NOC a nice basic game of actual mafia - game over - won by the Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
tropiusisbae said:
I am asking twin why he currently suspects me as scum. You can tell me any suspicions you have while you are at it if you want
Click to expand...
I suspect you because you didn't seem like normal Dullagamur early game and you had few post count with nothing of value, I'm still suspecting you now because to me it feels like you are sticking with your reads because you fucked up and don't want to seem contradictory.
 
You're scum because your reasoning is very forced and the thing with empoof sacrificing himself sounds like you just want to say next day look guys I'm so town cause I read empoof as town and refusing to commit to a scum read is scummy also
 
Tropius arguing my townness didn't make sense at the time I was at and calling me a "brilliant townie" is flattering but felt super forced to me. Need to read but have like 15 mins

Mithril looked scummy to me and I want to say their unvote was well timed with my calling them a busser
 
Empoof said:
Tropius arguing my townness didn't make sense at the time I was at and calling me a "brilliant townie" is flattering but felt super forced to me. Need to read but have like 15 mins

Mithril looked scummy to me and I want to say their unvote was well timed with my calling them a busser
Click to expand...

Stop flattering yourself. My unvote was 100% timed with stopping whydon from putting you at L-1 since I'd rather the day not end early.
 
King_ said:
I suspect you because you didn't seem like normal Dullagamur early game and you had few post count with nothing of value, I'm still suspecting you now because to me it feels like you are sticking with your reads because you fucked up and don't want to seem contradictory.
Click to expand...
I didn't seem like dullagamur, I explained that I want a fresh start with a new name. I think we can all agree that since the post or sub requirement, I have played very differently. As for sticking to the reads, I have stated that my sandshrewz read has changed. I will be re-evaluating everything during the silence of the night phase. Please explain how else I am sticking with claims because I fucked up

Thetwinmasters said:
You're scum because your reasoning is very forced and the thing with empoof sacrificing himself sounds like you just want to say next day look guys I'm so town cause I read empoof as town and refusing to commit to a scum read is scummy also
Click to expand...
My reasoning is forced? please provide examples. A successful town read means nothing as you all know, finally I ask you to check whether I am currently voting on someone or not
 
Scum team Whydon Mithril Tropius and idler looks good. Haruno can be in there too, idk if I'm anti tunneling too hard but that one read post swayed me well and his response to me sounds genuine af.

Mithril I'm literally thoughts to page at this point and I love myself so sorry if I sound egotistical
 
So I stopped whydon from going to L-1 and have been on tropius for a while, yet I'm on a scum team with them. That's honestly absurd. Now you feel like you are grasping at straws. It's happening anyway and I dont particularly care how this looks at this point.

Unvote vote empoof
 
Show me where you were on Tropius, I saw you null read him and nothing after.

Easily could have missed.
Everyone and their mom has to say Shubaka is maf at this point
 
Looking through the thread, I've noticed that Whydon and Sandshrewz are both trying really hard to prove that they're bad at this game and don't know what what they're doing. Almost a little forced tbh. Considering them for scumteam.
 
King_ said:
So what made you change your mind about this?
Click to expand...

(This is assuming after sandshrewz is mafia) After sandshrewz got called out for lurking, they quickly wrote up a spreadsheet post to try and reduce the suspicion on themselves. So if sandshrewz is clearly mafia, then clearly they don't want to be suspected at all, so they stopped lurking. Plus at this point in the game with all of these accusations being thrown around, it would make no sense for mafia to keep lurking at this point.

also rip om room?
 
I labeled Mithril as my busser before, he had the least reasoning from what I remember and the other guys voting for me I had harder town reads on. It's nice play for him to remove lynch so no one hammers, but it was after my call out and he could've left it empty with intent to come back. Instead he moves to Sandshrewz

Also his "I really can't read Tropius" shines me as if the wagon moves he'll bus it.

Mithril I can't see # on phone need link.
 
SomewhatOddish said:
Looking through the thread, I've noticed that Whydon and Sandshrewz are both trying really hard to prove that they're bad at this game and don't know what what they're doing. Almost a little forced tbh. Considering them for scumteam.
Click to expand...

Really? It would make no sense for two members of the mafia team to act stupid together. Also, while it isn't common for mafia to throw other mafia under the bus to keep themselves safe, I called out sandshrewz and pressured him very hard for answers. His frustration is fairly evident in his posts.
 
Whydon said:
(This is assuming after sandshrewz is mafia) After sandshrewz got called out for lurking, they quickly wrote up a spreadsheet post to try and reduce the suspicion on themselves. So if sandshrewz is clearly mafia, then clearly they don't want to be suspected at all, so they stopped lurking. Plus at this point in the game with all of these accusations being thrown around, it would make no sense for mafia to keep lurking at this point.

also rip om room?
Click to expand...
like he said he made a spreadsheet and you're focusing in on that wayy to much imo.
 
I'm clocking on in like 2 minutes, would really like that post you said you had of "being on" Tropius

Otherwise I'm leaving that as scum read and when I flip town I'm expecting fun times
 
Empoof said:
I labeled Mithril as my busser before, he had the least reasoning from what I remember and the other guys voting for me I had harder town reads on. It's nice play for him to remove lynch so no one hammers, but it was after my call out and he could've left it empty with intent to come back. Instead he moves to Sandshrewz

Also his "I really can't read Tropius" shines me as if the wagon moves he'll bus it.

Mithril I can't see # on phone need link.
Click to expand...

This is 435. It is not a super strong defense, but of everything at that point there were 3 people I would vote for. Sandshrewz, Tropius, and yourself. Sandshrewz is not getting traction and I was still on the fence for you after all of your posts after the "surrender."

It's play where you have made really odd reads overall and have been unwilling to make definitive statements about anybody. I strongly believe no lynch is the wrong answer as it prevents us from getting any useful information.

AM I sure you are mafia, no. But you are definitely one of the more likely ones to me.
Click to expand...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top