fyourblog said:Honestly, after playing multiple games, the meta just isn't better and arguable much worse. M-Sableye stall variations have increased tenfold and has basically pigeonholed teambuilding even worse than Lando-I did. Now you have to carry Manaphy or one of the other very few stallbreakers to even have a chance at beating these teams. If you guys want a stally meta then go ahead and vote ban, but I will 100% be voting no ban.
Also I'm dying laughing at the hypocrisy some of the above posters are using. The fact that I got laughed at for saying that Knock Off, Calm Mind, and Rock Slide Lando-I aren't as significant as the main RP set, yet people are trying to argue that Icy Wind Gengar is just "niche" is ridiculous. There are some good points brought up about Gengar here-- it has just as many counters as Lando-I does. Does that mean it deserves a ban? I guess it's only convenient to use usage in explaining viability when it's for YOUR argument.
How is "having" to carry Manaphy to have a chance against Stall/Balance an argument to keep Landorus? If we have to keep Landorus around for the sake of avoiding unbreakable Stall builds, then the issue is the Stall builds being powerful enough to require something we'd ban in order to break them. When you consider options like Gengar, Serperior, Kyu-B, Zard X and Y, Gardevoir, and Alakazam (to name a few from high ranks), there's plenty of offensive options for Wall/Balance Breaking.
And the point being made was that Icy Wind doesn't do as much for Gengar as Rock Slide/Knock Off does for Landorus. Icy Wind deals with a few checks slightly easier, considering that aside from SpD Gliscor, Gengar can 2HKO most of Icy Wind's target with his LO set already.
fyourblog said:No, I mean if you read any of arguments I refute the idea that usage = viability. Instead I state its one of the best indicators to what is viable. People argued that even if Knock Off is low in usage, Lando must be banned because it can still use it and counter and other threats. Then when the fact that Gengar has no counters because of Icy Wind came up, people started claiming that Gengar's using Icy Wind are "niche" and basically low in usage. The same argument I used for Lando. So what's stopping us from banning Gengar? It has no counters or really just as many as Lando does.
I'm not seeing talk of people saying Icy Wind Gengar is "niche" and disregardable here in the thread, unless I'm not reading something the same way you are. The point was more that Landorus being OHKO'd is one of the big reasons Gengar likes Icy Wind, since other targets like Garchomp could be 2HKOed by Shadow ball anyway.
And the issue with Landorus is you disregarded things like Knock Off altogether for low usage. I even recall one statement along the lines of preparing for Rock Polish being all you needed to be prepared for Landorus.
fyourblog said:Wow, I don't know how many times I need to repeat myself. Lando-I using Knock Off has 12.4% usage. Lando-I's using Rock Slide and Focus Blast have even less % usage. These ARE NOT valid arguments. You are cherry picking moves that are NOT valid in the current meta. Lando-I using these moves MEANS he gets countered by other pokes that he usually beats. The RP set is the MOST USED and MOST VALID. It means team building for him is team building for that set.
Even if RP is Landorus's best set, that doesn't mean you can get away with preparing only for that set. The AoA set is still able to do some pretty decent damage to offense, even if it's not sweeping the entire team.
And quite frankly, I'd argue that Landorus's AoA and CM sets, less effective or not, are still more influential in the Metagame than the difference between Icy Wind vs Taunt on Gengar. Gengar is losing Taunt, a big factor in how he troubles Balance and Stall, to beat one of his counters and hit a few other things slightly harder. Landorus with Knock Off or Rock Slide misses out on some targets, but he gains the ability to hit just as many equally well. It's not significantly different from simply changing HP Electric to HP Bug on Keldeo (Gyarados to Celebi answer move), just that Landorus gets a larger range of mons changed out with different coverage.
fyourblog said:I'm not arguing that Lando-I is a solid Gengar check, I'm arguing that Gengar has little to no checks in the current meta-- but that's not a reason to ban it. Also I'd argue that if you prepare your team for RP Lando, than it can be beaten. While Gengar can be easily revenge killed, Lando-I has a variety of checks that can revenge kill it as well in the meta.
And the issue is that Landorus has both much greater power, better defenses (not a wall, but there's much more he'll survive than Gengar), much less susceptible to passive damage (Gengar takes LO recoil, fears priority just as much if not more, while being just as vulnerable to hazards).
252+ Atk Choice Band Huge Power Azumarill Aqua Jet vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Gengar: 180-213 (69.4 - 82.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ Atk Choice Band Huge Power Azumarill Aqua Jet vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Landorus: 260-308 (81.5 - 96.5%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
That's a approximately an 11% difference, which seems notable, but Landorus is not only weak to that move, but Gengar loses 10% more to his LO in counter attacking. The comparison loses gravity because Landorus not only has absurd power and coverage, but he's not so frail as to be an outright glass cannon like most offensive mons with that kind of strength. Gengar also doesn't immediately swing momentum to his side just by getting on the field. While powerful, Gengar's moves aren't so absurd as to OHKO most neutral targets and consistently 2HKO resists, so while difficult, he's not ABSURD to check in the same way.
fyourblog said:I know you're being sarcastic but sure. Things that can come in and revenge kill Lando-I contains a large part of the meta. Alakazam, Azumarill, Conk, Gengar, Gyarados, Keldeo, Kyurem, Both Latis, M-Lop, Raikou, Rotom-W, Skarm, Slowbro, Starmie, Talonflame, Torn-T, Thundurus-T, Scarf Tar, SpD Zapdos, Crawdaunt, Klefki, Pinsir, Thundurus, Victini, SpD Volc, Weavile.
If you've prepped your team for RP Lando, that means you've prepped your team for 50% of Lando's in the meta right now. When you include this long list of revenge killers and checks that can come in on Lando, you can work around the other 50% that aren't RP, "the cores associated with it", very easily.
You only proved mons that can eliminate Landorus himself. You did nothing to disprove "the cores associated with it" by listing those. The point of cores is specifically for the mons to support each other because as good as they may be, no mon is perfect. The problem therein becomes that Landorus requires very little support to do his job while being extremely capable of supporting numerous mons himself without having to jump through hoops with his coverage.
Building a core involving Landorus is extremely low maintenance since Landorus has the tools to cover most of whatever it wants from the metagame with the right set. Many people have brought up the fact that Landorus can't actually handle every single answer to him in the Metagame because he only has 4 moves. Cores mitigate this complaint almost to the point of negligence because at that point, Landorus usually isn't even the heavy for the team. For example, say I build an offensive core around Serperior and Mega Metagross. The most likely thing this core will struggle with are extremely fast mons like Alakazam, Scarftini, and certain Steel types like Skarmory, opposing Metagross or Magnet Rise Klefki. My Landorus at that point doesn't have to be able to beat everything, just those mons to fulfill his roles. So the RP or AoA set using Focus Blast as one of the coverage moves is sufficient for what I need Landorus to do. Unlike most mons though, Landorus doesn't tend to then put much strain on core partners beyond that, because he requires minimal support of his own, so I'm mainly concerned with the members he was already brought in to support: w/out Knock Off or Rock Slide he has trouble with Lati@s and Torn-T, which Metagross handles extremely well in this example.
Landorus's extremely low opportunity makes him very easy to fit onto a team, and the ability to handle so many of his checks on his own makes him easy to support with team members that deal with the rest of them for him instead. Look at where the argument's gotten so far with the mood mostly being "Landorus vs the Metagame". Most of the anti-ban arguments are dealing with how answering Landorus himself goes, but this isn't just Landorus; you have to fight Landorus and his merry band of Sidekicks to be prepared.
Rock Polish Landorus has some answers like Weavile and CB Azumarill for example as Revenge Killers. So what happens if the opponent's team is built to pressure out those answers when fighting offense so they are worn out or broken before Landorus attempts his sweep. Heck, Landorus himself can draw them in early since they have to be prepared to get on the field ASAP after Landorus does, since the only free turn they could have is his boosting turn, and revenging means he probably killed something, which arguably can't be afforded by the point Landorus sweeps, or might have cost the team its best answer to the other/secondary win condition, such as losing Mega Scizor before Mega Metagross/Altaria, or losing Hippowdon before a Zard-X.
Landorus is an offensive crutch to teambuilding in addition to being a strain on the opposition. For defensive teams, dealing with Landorus is extremely tricky because of how many variants a team must be prepared for (even if 50% of Landorus are RP, I don't like the idea of the other 50% being able to run over me themselves). For offensive teams, Landorus is extremely easy to tailor to whatever a team might have missed in the teambuilding process, by poor construction or otherwise. It's similar to something I disapproved of with Aegislash: he's so easy to fit onto teams (albeit not nearly in as many roles or every archetype) and perform the role/provide the synergy he was chosen for that good teambuilding doesn't necessarily require exemplary skill, but just decent skill and the ability to choose the right Landorus set. It's extremely difficult to build a decent offensive team that would not be better for the inclusion of Landorus-I in the role of a wall breaker.