• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC a nice basic game of actual mafia - game over - won by the Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can't tell if this is just acting out having a check or if this is an actual cop claim, and at this point I don't care, and unless you're mafia, neither should you.

I do not want to discuss peeks any longer. Unless someone wants to hard claim cop, we are no longer going to discuss one another's peeks. We will let them sit and if a cop dies, we will use them, and if not, we will ignore them because it is anti-town to try to publicly speculate on who the cops are. If this explanation is not sufficient to you, feel free to ask me to explain because this matters a lot.
 
2 things: Saboteur can't act until WW and Arsonist are dead, so we've got atleast two more nights. Additionally, Saboteur shows up on all inspects as guilty as well.

2) I don't think I can keep up with this game, I'm trying to do too many things at once. If I can continue lurking and only swoop in when needed I can last til Friday but if somebody actively wants subbed in go for it.

Lynch Haruno due to either easy bus or tropius = scum. Either way, we lynch a scum. Why not take the bait?
 
to clarify the saboteur can still use his roleblock while arsonist/wolf are alive, it's just the kill he can't do

i'll hook you guys up with a votecount later tonight
 
shubaka17 said:
2 things: Saboteur can't act until WW and Arsonist are dead, so we've got atleast two more nights. Additionally, Saboteur shows up on all inspects as guilty as well.

2) I don't think I can keep up with this game, I'm trying to do too many things at once. If I can continue lurking and only swoop in when needed I can last til Friday but if somebody actively wants subbed in go for it.

Lynch Haruno due to either easy bus or tropius = scum. Either way, we lynch a scum. Why not take the bait?
Click to expand...
the thing is, you weren't really active during the weekend so I don't know when you can be active
 
Pooped from today/Weeb Hosting so I'll come back with something tomorrow.

Starting to think back on Twin/DLE I think I'm willing to investigate the possibility that DLE is scum. His scumgame relies on a lot of pinging and asking questions from what I've seen/heard, he's made himself demonstrably active and that's helped him a lot but it could easily be a front.

Points for DLE:
-I Think King is clearly town, especially now after his towntell, so that read was on point and not the least controversial at the time either.
-Gut Read on OM(now me) was also great, I felt I was subbing into town and DLE's game got townier when I read that too
-I also liked the defend on tropius, that was again a sentiment I had while reading the thread as an outsider.

Points against DLE:
-I thought it was odd of him to be so set on the Empoof lynch after not only the resign, but also the reads that followed. I don't think a Mafia tries that hard or that genuinely to get something from their own lynch, even if some may resign for sympathy.
-Whydon push is starting to feel a little bandwagony from everyone and I honestly don't trust myself to scumread a playstyle I simply hate because it's anti town but also realistic in both scenarios. I also feel like if Whydon is town, then DLE is likely scum from the way they've interacted.
-Some of the above townreads could be buddying
-I'm surprised DLE let this claim bullshit fly especially from a scumread (this being the important part) especially after his MU game when that was scumdriven and even more surprised at the way it's being handled now. The way I see it Mafia very likely has discerned at least one cop (and 100% of the time significantly narrowed the playing field) and it feels like he could be trying to stoke town confusion. That's a soft read with a lot of gamespec so it's minor. DLE is also right in that peeks should not be the main point of discussion and that these people claiming guilties should provide actual reasons for their scumreads instead of just going"results lol"

Questions for the crowd:

Take a stance: How do you feel about the push on Whydon?
Do you think DLE is scum motivated? If so, who do you think he's long term trying to push? If not, what about his game seems genuine?
 
Blazade said:
Pooped from today/Weeb Hosting so I'll come back with something tomorrow.

Starting to think back on Twin/DLE I think I'm willing to investigate the possibility that DLE is scum. His scumgame relies on a lot of pinging and asking questions from what I've seen/heard, he's made himself demonstrably active and that's helped him a lot but it could easily be a front.

Points for DLE:
-I Think King is clearly town, especially now after his towntell, so that read was on point and not the least controversial at the time either.
-Gut Read on OM(now me) was also great, I felt I was subbing into town and DLE's game got townier when I read that too
-I also liked the defend on tropius, that was again a sentiment I had while reading the thread as an outsider.

Points against DLE:
-I thought it was odd of him to be so set on the Empoof lynch after not only the resign, but also the reads that followed. I don't think a Mafia tries that hard or that genuinely to get something from their own lynch, even if some may resign for sympathy.
-Whydon push is starting to feel a little bandwagony from everyone and I honestly don't trust myself to scumread a playstyle I simply hate because it's anti town but also realistic in both scenarios. I also feel like if Whydon is town, then DLE is likely scum from the way they've interacted.
-Some of the above townreads could be buddying
-I'm surprised DLE let this claim bullshit fly especially from a scumread (this being the important part) especially after his MU game when that was scumdriven and even more surprised at the way it's being handled now. The way I see it Mafia very likely has discerned at least one cop (and 100% of the time significantly narrowed the playing field) and it feels like he could be trying to stoke town confusion. That's a soft read with a lot of gamespec so it's minor. DLE is also right in that peeks should not be the main point of discussion and that these people claiming guilties should provide actual reasons for their scumreads instead of just going"results lol"

Questions for the crowd:

Take a stance: How do you feel about the push on Whydon?
Do you think DLE is scum motivated? If so, who do you think he's long term trying to push? If not, what about his game seems genuine?
Click to expand...
The push on Whydon is a good one imo, Whydon doesn't really do anything except "I'm new so Mafia can just push to lynch me anytime" and also "Sandshrewz is mafia". He doesn't think anyone else is possible scum and keeps on pushing on Sandshrewz. He doesn't even gives his opinion on anyone else and I feel like he's trying to avoid giving info to town.

I personally don't think DLE is scum. If he is scum I feel he would've directed the scummerino's aka (Whydon + Tropius + Sandshrewz + Aubisio)? a little better instead of making it seem like they're in a sense of panic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top