Timeline of events:
I don't like the lynch on GME and figure I get more utility after showing my unlynchability.
I post at 11:23pm.
Haruno posts at 11:25pm after seeing nobody is going for the shubaka lynch, no lynch is in range of beating a GME lynch, and I have just proposed essentially a no lynch as well.
Haruno said:
rather have this than not having a lynch at all. I'm still pretty positive that shubaka and/or vpp are scum
Haruno then votes GME saying he'd rather someone die - why? In D1 of a NOC with no reason for it? GME hadn't done anything scummy except idle. There was no good reason for town to support a lynch on GME that day and quite possibly lose one of their own.
Haruno is also sure shubaka/vpp are scum yet refuses to try and push for a lynch on either by appealing to everyone around deadline and instead chooses GME for... what reason, exactly? Except that mafia don't want no lynches and a mislynch would be just swell.
Former Hope votes me at 11:34pm.
rssp1 asks if I am 1s or not at 11:37pm.
I reply after confirming with jalmont I didn't misunderstand my role and yolo too hard at 11:39pm (I had pmed him before rssp1 posted):
Yeti said:
no i have IMMORTALITYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
rssp1 replies at 11:41 saying he's sticking on shubaka because he... doesn't want to waste my oneshot?
After I had said no, it's not a 1s?
Blazade also votes me at 11:41pm.
I clarify again to rssp1 it's not a 1s lpv at 11:47pm after a vote count reveals it's 4 GME to 3 me.
MeowMixxx puts the nail in GME's coffin at 11:58pm, likely to ensure no lurking town are going to vote me and thus tie the lynch, resulting in no proving my LPV BUT no death.
MeowMixxx is surely mafia for this move. There is no way a villager does this unless they are just really, really bad at NOC. GME was not a 'slam dunk scum' and there was no reason to force a lynch on D1 - it was NOT informative on anyone's connections especially since GME had been relatively inactive.
Haruno's logic that it would incriminate shubaka/vpp even more if GME flipped town is thus faulty. Haruno is a strong candidate for either idiot!town or mafia along with MM for the exact same reason - town does not want to try and force a lynch on D1 when proving someone's role or NL are options. Considering his hood Vegeta play and the terrible Bulma claim in DBZ NOC maybe he just yolos way too hard in NOCs and makes flawed logical connections.
rssp1, now, is an interesting subject. After being told no, it's not a 1s LPV, he responds as if I had said yes, it is, that he won't change his vote to 'waste' it. I then tag him to clarify again, no, it's not a 1s. He never replies. If he was there 20 minutes before deadline where does he go as it's winding down? Does anyone really believe town!rssp1 just up and misreads my response then vanishes after more clarification? To me this feels like a mafia move - he intentionally mistook my clarification as a justification for not helping town by voting me and securing a no lynch/proof of my role - without even having to be voting for GME to look suspicious! I just don't see why after being informed then corrected he keeps his vote on shubaka knowing GME has 1+ more votes than me.
I townread FH and Blazade for being willing to try and prove my LPV as well as try and avoiding the GME mislynch.