Blackdrakon30 said:I personally find Haze extremely overwhelming on Tomohawk and think it is unhealthy for the metagame. Heck, it doesn't really even need Reflect to invalidate half the potential setup sweepers in CAP. It's as bad as Chansey when it comes to beating an entire category of attacker. I have to agree with pretty much everything DrapionSwing said. I realize Tomohawk's concept was centered around affecting momentum and whatnot, but look at it this way: Do we really want a CAP that can erase almost all the opponent's hard-earned momentum instantly? The enemy obtained momentum and used it to set up. It seems kind of stupid that you can wipe out a turn that would have gotten the opponent the game, and the sacrifice of a bit of health which can be healed back the next turn. Sure the enemy technically comes out with the momentum when you use Haze, but it would have been much more valuable to keep the boost. And guess what? If the opponent kills Tomohawk after it uses Haze, the player who sacked Tomohawk actually comes out with the momentum which is just exceedingly stupid. Overall I think that this invalidation of many setup sweepers due to Haze Tomohawk is unhealthy and unnatural within the metagame, and makes teambuilding become lazy because as soon as they need a way to beat setup sweepers, many players instantly think "Hey, time to add Haze Tomohawk!"
However, I don't honestly want to go overboard with the changes. I personally believe Tomohawk should run a DryPass pivot set, Spinner set, Stealth Rock, set, and maybe a few other utility/tank options. I don't believe that it should be having a 100% guaranteed way to demolish the enemy's statistics. The main problem is that I think Haze coupled with Prankster is too good of an option. I realize this is a bit polljump-ish, but we could consider removing Haze in lieu for Clear Smog, which lets it remove stat changes from many Pokemon still, but focuses on slower ones rather than the likes of Keldeo. But we need to tread carefully regardless of what we do. I'd rather underkill and leave it with Haze than completely demolish Tomo's roles.
Okay first things first, Tomohawk has 8 billion roles and options, changing haze will not completely demolish anything.
Do you believe Haze Tomohawk is healthy for the metagame? Why or why not?
No, absolutely not. To me, Haze really oversteps the boundary of stealing momentum, into as I've said before, saving games. Losing Tomohawk to stop a sweep, not counter it or to beat the sweeper, but to stop it, is an extremely powerful and unhealthy tool that no other pokemon in the game has, for good reason. Haze in Tomohawk's movepool also makes the set extremely over centralized, and in my opinion, saturates his usage (by that I mean its so good, that it becomes extremely common, and thats a bit silly for a mon that has as many options as Tomohawk has).
Now to address what other people have said.
HeaLnDeaL said:Having one good priority Hazer is a fantastic for the metagame because of the huge prevalence of stat boosters. What's more, Tomohawk can often stop the boosts but loses to the targets 1v1, making it a balanced move. It doesn't just stop anything and everything without a cost and the cost is even sometimes Tomohawk's own life. Haze is not a get out of jail free card with no risks as some people have suggested; the risks are very real once you realize that the main targets for Haze Hawk have STAB or powerful coverage that deal with Tomohawk
In several cases, with examples such as Mega Gyarados or Mega Scizor, Tomohawk can stop a sweep with no fear whatsoever, and of course in other cases has to sacrifice it's life to get the job done. However, the key to this is to realize, losing Tomohawk to prevent losing to a sweeper, is very much a trade in your favor. Do not look at the theoretical "6 mons vs 5 mons" with Tomohawk having died, look at the actual implications of its death. It may be dead, but if you have a chance to win after it has hazed the sweeper, thats much better than just losing outright, and that in itself, should not happen.
Deck Knight mentioned psyshock, and that it hits Crucibelle a little harder. A) I dont really support this move, I don't see the point of taking away coverage just to add things back.
B) Calculations
0 SpA Tomohawk Hidden Power Ground vs. 4 HP / 0 SpD Crucibelle-Mega: 160-192 (45.1 - 54.2%) -- 44.1% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Tomohawk Psyshock vs. 4 HP / 0 Def Crucibelle-Mega: 166-196 (46.8 - 55.3%) -- 74.2% chance to 2HKO
It quite literally does a "little more" but if thats the reasoning, I see no point
cbrevan said:Furthermore, Tomohawk alone isn't enough to completely stop a setup sweeper. It still takes careful planning and playing on the Tomohawk user's part to ensure that the one chance that Haze Tomohawk gives them to get back into the game is enough to win because Haze does not directly deal with the issue at hand, which is the Pokemon threatening to blow past its team. Compared to other reliable ways at prevent a sweep, such as a fast Scarfer, Haze is arguably less efficient because it leaves the mon behind, but is more useful for slower teams that appreciate the blanket check. In effect, Tomohawk is a balancing force against setup sweepers that may not be a problem on their own, but combined they can lead to a more matchup dependent metagame. Overall, I believe Haze Tomohawk is a healthy, if a bit centralizing, aspect of the metagame because it helps keep the metagame from polarizing behind offense and stall by allowing balance teams a way to reliably halt most setup sweepers.
- Tomohawk alone can stop a sweep, it however does not guarantee a counter to that sweeper
- I do agree with Cbrevan here, it does take careful planning to use hazehawk, but anyone can do that if they have the skill. "All i have to do is haze and make sure I have a wincon when my Tomohawk dies."
- While yes a scarfer can kill the mon, no one scarfer can stop all sweepers. Hazehawk can stop these sweepers, and again notice the stop.
- If Haze is removed from Tomohawk's arsenal, the metagame will not polarize. The obvious example of course, whether or not anyone wants to actually consider it valid, is OU. The priority reset button does not exist there, and it is not polarized behind any particular playstyle.
So that's basically where I stand. There's generally a lot of back and forth on Hazehawk, which should really speak volumes for itself. I look forward to seeing what other arguments can be made to justify haze.