point other than to outrun stuff you already run.
- Why you'd run it over Talonflame : Hits much harder, has far better coverage with the combination of Brave Bird and Superpower preventing TTar and other Rock types from screwing it over as easily and making it far better at wallbreaking in general, and Moxie's snowball effect can make it tricky to revenge kill.
This only applies to support Ttars, unless you predict (this goes both ways of course) you're dealing with a ScarfTar, the more common variant now a days, threatening you with Stone Edge and that's the mind game that is not in your favor. You'd run Talonflame because it has more superiority in its overall arsenal to effect the tier. A burn immunity, amongst 5 different legitimate sets that you can run, and even a couple of lure sets to turn some of these checks and counters into a liability. Moxies snowball effect is by virtue its only real selling point that isn't actually large when you take into account it kills itself off very quickly based on Life Orb recoil + Brave Bird damage. You could say that by removing checks and counters it'll amplify its Moxie abilities but a Pokemons capabilities will always be improved when ones checks and counters are out of the way to begin with.
Its closest comparison is probably Pinsir, which is a far superior version of it but takes up a mega slot. In fact, it's actually a decent partner to Pinsir on birdspam teams since it lures Skarmory and Slowbro and weakens Rotom-W and Rhyperior thanks to Dark Pulse. Basically, if you're using Honchkrow, use either Dark Pulse or Heat Wave because that's half the reason to use it in the first place.
That has to do more with a playstyle, birdspam, than an actual comparison and basically by this definition we're going to assume that the cores you're wearing down don't have back-up answers to mitigate the effectiveness of this core. Pinsir might take up the mega slot but it's not being over dependent on the power of Life Orb to be effective and unlike Honchkrow isn't being worn down by said item. The comparison is a stretch when Pinsir already has easier ways of bypassing these checks and counters either through a utility move in something like Swords Dance or a partner such as Magnezone who not only helps with certain issues Pinsir has, namely Skarmory, but also has other traits to offer from an offensive and most importantly defensive standpoint.
Admittedly it dies extremely fast and has a really unfortunate combination of bad speed and bad bulk, and I haven't seen it used in tours at all, but the same can be said of stuff like Chandelure and Cofagrigus (in fact Chandelure is very similar to Honchkrow in terms of viability in the sense that it's also a hybrid of 2 far, far better Pokemon, Gengar and Heatran, while not being good enough to be chosen over either is the vast majority of cases). I don't know if in practice it can viably fit on any team so I'm not really sure if it deserves a rank but it definitely needs to be discussed.
That's my problem, it dies extremely fast. Chandelure and Honchkrow should not be compared in terms of viability because Chandelure has a bit more flexibility due to its typing and sets that it can run such as Life Orb attacker, Scarf, and stall-breaker Chandelure and is one of the more consistent checks to Charizard-Y on any given day, a very dangerous threat against Balanced builds. Chandelure may have some competition to Gengar and Heatran but the combination of traits that Chandelure has allows itself to have more tools at its disposable based on the build that you're using it for. You're pretty much comparing apples and oranges at this point. Cofagrigus benefits itself from being a pseudo check to physical contact attackers such as M-Lopunny and M-Metagross, so not easily comparable to begin with.
By all means feel free to prove me wrong but the traits that you would use Honchkrow for seem very limited and sort of is relying on the idea that these are all standard aspects that always apply in practice when the reality is that Honchkrow finds itself as a niche tool or is used for shits and giggles with players who have better tools at disposable but because of their ability can make a bad option seem great.