Having used Rattata and Sentret before (and I must have used different Pokemon to Hiddenfreezer because I didn't think they were bad at all, and I certainly didn't feel compelled to reset my game due to how much I regretted using Sentret), I would say that Sentret is worse initially because Sentret's Base 20 Speed is so dreadful (it actually ties with Geodude) and it gets outsped more frequently than Rattata early-game, but once both of them evolve they are as similar as Lucchini says, although Furret has a wider Special movepool that Raticate if it's worth anything. I think to say that GSC Furret is at the same level of suck as BW Purrloin is pushing it lol
Just wondering, but what is everyone's opinion on gift Spearow vs. early game wild Spearow? I think the boosted experience is nice but I also think that happiness could be an issue when trying to use Return. Remember that the in-game trade one is going to be at its default happiness when it's obtained (I'm assuming?) which gives Return a whopping 28 Base Power, whereas a wild caught Spearow should have a much more powerful Return due to being on your team for longer. But maybe it wouldn't matter too much since it can just use Swift in the meantime. I'd call it A tier either way though.
Random Passerby said:Oh yeah, is Corsola really that bad? You can grab one after Whitney (Lv20) and can teach it Surf + Rollout right away. It also comes with Recover. Then, at Lv37, it learns Mirror Coat which might be too late for Claire but cool for Will, Karen and Lance (especially when you have Recover)
Well, Corsola is definitely among the best Pokemon we have in E-tier right now if not the best, and I do kind of like how its part Rock typing gives it useful Normal and Poison resistances for Team Rocket which is kinda niche for a Water type (although questionable in usefulness since the best Water types will just obliterate everything with STAB Surf). I don't really feel that strongly about it rising or dropping though.
Lucchini said:Tauros/Miltank are way bulkier than these two, and thus more reliable, but it's true that neither happens to learn Dig (which would help against Morty and Jasmine) and also have poorer availability in a tier list discussion where we're currently at a point when we only treat the pre-Kanto portion of the game as worth investigating and considering, and where Falkner, Bugsy and Whitney actually form 3/8ths of the gym conquest (if you want to catch Tauros/Miltank with a Friend Ball, and you should, you have to wait until Morty is beaten and you can Surf, so that's nearly a half of the maingame pretty much).
Yeah this is what I was getting at with my comment. I don't know, I guess I just favour availability more than most. Like, obviously Tauros and Miltank are bulkier and I'm sure that might come into play sometimes, but if Normal-types are so overpowered, why would you wait for the mid-Johto, rarish, low catch-rate ones when there are several perfectly decent alternative Normals that are easier to catch and are available too you for practically the whole game? Honestly if we really are talking about "efficiency" in a playthrough, I'd argue that Rattata and Spearow are superior to Tauros and Miltank despite the higher bulk.