We're giving this a fresh start again since
NOVED is no longer running the VR thread and there's still some cleaning up that needs to be done. First off we have
chemcoop and
Solerme joining the VR council! They were part of the council during the previous vote but it was never made clear before, welcome guys! Second, we did take a look at the previous nominations in the last thread and voted on those, these changes are reflected in the current VR and I'll be posting our votes so you can see exactly why we did or didn't move something, with explanations if any were given. This list is by no means definitive so if you have anything to nominate then do so by all means.
With that said here are the votes for the previous round of nominations:
Mega Charizard Y: A -> A+
Hide
cant say: A+
chemcoop: agree; this thing just torches half the meta immediately and then flame charges to outspeed and HP Ice/fire moves most of the rest of the meta
DragonWhale: it wasnt A+ already?
NOVED: A+
Psynergy: Definitely move up, there aren't many Fire resists that can afford to take a Solar Beam right after switching into Sun-boosted Fire moves. The fact that we're seeing more Stealth Rock for stuff like this is a strong indicator of how threatening Charizard is, no reason for this to be below Mega Charizard X.
Solerme: A+
Theorymon: A+
Mega Charizard X: A+ -> A
Hide
cant say: A
chemcoop: disagree; if you don't have a game plan vs. X, you will be swept or at least torn apart by this thing. Way too much of a monster to drop to A.
DragonWhale: A+
NOVED: disagree, i think zard x is a+ strong. it can take games just as well as zard y too imo.
Psynergy: Keep in A+, this thing is still insane and it will break down teams that aren't properly prepared for it. It's like a Salamence that isn't cheesed by HP Ice and has burn immunity, which can be even more dangerous than Salamence for some teams. If I'm honest I usually find it easier to cover Salamence than Mega Charizard X, Fire/Dragon is just that good even with Tapu Fini around.
Solerme: i'm with noved on this, i definitely think that CharX deserves a place in A+. It can change games if manages to go +1 (even without), also it has cool moves such as roost and WoW. It's probably not the strongest A+, but it's still worth a place there.
Theorymon: Don't agree to this, I think Mega Charizard X is just as good as Y. In fact, I feel that part of the reason why Mega Charizard Y deserves A+ is because of Mega Charizard X: Since you don't know which Charizard you'll be facing, a misprediction can screw you over.
Suicune: A -> A-
Hide
cant say: A-
chemcoop: agree; a bit too passive in a high paced meta - taunters like gyara can stop the CM lefties variant and electric/misty stop chesto resto. Also the presence of strong special attackers like Char Y and Koko put a lot of pressure on it. AV Mirror Coat variants are the most viable rn imo, but it's still too niche to give it A.
DragonWhale: A-
NOVED: agree, cunes bulk just isnt as necessary this gen like it used to be, too passive.
Psynergy: I love using Suicune but I find it hard to put this on a team that wouldn't prefer having Tapu Fini in its place. Passive Pokemon took a huge hit this gen and Suicune struggles even more with finding times to set up with Calm Mind, while Tapu Fini handles most of the same things that Suicune can and more. Suicune is still a great Pokemon on teams that don't want that Poison weakness and it's still a solid CM user, it's just not quite as strong as it used to be.
Solerme: A-
Theorymon: Sure, Tapu Fini tends to be a better pick for a lot of teams, but Suicune still has enough niches to remain in A-.
Rotom-H: A- -> B+
Hide
cant say: A-
chemcoop: disagree; Sp.D Rotom-H is probably the best answer in existence to Char Y, Fini, Ferro cores and really only greninja is the only common water that can outspeed this thing and feel comfortable hitting it with a water move. The abundance of SR also hurts this little guy, but I think it's strong enough and checking mence/zard y teams to stay at A-
DragonWhale: B+
NOVED: kinda iffy, rotom-h is def way more useful i think, as far as rotoms go. but i feel like rotoms are just kinda underwhelming.
Psynergy: I think Rotom-H is the better Rotom but I think there's just better Fire-types and better Electric-types to choose from. Overheat as its only Fire STAB is still not great even with Firium Z to help out, and its bulk is just not good enough especially with Talonflame being dead. It's a cool Rotom but I don't think this belongs in A- either, move this down.
Solerme: A-
Theorymon: Sure, I find them harder to place on teams lately.
Rotom-W: A- -> B+
Hide
cant say: B+
chemcoop: agree; not as much viability with so many strong special attackers - electrium koko just bops this thing for example, and so does zard y iirc.
DragonWhale: B+
NOVED: agree, lots of special attackers this gen made rotoms life tougher
Psynergy: Same deal as Rotom-H, this thing is even worse off since Electric/Water is just not a great defensive typing in this meta, and it's not strong enough without Choice Specs or a Z-Move which has obvious flaws of making it rather frail while not being very fast. It still has a useful niche but I find it difficult to fit this on a team these days.
Solerme: not 100% sure about this, but i'm good with B+.
Theorymon: B+
Garchomp: S -> A+
Hide
cant say: A+
chemcoop: agree; rip the king. I think AV/sash landog has surpassed it in doing ground type things like setting rocks and dishing out EQs. Still has the ability to act as a zard/volc/mence counter with a scarf set, but all in all has lost the invincibility and utility it had in oras. Honestly, I don't understand how it is still #6 in usage - I literally never see it on cart or ps
DragonWhale: A+
NOVED: yeah, with lando everywhere, mimi everywhere, fairies in general everywhere, chomp doesnt feel that great. at least not S rank great
Psynergy: Honestly still think this is S tier worthy just because it's still just as versatile as before, but it's hard to deny the drop in usage and the competition it has as a splashable Pokemon. Dragon/Ground is also not as dominant of a type combination as it used to be with stuff like Celesteela and Tapu Fini around, but it's still capable of filling so many roles and can easily fit the trump card role on a team. I don't want this to drop from S, but based on everyone else's votes it might be time.
Solerme: rip the king, but yes.
Theorymon: I still like Garchomp a lot... but I think A+ is a better fit for it due to the rise of Mimikyu and Landorus-T and such.
Mega Kangaskhan: A -> A-
Hide
cant say: A-
chemcoop: disagree; too bulky, too fast, too good of move pool still
DragonWhale: maybe
NOVED: disagree, i think mega kang is still solid enough for A. its insane coverage and bulk makes it tough to beat for certain teams.
Psynergy: I think Kangaskhan has definitely taken enough of a hit to justify this drop. It's still an excellent Mega but I've seen so many games where the damage is not as impressive as I'd want it to be, even at +2. It's got the movepool to cover so much but the nerf hits it too much for my liking. Kang's usage keeps on falling too, it's only barely edging into top 30 at this point.
Solerme: i'm kinda 50/50 on this.
Theorymon: Not a fan of this since I think Mega Kangaskhan is still one of the better bulky attackers out there.
Azumarill: A- -> B+
Hide
cant say: B+
chemcoop: agree; even z-BD is pretty meh with lele blocking priority and stuff like ferro walling it and koko blowing it up in 1 hit.
DragonWhale: B+
NOVED: agree, azu is kinda meh.
Psynergy: Azumarill is good but also not. Honestly can't see myself using this much, it's so much more difficult to set up on stuff and Tapu Lele just kills its primary sweeping tool. It's not a bad Pokemon in the current meta but it also doesn't really stand out all that much. As a Blaziken check it's also outclassed by Tapu Fini which doesn't take nearly 50% switching into High Jump Kick. Definitely drop to B+.
Solerme: B+
Theorymon: Sure, I think Tapu Fini and Primarina are usually the better Water / Fairy mons, and Tapu Lele screws up the Belly Drum set pretty hard.
Cresselia: A- -> A
Hide
cant say: A
chemcoop: disagree; cress is more viable than in earlier SM seasons with both hera and mawile available, but rise in fast taunt usage/z-moves mean it can't take as many hits. Plus cress is the biggest definition of set-up fodder for mimi.
DragonWhale: A-
NOVED: disagree, dont think this thing is that great. insane bulk isnt needed this gen. same reason i think cune isnt as good anymore. too passive and super bulk isnt a necessity with pbond nerfed.
Psynergy: I'm a fan of Cresselia but I don't think it's good enough for A, it has the Suicune problem of being too passive and Thunder Wave being nerfed makes it less effective than it used to be. Aegislash is still around and now we have Mimikyu and Z-Moves making its job tougher. It's still a cool Lele check and has awesome bulk and utility for Trick Room Megas but I don't think it's prominent enough to be A.
Solerme: A
Theorymon: Pretty neutral on this. I guess we could put it in the same place as Suicune since its passive, but I'm leaning a bit towards an upgrade because I think Lunar Dance and Trick Room put Cresselia above Suicune now a days.
Nihilego: B+ -> A-
Hide
cant say: A-
chemcoop: agree; strong anti-meta pick that can clean up weakened teams late game. scarf = zard killa, which is all important rn.
DragonWhale: A-
NOVED: yeah, this thing is super good at taking shit out with the scarf set.
Psynergy: Definitely one of the better UBs, I can't say I see this thing enough but I've liked it every time I've used it. The STAB combination has glaring weaknesses but with a great Speed tier and often overlooked special bulk it's not as hard to switch in as it might look. Great revenge killer and a neat Stealth Rock setter, and being a special Rock-type with Poison STAB is a very useful niche.
Solerme: i agree for mainly one reason: it can stop some of the A+ mons pretty easily.
Theorymon: Hell yeah, Nihileglo can screw up a lot of common mons like the Charizards, so this has my vote!
Alolan Marowak: B+ -> B
Hide
cant say: B
chemcoop: disagree; only because it is mish mish and should go to B- or C once we get it set up. B is still too high lol
DragonWhale: B
NOVED: agree, this thing sucks.
Psynergy: This probably isn't even B now that I think about it, honestly should be as low as B- but lower than that might be too harsh. It has a niche as a strong Trick Room attacker that isn't a Mega but it's not very bulky so it still takes a lot of damage switching into stuff that isn't resisted. The Lightning Rod niche is cool but there's better options if all you need is the Electric immunity. Still an ok Pokemon but it's not really a stand-out choice.
Solerme: yeah definitely, might even be B-.
Theorymon: Honestly I'd go even lower and put it to B-. It's usable, but post bank had made it much more niche in the singles world imo.
Xurkitree: B -> B-
Hide
cant say: B-
chemcoop: agree; needs too much support to set up z-hypno, the only viable set imo, and even then it can get countered by any decently fast scarf user.
DragonWhale: B
NOVED: B-
Psynergy: Yeah there's way better Electric-types, Tail Glow is cool since it makes heavy bulk sets an option and it's a potentially dangerous Choice Scarf user, but that Speed tier sucks and it needs a lot of investment to be any bit bulky. Z-Hypnosis is also awful, never use this.
Solerme: B-
Theorymon: Totally, hell I'd argue that C+ is ok for Xurkitree too. It's not a very consistent Pokemon sadly.
Mimikyu: A+ -> S
Hide
cant say: S
chemcoop: disagree; mimikyu is really good, but lacks the physical bulk, speed, and/or raw power to make it S like chomper back in the day.
DragonWhale: S
NOVED: disagree, i think mimikyu is great but i dont think its s rank good. and ive used this a lot, both the SD sets and some of the curse sets. i just dont see this thing as a meta running powerhouse. its just a nice, splashable mon. not s material imo
Psynergy: Nah this isn't S tier, and that's not my Mimikyu skepticism speaking. It's very splashable and blanket checks a lot of stuff but it doesn't really excel at any one role. It needs the Z-Move and Swords Dance to be remotely threatening offensively, and utility sets suffer from wanting more moveslots but not being able to use them without giving up necessary STAB moves. It's super splashable and has a broken ability but if Garchomp isn't S for being splashable I don't think Mimikyu is either.
Solerme: Definitely S. Mimikyu is the new chomp in this gen.
Theorymon: This one is tough, since Mimikyu isn't on the level of say... Garchomp or Mega Kangaskhan's reign from last gen. However, its so splashable but I don't really mind if we bump it up regardless.
Volcarona: A -> A+
Hide
cant say: A+
chemcoop: disagree; can still sweep teams, but 4x rock weakness means SR can easily turn a 2hko into an ohko. unlike zard y, which also has a 4x SR weakness, volc doesn't carry a portable choice specs with it, so it often needs a set-up turn to blow stuff away whereas zard just starts clicking attack buttons.
DragonWhale: A+
NOVED: bit iffy on if this is really A+ good but its def a threatening mon, im ok with A+.
Psynergy: I'm inclined to say yes but I'm going to say no to this one. Volcarona is almost Blaziken tier in how versatile it can be but it can't passively boost its Speed and has awful physical bulk. Fire/Bug isn't exactly amazing this gen especially with Cresselia falling out of favor a bit, and while it has strong coverage options it needs a Quiver Dance to make use of them effectively. Still an awesome Pokemon but I don't think it's quite on the level of Blaziken or Charizard Y.
Solerme: A+
Theorymon: Totally, this is the other big reason to run Stealth Rock imo!
Mega Metagross: A- -> A
Hide
cant say: A
chemcoop: agree; solid mon, dual punch is godly with electric terrain.
DragonWhale: A
NOVED: yeah this things solid.
Psynergy: Yeah why didn't we do this sooner? Metagross is fantastic and the increased viability of Thunder Punch makes it more dangerous. It can't cover everything at once but with that bulk and Speed that doesn't always matter until it's too late for the opponent to do anything about it. Its also a cool Lele check which is huge these days.
Solerme: A
Theorymon: With the rise of double punch, Mega Metagross is much more unpredictable than it used to be, so I'm for this!
Zapdos: B+ -> A-
Hide
cant say: A-
chemcoop: has a great role as probably the best mence counter in the game and solid coverage to take on "switch-ins" like ferrothorn and landog too.
DragonWhale: A-
NOVED: sure, not super crazy about this bird but a- isnt that high either. dont really mind where this goes
Psynergy: Zapdos isn't what it was last gen but it's still an excellent defensive Pokemon that benefits from its biggest competition in Thundurus being nerfed. It has great utility for offensive teams and its movepool lets it chunk away at a lot of threats even without much investment, but I can't agree with it being any higher than A- either. It's a great mon but it's not as easy to fit onto a team as I'd like it to be.
Solerme: A-
Theorymon: Not really sure since I barely see Zapdos. I think B+ is a fine place for it however.
Excadrill: A -> A+
Hide
cant say: A+
chemcoop: disagree; too much intimidate and/or non-grounded mons. scarf mold breaker is cool, sand is cool, but both are rather predictable in team preview and can be played around reasonably easily.
DragonWhale: A
NOVED: nah, sand dependant and even then it can be stopped. lando-t is rising like all hell. A is good, i dont see this as A+ solid.
Psynergy: Everyone else has covered it, great sand sweeper but there's too much Landorus-T around. It's an easy stomper against unprepared teams but most solid teams can play around it fairly well. Scarf Mold Breaker is really cool for Mimikyu but that can also be played around, this is fine in A.
Solerme: It's a solid antimeta call, but A is fine for it imo
Theorymon: Think this should stay at A, too many Landorus-T and Mega Charizard Y imo.
Breloom: A- -> A
Hide
cant say: A
chemcoop: disagree; too predictable, spore spam gets stopped by electric/misty terrain, and too slow to just sweep. once its sash goes, it's dead. Despite that, still has a lot of utility and can open up things for a sweeper later. A is good for this guy.
DragonWhale: A
NOVED: nah, spores amazing but A+ is a crazy jump for a slow and predictable thing. i'd be okay with A tho.
Psynergy: I made a typo here while listing the noms, this should actually say A and not A+ but I'm not totally convinced it should be A either. It's super annoying though and even with Terrain around that's only an issue if they have Koko or Fini, and in those cases Breloom usually forces them to bring it which can be abused. I can get behind A for this but I'm still not 100% convinced.
Solerme: i'm good with Loom in A
Theorymon: I think bumping it up to A is better. Breloom has proven it can deal with terrain abuse, but its speed is still a big problem to overcome.
Mega Heracross: Unranked -> B+/A-/A
Hide
cant say: think Hera is maybe only B but wouldn't argue against B+
chemcoop: A- is solid. Loses to common mons like both zards and mence outside of TR and needs too much support to bring out its full potential to be A. Under TR though, this thing is hard to stop and good skill link coverage means it can OHKO/2HKO most things.
DragonWhale: A-
NOVED: im cool with A-. nothing switches in on this thing and it can tear in TR.
Psynergy: I think Heracross is fine in B+ but no higher than A- just because there's a ton of threats that Heracross hates dealing with this gen. It completely stomps on stall and few things like switching into it, but it needs the team support to work well, whether it's Trick Room or Thunder Wave support. I think A- is fair though, it has the usage to back it up and Skill Link utility is always excellent.
Solerme: This is a hard one, i can say that it's not B+, but i'm not sure about A either. I'd say A- for now
Theorymon: I think A is a good place for Mega Heracross right now, it's pretty good but things gotta settle a bit imo!
Changes:
Mega Charizard Y moves from A to A+
Suicune moves from A to A-
Rotom-H and Rotom-W move from A- to B+
Garchomp moves from S to A+
Azumarill moves from A- to B+
Nihilego moves from B+ to A-
Alolan Marowak moves from B+ to B-
Xurkitruee moves from B to B-
Volcarona moves from A to A+
Mega Metagross moves from A- to A
Zapdos moves from B+ to A-
Breloom moves from A- to A
Mega Heracross moves from UR to A-