FlamingVictini said:I can't be bothered to read every post thus far or write something lengthy myself, or even bother writing a full argument for why dug should be banned. I have seen some decent arguments for and against the ban, but one thing I've noticed is that a lot of people are only thinking about dugtrio with regards to stall and coming to conclusions based on that. Dugtrio can very easily be utilized on any type of team and immediately restrict the opponent straight from team preview, even if it is never sent out in the entire game. Just an example, in my SPL game vs ABR, dugtrio never got sent out, but it still helped me in the game because he had to be careful about leaving in his rain sweepers as rain ended (and if I was good and running jolly, I would be able to outrun his swift swim sweepers even while rain was up), since I could pick them off with some prior damage. Did I ever intend for dugtrio to function like that? Not actively, I just wanted a fast revenge killer that didn't give my opponent room to play around. If someone used volcarona against me with that team, all I had to do was not give it two turns to quiver dance, and dugtrio could come in right after and cleanly remove it from the game. If I used scarf garchomp instead, the volcarona would be able to still switch out and kill something the next time it came back in, and going hard garchomp would risk hp ice and me just losing the next time volcarona had an opportunity to set up. With other mons I can easily cover a variety of opposing mons, but with dugtrio I can ensure that my opponent's target mons will have no counterplay, or that they will have to play differently to avoid getting trapped. And its not even that duggy has just one viable set, it can easily be catered to defeat a myriad of other mons. Dugtrio removes counterplay with its ability, and that's why it is uncompetitive. This isn't a matter of removing the inconvenience dug brings when trying to break stall, its that near-universal trapping doesn't require any skill to utilize effectively and is uncompetitive. Needless to say, Ban Dug.
So you gave us a huge amount of
one example in which Dugtrio was actually a pretty good Pokémon due to its ability, but still not fully sure how is your example good considering a) Rain in general is quite rare; b) Other than Kingdra / Omastar / Kabutops (?) I don't think Dugtrio traps anything else in Rain teams; c) Dugtrio is still useless against things like Tornadus-T and Tapu Koko (with U-turn).
So let's take a look at your match...
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7ou-241051
It has a total of
eleven turns, in which we don't see ABR being forced to switch out a single Rain threat or be careful around them due to "Dugtrio's presence in your team". I mean I'm not saying Dugtrio is bad against ABR's team, I'm just not sure where in this match we actually see Dugtrio being broken? I mean ABR would've lost the exact same way if you had a Pikachu instead of a Dugtrio... maybe he stays in and kills Keldeo, but he'd be forced to switch out eventually anyway. Are you actually using this match to make a point?
There are lots of better, closer matches in which we see great players having to play extremely carefully around Dugtrio and other trappers. It happens all the time in older generations too. In these matches we can see how much skill is required from both parties when playing around trappers.
Now let's get into some different games, some that hopefully will show Dugtrio's role a little bit better:
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7ou-248998 - Dug gets 40% of damage on Kyurem-B and dies.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7ou-249016 - Dug dies without doing anything.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7ou-245175 - Dug dies without doing anything.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7ou-245183 - Dug threatens to kill Thundurus a lot with Stone Edge, but by doing so it gives Bronzong free Stealth Rocks. Dug actually manages to trap a 30% HP Thundurus with Pursuit and it also traps Tyranitar... but then it gives a free SD to Landorus-T as a result and the game ends.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7ou-243868 - Dug doesn't do anything.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7ou-245377 - Dug gets a Toxic off on Rotom-W and dies without doing anything else.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7ou-245369 - Dug traps a Pokémon after it does a lot of damage to the stall team and is at a position where it would die 2 turns afterwards and wouldn't be able to set up in case it switched out regardless.
So in these matches we see how Dugtrio looks like in most games. It actually helped its opponents more than it helped its team in most of them, since it gave free setup opportunities in almost all of them... this is what Dugtrio looks like.
A 0% win ratio in the last 2 weeks of SPL... this is probably the worst "uncompetitive" strategy I have ever seen.
And I mean you wanna tell me we aren't looking at Dugtrio outside of stall? Honestly it looks like you guys aren't looking at Dugtrio outside of stall... all the examples you give are completely biased and none of which discredit what I already said in my post (that Dugtrio's trapping is balanced because it is a very limited Pokémon with a very limited ability too).
Take an actual look at Dugtrio outside of stall: a niche Pokémon that more often than not doesn't offer much to a match. I mean people who actually think this suspect isn't because of stall are either trolling or being completely blind to a plethora of arguments that clearly show why Dugtrio isn't broken.