I like pink mons said:I have to disagree here. You and many people seem to overestimate Mega Sableye in this metagame.
The double defog stall I have been using from the beginning of the SM metagame has clearly showed Mega Sableye is not mandatory on stall (
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7pokebankou-515624213).
Skarmory + Zapdos covers more threats than Mega Sableye + Skarmory / Zapdos, and overall, is more solid and gives better hazard control (not going to argue there, but I could if people want me to).
The only difference is that you don't rely on hazard stacking with double defog (since you end up using Defog no matter the cost), while with Mega Sableye you can actually make use of EH.
I agree with Mega Sableye blocking taunt users such as Gliscor and Mew which would otherwise easily defeat stall, though. But it is not like people actually use them; the simple fact Mega Sableye exists prevents them from being viable.
Back on topic:
What makes Dugtrio
usable is hazard control. Get any kind of EH up versus stall, keep the momentum and this should be an easy win.
Pokemons like Landorus-T with Rock move + SD + SR (which is now standard) completely destroy the so common Mega Sableye + Skarmory core:
Turn 1: Landorus-T uses SD, Skarmory switches in (let's say Skarmory is full life).
Turn 2: Landorus-T uses SR,
If Skarmory uses Defog, repeat turn 2 (SR has more PP than Defog).
If Mega Sableye switches in, you are going to kill something and are in a strong position.
If Skarmory uses Whirlwind, either you're lucky and can directly pressure Skarm, or just repeat the whole process.
If Skarmory uses Counter:
Turn 3: Landorus-T uses SD (it is needed to SD again so Stone Edge does more than 50%). At this point you have won. If Skarmory uses Defog, keep using SR. If it's not, use Continental Crush. You just traded your Landorus-T versus Skarmory and the SR are on field. Skarmory being the only Defog user on the Mega Sableye team, victory is yours.
If Skarmory uses Toxic (and assuming Skarmory has both Toxic + Counter):
This situation is the only one where you have to actually predict something. You will only lose if your opponent wins - say - four 50/50 in a row.
Turn 3: Landorus-T uses SD. If Skarmory does not Defog, you have won. If Skarmory does Defog, it is now all about 50/50s: either Skarmory will use Defog or Counter next turn and you have to decide between Continental Crush and SR. You can try until Toxic kills you.
This strategy always works, and you don't need to predict anything except if it is Toxic + Counter Skarmory.
I do indeed use this Skarmory set, but let's be real I don't think this is standard as people use Spikes Skarmory on the Mega Sableye + Toxapex + Chansey + Clefable + Skarmory + Dugtrio stall.
So if you follow what I have just written, you always win with SD + SR Rockium Landorus-T versus this team. Yet people still manage to lose (!!)... I really think some people do not play versus stall the right way, and this needs to be taken into consideration.
When the #1 threat of the OU metagame (Landorus-T has a usage of 33%) can easily 6-0 the common stall team spammed by everyone, I don't think it is close from being broken !
And I did not even mention the other EH users that can beat stall:
Garchomp with LO / SD / Z Firium
Greninja with Spikes
Marowak-Alola
Shed Shell Heatran (even if that might be retarded)
Seismitoad
Clefable
Necrozma (for the lolz)
While I agree with the first half of the post regarding Msab and double defog, the second half needs to be taken with a rock of salt. If it was really so easy as slapping a rockium-z landot on a team to be able to handle stall 100% of the time, you think maybe everyone might do that? Especially considering half of teams have landot on them anyway?
This looking at things in a vacuum doesn't work. Let's analyze:
"Turn 1: Landorus-T uses SD, Skarmory switches in (let's say Skarmory is full life)."
So you're holding rockium-z, and not earth plate. This means MSab can stay in and wisp you. Goodbye landot.
"If Mega Sableye switches in, you are going to kill something and are in a strong position"
If mega sableye switches in as you rock, that means they got rocks up against you. I wouldn't exactly call this a 'strong position.' Again, msab can proceed to WoW you.
"If Skarmory uses Whirlwind, either you're lucky and can directly pressure Skarm, or just repeat the whole process."
If skarmory uses whirlwind, your momentum is disrupted and stall is doing exactly what it's supposed to: disrupt your momentum until you die.
"At this point you have won. "
"So if you follow what I have just written, you always win with SD + SR Rockium Landorus-T versus this team. Yet people still manage to lose (!!).."
Your post really fails to take into account, well, anything and everything involved in an actual live battle against a human. And dugtrio doesn't need a sash in order to pick up crucial kills, it just needs a safe switchin, either via RK or a double. Getting rocks up against stall is NOT an auto-win by any stretch.
about tone
You write from a very 'better-than-thou' perspective, and it makes it harder to stomach things you say, regardless of their validity. In response to my post about stallbreaker tran losing to things on stall, you linked the smogdex pointing to the offensive tran set and said something about my lacking knowledge and refusing to discuss further. In this post you basically tell the entire community that you have the answers none of us could find in the past months. While we all tend to push our arguments a bit forcefully in suspects, there is a certain degree of respect and willingness to listen that you'll find in most all posts in this thread that you should try to live up to.
_____
papai noel said:damn this thread and this suspect are both so bad it actually tilted me to the point where i'm giving a fuck about this lol i really don't want this trash pokémon to be banned
wall of salt
i'm gonna make a really big post explaining some stuff in order:
1) why trapping isn't broken or uncompetitive (it depends on a lot of stuff)
2) why this suspect is the most dumb thing i've ever witnessed in the history of smogon (and i was there when people were defending style in ost)
1)
one of the premier arguments in the ban of dugtrio is arena trap. it's weird that arena trap is so much better in sm than it used to be in other generations, because its effect and utility in the metagame have been pretty much the same since release. let's take a look at that.
(friendly reminder that until bw there's no team preview, which means you can't even play around trapping as proactively as you can in recent generations.)
it seems rather odd to me that for some reason trapping has been considered a competitive strategy for a very long time yet suddenly people started to think about it in a different way after xy. maybe trapping has been broken for all these years and people never stopped to think about it, but that seems a bit unlikely. i've lost several times to volcaronas after dugtrios trapped my heatran. i've also lost a lot to dragons after magnezones killed my skarmory. hell, i've even lost a lot to some special sweepers such as raikou after dugtrios trapped my blissey in adv! why is it that this happens so much in old generations and it is only now being considered this uncompetitive?
my best guess is that trapping has always been a strategy that comes with an unpredictable risk/reward. if you bring a team with dugtrio + volcarona and your opponent doesn't bring anything that dugtrio can trap, you're essentially stuck with 5 pokémon. that pretty much sums why dugtrio and magnezone aren't broken: they're extremely situational.
with that said, it pretty much convinces me already that trapping in itself isn't a problem; it's the extent of it. that's why some clauses in previous generations exist (like misdreavus with mean look + perish song + hypnosis) and some trapping abilities have been straight banned. what puts you in a risky position before every match when using magnezone or dugtrio only happens because they're both very limited pokémon. that is why a pokémon such as mega gengar is completely broken in every tier he's in: because he can have a huge impact in nearly every match due to the extent of his trapping and his overall strength in movepool, typing and stats without having any drawbacks. dugtrio can only trap a handful of pokémon and relies on focus sash to do so almost every time. it's also so weak it offers free set up opportunities for pokémon that are extremely common in the tier. if something like mega gengar was released in bw ou i guarantee you it'd be used in every single team, because it wouldn't have any cost to it and the reward would be almost always very positive.
if you think dugtrio itself is broken for doing almost exactly what it has done since release then i say go ahead and vote to ban him from ou. i think it's important to note that some players actually think dugtrio should be banned in adv for reasons that are similar to the ones being said about his place in sm (difference is it's the actual reason in adv, it's not in sm). it is a fact that dugtrio is more relevant in these tiers than it is in bw / dpp, but i still don't think that's enough to justify a ban.
2)
we can now enter the topic that explains "well then if dugtrio isn't broken, why is it being suspected in the first place?". the reason behind this is something that i explained in my first post, but i will extend in this one: people don't like playing against stall and whatever they can do to weaken it will be done. it's ironic because dugtrio is actually pretty good into stall as it traps chansey and has a decent chance of trapping toxapex, but i guess it's much better in stall than against it in the current metagame as you pretty much don't lose anything by adding dugtrio into your stall team.
moving on, the reason behind this suspect is the fact that dugtrio coupled with stall actually makes a very strong core that turns pokémon into quite a matchup-reliant game. if you have a good matchup with stall you can win nearly every game unless you fuck up terribly, which means it doesn't take much skill to do.
does that mean dugtrio should be suspected? no. of course not. maybe it should be suspected later on, but it actually bothers me so much that in a metagame with so many broken things the second suspect is this. this proves why our suspect system is so flawed: we essentially ban strategies / pokémon we simply don't like facing, it doesn't really matter wether they're broken or not. there's no actual reason to suspect dugtrio before a list of at least 10 pokémon in the tier right now other than the fact that facing stall with it is frustrating as hell, because dugtrio was never suspected before and it never would've been if not paired with such a strong defensive core such as this one in sm. it's pathetic how much threats like mega metagross, tapu lele, pheromosa and greninja limit your teambuilding (much more than dugtrio) and it's bizarre that people would rather have them allowed than dugtrio.
it's really easy to create an argument that runs away from the actual reason why dugtrio is being banned. it's happening because of stall, and that is fucked up to say the least. banning something because we don't like facing it is pretty much recognizing we're not a competitive community, since we should ban pokémon based on their strength in the tier. it's really sad that we're gonna see a pokémon that has been really good and fun to watch for 4 generations be banned because of one playstyle, and it's even more sad to see that our tiering system is being organized like this.
also like i said before, later on there is going to be a mega sableye suspect anyway because i'm sure people will continue to lose to stall. if you don't believe me, just take a look at some spl replays where people used dugtrio stall. you'll see that most people who lost used teams that couldn't break stall regardless of dugtrio.
this is post is actually so long i'm just gonna make a tl;dr here and if you feel compelled by my thought process you go ahead and read the book that is above you:
- dugtrio does the same thing in previous gens but it traps more relevant stuff now (still less stuff than what it traps in adv though);
- dugtrio isn't broken in a tier where mega metagross, greninja, tapu lele, pheromosa and a lot of other things are;
- dugtrio is being banned because of stall;
- banning dugtrio proves our tiering system is silly;
Ok i will respond to the original post.
papai noel said:why is it that this happens so much in old generations and it is only now being considered this uncompetitive?
my best guess is that trapping has always been a strategy that comes with an unpredictable risk/reward."
I talked about this in earlier posts, but the reason why I think it's just now being considered so uncompetitive is that it works so well with current top-tier threats that typically only need 1 poke removed in order to run through the rest of the team. This issue hasn't been so exacerbated in the past because the
quantity and
power of threats in early gens was simply fewer and lower than it is now. I believe this issue to be entirely connected to power creep. Mons like Tapu Lele, Magearna, and Mega-Meta can wreck teams once that heatran/toxapex/chansey is removed. And it's not even the defending player's fault, because you can only account for so many things in the teambuilder with 6 slots. It's normal to only have 1 solid answer on your team to big threat XYZ, it's not bad teambuilding.
So the reason I think dugtrio is a problem now is that it makes the matchup issues we have even worse. The non-dugtrio player has to play really carefully, and sometimes make otherwise very bad plays because the
threat of dugtrio coming in to remove that one mon is so great, bc you quite possibly just lose once they got rid of it. These issues will only continue to grow as inevitable power creep and newmons come in every couple years. We're all treading on new ground here, and this thing will come to a head at some point in the future where something drastic needs to be done (that is, assuming GF keeps going the way they're going), but to me it seems that getting rid of dugtrio would be the most efficient stop-gap to make our current meta more enjoyable and less matchup-dependant.
I will grant that this is not a perfect solution. Show me one, and I will gladly hop on board.
Regarding MSab, no doubt there is a connection between the two, in that duggy gets to keep its sash as long as msab is alive. But MSab isn't an issue, it's not particularly hard to kill and can be handled very easily by some mons, which also happen to be the same mons that dug traps and kills. People look at this as, 'dugtrio and stall were fine before msab, now post-msab it's broken.' But this is another case where correlation != causality. MSab joining the meta wasn't the only shift that occurred at the time, lots of things changed as it was a mid-generation shift. I won't pretend to be able to analyze everything that changed with the release of lopunite or metagrossite and how that changed viability of certain things, but it's worth considering that the post-msab meta was not shaped just by sablenite.
papai noel said:"there's no actual reason to suspect dugtrio before a list of at least 10 pokémon in the tier right now other than the fact that facing stall with it is frustrating as hell, because dugtrio was never suspected before and it never would've been if not paired with such a strong defensive core such as this one in sm. it's pathetic how much threats like mega metagross, tapu lele, pheromosa and greninja limit your teambuilding (much more than dugtrio) and it's bizarre that people would rather have them allowed than dugtrio."
Sure, fair point that there are other things that also deserve our attention right now. But I don't think it's really so bad to test dug first. I mean, we've known what it does for generations, so we can form much more solid ideas of it than we can of other new pokes that we haven't even fully explored. I'm happy OU council decided to let tapu lele and pheromosa and the gang hang out for a while longer, because these are threats that we actually have not had time to fully adapt to or come to understand in a settled meta.
Also, dugtrio is largely unrelated to these threats. It doesn't reliably kill ninja or phero or mega-meta (although it does trap some of their checks/counters). So I don't fell like we need to wait on that part of the meta to settle while we look at dugtrio.
edit: for readability