boltsandbombers said:I know I'm not always right nor do I expect everyone to agree with everything I say, but I might as well try and defend myself.
So, the arguments against Blizzard + Snow Warning are:
- Less PP
- Weather dependent
- Hinders teammates
- Cant hit through subs
- "Straight up weaker"
Less PP: Are you really telling me that you'd end up clicking Hyper Voice 9 times in a game [as opposed to Blizzards 8 PP]? Because I dont see any scenario where that would be the case (if I'm wrong tell me), most of the time its between 2 and 6ish (at most) because most of the time Aurorus gets a kill or heavily dents something and then something revenge kills / forces it out due to its awful typing. Nothing super relevant with Pressure apart from Articuno, so this doesnt seem like a great negative.
Weather dependent: Why is this an issue? Snow Warning summons hail and then you can freely spam blizzard, its not like specs aurorus is staying in for more than 5 turns, and there arent any relevant pokemon that can automatically get rid of Aurorus's Hail apart from hippopotas which has no business switching in and is very uncommon, and manual weather setters like uxie and liepard take massive damage from Blizzard upon switch in [uxie is 2HKOed iirc and obviously Liepard straight up dies], and its basically they are coming in after Aurorus gets a kill, which isnt a great justification.
Hinders teammates: This is one of the more significant negatives, but like I said earlier, Specs Aurorus mainly fits on offensive teams which arent completely ruined by residual damage, unlike defensive pokemon which have to switch in and out a lot.
Cant hit through subs: Lets go over the list of potential sub users after skimming through the vr thread that having Hyper Voice would be beneficial for:
- Sub Endeavor Tauros: Pretty non existant in ORAS after mega steelix is gone, but on the chance it has EQ that would deal hefty damage anyways.
- Sub CM Uxie: Awful set in ORAS compared to CM 3 Attacks, but I can kinda see the merit here.
- Sub Klinklang: lol it just kills you anyways
- Sub 3 Attacks Malamar: This one is a pretty good reason, but RestTalk is much more common.
- Sub Split Rotom: Fair one, but still not switching in obviously.
- Sub SD Bouffalant: Thats fair as well.
I feel that hitting through subs just isnt beneficial enough to justify the use over Blizzard.
Straight up weaker: No its not, as I showed with the calcs Blizzard + Hail outdamages Refrigerate Hyper Voice by 2%.
mmmk, here's last round of rebuttal :P
1) PP: admittedly, it's hands down the weakest point against Blizzard - but it's literally never a bad thing to have more PP. Now obviously PP rarely ever comes into play, but Blizzard would come closer to that (he's stalling me out of Blizzards) thought while playing more often than Hyper Voice would. On a side note, when playing against Hail teams which are no longer non-existent (only nearly non-existent), Having more Hyper Voices vs Articuno is helpful.
2) Out Damages: time to math.
Alright. Now, this is Choice Specs fucking Aurorus we're talking about here.
It hits rather hard. There's very few Pokemon who won't be getting at the least, 2HKOd by it. and those that do avoid the 2HKO? What item do you think they're gonna have? Is that super bulky thing going to have a Life Orb? Likely not. In fact the only Pokemon who could potentially be Offensive and take 2 stab hits are Articuno, Cryogonal, and Regice, all of which are immune to Hail anyways. So it's safe to say that anything avoiding just getting nuked (by either set) will be holding Leftovers - which cancels out Hail's mythical 6% advantage it has over Hyper Voice.
[In laymans terms: the Pokemon who takes a Hyper Voice gets hit 6% harder, but heals 6%. The Pokemon getting hit by Blizzard gets hit 6% weaker, but doesn't heal.]
This stands true for any Pokemon that takes around 70% or more damage, aka a clean 2HKO, from Hyper Voice.
(at that high of a damage range, Hyper Voice cleanly beats out Blizzard by 6%) But, Hyper Voice sadly doesn't always outdamage Blizzard by 6%. At lower ranges it gets beaten out after Hail; but how low is too low? Aurorus has great coverage it loves to abuse against any wall that would take less than 40%~ from it's main STAB Ice move (the one we're comparing), so it's silly to compare damage ranges below about 40%. At 40% for Hyper Voice, Blizzard would be doing about 36.5% so let's round er' up and say 37%. Against any competent player, the hail damage would round down (odd HP) to 5%. This leaves us with: Blizzard does 3% less damage + 5% additional hail damage = somewhere around (depending on damage variations) a grand total of 1-2% more damage per turn, even if you use Blizzard at the minimum viable range. To say the least, this point is as powerful as the PP point - it's negligible in 99% of games.
3) Teammates: Something that isn't negligible in 99% of games is your team structure. Now obviously Aurorus doesn't restrict your teambuilding by very much if it carries Snow Warning, but it prevents you from wanting to carry your own Musharna, Vileplume, Gourgiest, Sturdy Sawk, Sturdy Magneton, Sash Vivvy, Sash Archeops, Sash anything, because if you end up forced into it at an inopportune time, you're kinda shooting yourself in the foot. Obviously with Refridgerate teammates are 0% an issue. I personally don't understand handicapping yourself for a
4.091% (couldn't find 1750 cause smogon.com/stats only has lc stuff?) chance of running into a Musharna and limiting it's recovery. Wanting that Sturdy still intact on your Sawk likely happens more than 4% of battles.
4) Hitting through Subs: First two points we've debated about really both are negligible. They come into play so fucking rarely that neither can be determined "better" than the other soley from that. Hell, even the 3rd point is rather shaky, maybe you can create a great Offensive team with Snow Warning Aurorus without Sturdy, Focus Sash, or Weather-based Healing Moves. This last point, while again not a common occurrence, has nothing but positives to offer for Fridge side of the debate, and nothing to offer for the Snowy side.
I would argue that maybe, once in every 10 battles (let's ere on the side of caution here with estimates), that you bring in Aurorus on something that has a Sub up. That's 10% of the time, having Hyper Voice and Refridgerate is more beneficial. That's double as often as Snow Warning is potentially (only lasts 5 turns) able to ruin Musharna's recovery.
tl;dr: I honestly think being able to hit through subs and not have to even think about teammate conflicts is worth a lot more than you're playing off. The extra damage is negligible, the PP is negligible, so it all falls onto those last points. I really don't care if we slash Snow Warning and Blizzard afterwards on the Specs set and explain the differences in Set Details between how the abilities play, and what you can expect with them - I just refuse to allow Snow Warning to be called the "better" ability for the Specs set. It's simply not true.
spoiler
spent more time on point 2 than I did on the actual analysis so far ROFL